English dovetail
jeff
>Hi all
I heard a comment about an English Dovetai joint.
Any idea what is is?
I never heard of it.
Jeff
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
English dovetail
jeff
>Hi all
I heard a comment about an English Dovetai joint.
Any idea what is is?
I never heard of it.
Jeff
You use them in your jewelry box construction
Curly Smith
>The difference between French and English dovetails:
Everything you ever wanted to know about Drawer Construction
Re: English dovetail
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>English dovetails historically tend to have wide tails and wide pins. Continental dovetails like German tend to have wide tails and narrow pins. Northern European have fine tails and pins. Not a hard fast rule but the traditions continued even to this country.
Out here in Utah the Pioneers came from Europe, not the eastern US and brought their traditions with them. Looking at drawers on old pieces it is easy to pin down the country of origin of the maker by his dovetails and other subtle construction techniques common in those areas.
Stephen
Re: You use them in your jewelry box construction
Sgian Dubh
>The only problem with the description at your link Curly is that it's all pure marketing spin and, er, well, inaccurate cobblers. They're trying to make something special out of two types of very common machine cut joints.
The first, their 'English' dovetail is a common or garden machine cut corner dovetail. The second, their so-called 'French' dovetail is just a sliding dovetail.
To be honest I've no idea what an 'English' dovetail is, and I was born in Great Britain, trained and qualified as a furniture maker in Great Britain, work as furniture maker, and teach the subject to students, all also in Great Britain. None of the British text books on joinery I've ever read describe an 'English' dovetail as far as I can rememebr. I've never described to anyone, not even my students, a dovetail as being an 'English' dovetail.
Perhaps Stephen gave the right descriptions for the variations in dovetail patterns to have come out of various parts of Europe at different times, but I can't say. We just mark and cut dovetails much the same way we've been cutting them for decades, and probably centuries, ha, ha. Slainte.
Of course not.. wher does bacon come from?
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>"...To be honest I've no idea what an 'English' dovetail is, and I was born in Great Britain, trained and qualified as a furniture maker in Great Britain, work as furniture maker, and teach the subject to students, all also in Great Britain. None of the British text books on joinery I've ever read describe an 'English' dovetail as far as I can rememebr....."
Wouldn't a "English Dovetail" be called a "Dovetail" in England?
I lived in Canada for nearly 30 years and enjoyed bacon for breakfast on occasion. 10 years ago I moved down here to the USA and discovered something called "Canadian Bacon". Funny, it looked and tasted just like the "Bacon" I ate as a kid.
I discoverd that all those years I was eating "Canadian Bacon" and didn't even realize it. Jeeze, I thought it was just "Bacon".
Happy Woodworking!
Re: Of course not.. wher does bacon come from?
Sgian Dubh
>That might be the case Mark, but I also don't recognise Stephen's description of English dovetails, "English dovetails historically tend to have wide tails and wide pins."
I recognise the wide tails bit in the description, but I don't recognise the wide pins bit. In the British tradition I was trained in those are what we in the trade simply know as a carcase dovetail configuration for structural work or, if used on show parts such as drawers, they're just crude.
All the premium quality British antiques-- 1740's or so onwards, I've worked on over the decades had very fine pins on drawer sides. The narrow end of the pin is typically no more than a saw kerf thick.
Antique or old drawer dovetails with wide'ish tails and quite chunky or wide pins are, as a rule, found only on country style or lesser quality British furniture in my experience.
I truly don't understand the definition Stephen gave. It doesn't match the training, experience, and understanding of my countries furniture making history and the traditions of construction I inherited from the people that taught me. Slainte.
It's not just called bacon Mark.
HC Sakman
>It's called "Back Bacon", here at least in the wet coast.
Chico...
Hmmm, I know exactly the opposite.
HC Sakman
>As far as I know, "English" dovetails supposed to have wider tails and 6~7 degree very narrow pins. God only knows what it's exactly. In North America, people use some European country's name as an adjective to emphesize something. Also the continent's name itself is used, simply "Euro" to make something more important (or "different" which can be justifed.) than it actually is.
Chico...
Definitions
Curly Smith
>Sorry to disagree but the terms "English Dovetail" and "French Dovetail" actually have meaning in the pretentious world of high-end furniture. Go ahead, do some shopping and listen to a salesman prattle on about English and French dovetails or find somebody with a copy of drawer construction standards from the Architectural Woodwork Institute (AWI).
Or, try this:
Dovetail Joint
"This form of locking joint looks similar to an outspread bird�s tail, hence the name. One board has a flared extension which fits into a matching flared cavity in the adjoining board. Use of a single dovetail is called a French Dovetail, and multiple joints in the same corner are called an English Dovetail. Better drawers often use a multi-dovetail because of its strong holding power. (See illustration 4)"
Re: Definitions
Sgian Dubh
>The joinery primer you pointed me to Curly has at least one howling error drawn, therefore I assume the author of the text has a rather limited understanding of joinery.
