Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

Posts

Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

#1

Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

Dan Manturi

>I have a PC ROS (right angle 5") and a DeWalt ROS (Palm model, 5"), but have seen the Festool models in action with the ROTEX action. I do not do woodworking commercially. Is this puppy that much of an improvement? I hear raves about them and no doubt they are durable. The tools I have are pretty good quality.

Comments?

Thanks.

Dan M.

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

#2

Different animals *LINK*

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Five-inch palm sanders are to the Festool RO150E Rotex as a cordless screwdriver is to a hammer drill. Not to stretch the point too much, I'd keep the PC if it still is running smoothly, and, if you need a much heavier duty sander for aggressive action, then consider the Rotex. The Rotex is a precision tool, but it is rather heavy and it vibrates a bit because of the bevel gearing. That said, you can calm it down by unlocking the freewheeling feature and turning down the variable speed control. Still, if you had to use it all day on vertical surfaces, you'd be wishing you still had your little pad sander.

The link is to a comparison chart we put together for CWB in '99. You will need MSExcel to open the chart. There are some newcomers since this chart was compiled, including the Ridgid 6" dual-function sander (made by Metabo, IINM) and a few others that might enter the equation for you, depending on your budget. Also, remember that the prices in the chart are 8 years old. :-)

Ellis


Random Orbit Sander chart

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

#3

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hello Dan,

I don't have the Festool, but I do have both the 5" DeWalt and P+C RO sanders. I favor the one P+C I have left from the pair of P+C's I used for quite some time. One was lousey, and the survivor is excellent. I had a very lousey Bosch also. When I decided I needed another ROS, I bought the Ridgid which I consider outstanding. And, I imagine you could buy several Ridgid ROS for the price of one Festool. If I ever have to replace the DeWalt or the P+C, I'll buy a 6" Ridgid.

George

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

#4

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

Jesse in New Mexico

>Hey Dan,

Do you need a new sander? Only you can answer that. I have a few Festool sanders and one 5 inch PC sander (sold or gave away the others). I always reach for the Festool first. Its quieter, less vibration, and way less dust. The efficient dust control is not only better for your health, it makes your work better and faster by letting you sand wood instead of dust. The paper lasts a lot longer, too. As soon as I have used up the last of my 5 inch paper, that PC puppy goes on cragslist or in the trash. By the way, a 6 inch sander has about 50% more area than a 5 incher (28.3 sq in vs. 19.6).

The Festool 150/3 costs about twice ($270) what HD sells the 6 inch ridgid for $129.

The ROTEX is a different animal altogether. You would probably need a RIDGID angle grinder to get the same performance.

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

#5

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

David Yoho

>Dan, I've got the same PC ROS and have always liked it... until I got the 6-inch Rotex. As John said, it's much better mainly due to the extremely efficient dust collection, and less vibration to your hands. However, as Ellis pointed out, its weight makes sanding vertical surfaces for any length of time a chore.

I find myself reaching for and using my two Festool sanders almost exclusively now but I still use my two palm sanders and the PC ROS for various sanding tasks when the job warrants it.

It's totally your decision whether you NEED a new sander. If your budget can stand it, you won't be disappointed with the Rotex. If your current duo of sanders gets the job done, maybe you don't really need one. The big difference with the Rotex and dust vac is the dust you won't be breathing and dispersing into your shop.

David

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

#6

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

Dan Manturi

>Got valuable info. I do not need a super heavy duty sander, but one that will produce a fine finish consistently and less swirl marks. The word on the Rotex action is that if you want aggressive you get it but it also produces a very consistent surface ( of course, operator skill is a large factor!). I was being a little cute in my question - I need a new sander like I need a new router, but I have some work to do where the quality is important. And some of it is vertical work, but not a large amount.'

Ellis, I'l check out ha data source and thanks to all. Seems a lot of folks like the Festool. The are a quantum leap in cost...

Dan M

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

#7

I was wondering, Dan...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>...if you were referring to Festool's 6" non-Rotex sanders. They have a handle grip and are available with a 3mm or a 5mm orbit. They take the same paper as the Rotex, but they don't cut as aggressively and they are considerably lighter and smoother. Cost less too.

These are closer equivalents to the pad sander family you are moving up from. Maybe this is yet another little budget item for you. :-)

Ellis

PS Dan is the president of the Lehigh Valley Woodworker's Guild. He puts out a heckuva newsletter.

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

#8

Re: I was wondering, Dan...

Dan Manturi

>Ellis,

Thanks for the Kudos on the newsletter. I do try and sometimes have fun with it, as you know from some of my onel liners and captions. We do not have a president - we run by steering committee - everyone does their part, just FYI. Do not want the other steering committee folks to start spreading rumors about shenanigans in the Oval Office! We miss seeing you - assume you are busy and busy is a good thing.

Actually, you have seen my posts about my stepson's house. Mahogany plank walls in miving /dining room which came out great (Thanks to all who made suggestions) and a mahogany kitchen. I was looking at removing all cabinet doors (flat plywood, thick veneer) and buying a performax to freshen them up. Someone suggested the Festool, and I thought the ROTEX action was smoother. Apparently it is more aggressive, and I may be better off to just use the old PC right angle on them. I can get a used performax 22-44 pro (Angelo had one), but the thing is huge. It may be worth the garage shop space, though, as I plan on re-doing my kitchen - after I do my stepson's.

I think i will pass on the Festool for now. The PC right angle and the DeWalt palm ROS will be fine for the non removable parts. I may even do OK with them on the doors I remove, but the Performax may be a better option after all.

Regards and thanks again,

Dan Manturi

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

#9

Re: I was wondering, Dan... *LINK*

Dan Manturi

>I did not serve myself well in my response to your newsletter kudos. Miving room? Is that a new phrase for Mahogany Living room?

By the way, more typos are available in the newsletters at the attached URL if you (forum members) have some slack time. I do not promise technical accuracy on woodworking issues, just a re-cap of what was presented. If any of my one liners or captions offend you, I guess they just do.

Regards,

Dan manturi


http://www.lvwwg.com

Re: Random Orbit Sander - do I need a new one?

#10

Re: I was wondering, Dan...

David Yoho

>Ahh... this sounds like the Festool 150/3 6-inch ROS I have. As Bob Marino indicated when I talked to him before purchasing, this sander is truly a finishing sander. Heck, even with an 80-grit disk applied, it still isn't very aggressive! It's a real joy to use. It's not fast but it leaves a fine finished surface and I still have the benefit of the great dust collection.

David