From a painter...
Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN
>You need to determine what you spend vs. your target rental market.
I paint about 30 or so rental units per year, most of those in about 2 weeks every August as I live near a college town. (Our company paints 150-200 rental units total per year). Those units that go mostly to students get less attention than those that are in the quieter parts of town.
First off, we don't have time to be washing walls, it's just not generally necessary, even with cigarette smoke. We scrape any nasty stuff off, if there are cobwebs, a quick broom around the ceiling and down the corners will take care of that. Then we use a no-shrink, lightweight spackle to fill anything up to about the size of a quarter, scraping the spackle flush with the wall--no sanding. Anything larger or excessive (like dart boards) incurs an extra charge, and we'll use 5- or 20-minute setting-type joint compound for those (we'll sand those). Next, we'll use rattle-cans of Zinsser BIN (white pigmented shellac, or I've switched to clear shellac--no visible overspray) for any ink or water stains, or any other stain that we think might not cover in 2 coats. In units with painted trim, we try to get the landlord to go with one paint on everything, as it's about half the time to paint (and half the cost). Generally, that is an egg-shell. Depending on how good you want the walls to look, you could take your roller and go over all the spackle spots first, then roll everything (better, not as quick), or paint everything, then touch-up the spackle spots with the roller (look at the wall at a low angle to look for "dry" spots, looking toward a light source is best). Most of the time, we roll first, then cut-in becuase many of the units don't get fully painted, so we don't paint more than we have to, and we charge accordingly.
As for paint, an off-white eggshell is best. Cleanable, and it doesn't look diry as quick as a straight white. Even better is a factory-mixed color (we use a lot of Glidden Ultra-Hide Antique White Eggshell). We roll with 18"x3/4" rollers and cut with 4" brushes. If the paint leaves lots of spatter on your arms, it's junk, get a better paint. If we come across a ceiling that needs to be painted and hasn't been before, we spray it. Most ceilings are stomped drywall mud here, we don't want those chunks breaking off in our roller. If they're already painted, the peaks don't tend to break off as easily, so they can be rolled if necessary. For a 4 BR unit, I figure on about 3-4 hours (no ceilings), and if it's not too bad, and I have to get it done yesterday, it can be done in as little as 2 hours. I should note that we use the same paint every year, and have quite a few landlords using the same paint.
Okay, I've rambled on enough. Let me know if you have any questions. I just think too many people "overdo" painting, making it more work than they need to (but those are the ones that often keep us in business!) It's not rocket science.
Jason