The big error is the drawing of the mortice and tenon in which the form illustrated is inherently weak. It would seldom be used by any furniture maker that understands construction in anything other than the rarest circumstances.
What Carol Giusti described in that text as a French dovetail is a framing or construction dovetail in British terminology. It's sometimes used as drawn on wide and thin stock, e.g., about 2" X 1". I've also seen that form of a single dovetail on the front end of a drawer side in fairly crudely made furniture, usually early stuff from perhaps the early 17th., century or some later country items. To me, when it was used that way in a drawer side it's just crude, not French.
That form is also used to connect rails to the tops of legs or carcase sides in cabinets. In another version it's used to form T junctions in framing members where it's known as a T halving dovetail.
I agree with you that the text linked to is disingenuous and carries just enough air of authority that it might impress a lay reader. It illustrates your point about advertisers hijacking terms and words to 'big-up' something and the twaddle that goes with it very well. Slainte.
Just Guessing - London pattern dovetail = fine pin
Andrew F in Australia
>HI Richard/All,
Just a guess, but it could be the fine dovetails I've seen called London Pattern dovetails on the internet. There's no such formal description, I believe, just the internet name.
Cheers,
Andrew
l knew the French......
Barry Irby
>had claimed Toast, Fries, Salad Dressing, But Dovetails? This is too much! There will be war, I tell you! Grab your dovetail saws and chisles and head out for the trenches. Next they will claim Champaign. Oh, wait they do. And claim there is some sort of treaty about it that us unruly Americans did not sign onto. Asti Spumonti anyone?
And this from someone who lives in a country that has the initials US but claims to be America. Talk about your "big-up".
Craftsman Dovetails
Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI
>I once had shop owner describe an antique A&C desk as genuine as it had "hand-made" "Craftsman" dovetails. I give him a little lecture in Craftsman construction methods, including the use of machine-cut dovetails. I pointed out that his logic was correct-the dovetails supported his contention that it was a genuine piece-but that they were clearly not hand-cut, nor should they be.
When I get back....
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>Thanks Chico!
This summer when I get BACK to CANADA, I'll make sure I get to eat some CANADIAN BACK BACON.
Of course, I'll have to ask my mom for "bacon" otherwise she won't know what I'm talking about.
Happy Woodworking!
What about poor, confused Chico?
Charles R. Smith from Victoria
>And what shall we say to poor Chico to end his confusion? In his family, 'turkey' refers to a special homeland rather than a festive meal. :)
Re: English dovetail
albertabob
>The English dovetail is what most of us consider the half blind dove.
The French dovetail uses dovetail slots in the carcass to effect the joints.
In doing it this way you would sacrifice up to 30% of the usable drawer space as each slot must have a runner outside the tail to support it.
Bob
That's right Charles.... Little Trivia
HC Sakman
>Hi Charles!
Yes, everybody eats my previous home country!
Here's the trivia...
Although North America has its own wild turkey, in the old world, domestic turkey (as well as peacock) was originated from India, which is called "Hindistan" in Turkish. As Turkey is being the crossroads in between East & West, the bird turkey was brought to Turkey from India and it is called "Hindi" which means "Indian" or "from India". When the Europeans asked the name of the bird that's the answer they got and then they named the bird "turkey" because it came from Turkey.
That's how the story goes.
Chico...
Just helping out...
HC Sakman
>...to an old Canuck by reminding what things are called up here! ;-)
Happy Baconing! ;-)
Chico....
Well....
HC Sakman
>...the damn things have been crafted since the Egyptians! Perhaps we call them that!
I don't think country affix. means anything clear. We already named the variations of dovetails in many different ways.
Chico...
Re: Well....
albertabob
>You missed the point entirely.
It's dogs and cats this time not variations.
Do a google.
Bob
Actually...
HC Sakman
>I meant to reply to the original post Bob.
Chico...
Re: it's O.K. Here's the answer for both *LINK*
albertabob
>There is a real difference in the joinery albeit the names are some what irrelevant.
no harm- no foul.
I am sorry Bob...
HC Sakman
>I know better than that description. It's multi spindle cut machined dovetails and sliding dovetails. That page is a marketing gimmick info, far from what we're talking about. Sgian up there already replied to somebody who posted the same link.
Chico...
Re: I am sorry Bob...
albertabob
>You could be right Chico.
All I know about the terms is waht I can read here and elsewhere.
I thought I was helping .. but maybe not.
Bob