Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Motor trouble follow-up

Posts

Motor trouble follow-up

#1

Motor trouble follow-up

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>A couple weeks ago I posted a message about my air compressor quitting while filling the tank. I did a number of checks and here's where I stand now:

- pressure switch is still on

- power goes to the motor

- motor remains absolutely silent, no humming or anything

- I had both capacitors (start and run) checked, and they are up to spec

- I checked for continuity at the capacitors leads (before putting the capacitors back on), and I get continuity in both cases, so it seems the windings are intact

I would tend to think that the starting switch is not of an issue, since the motor quit while running. The only item left to check is the thermal protection switch, which I am kind of reluctant to do as it involves opening the motor. But then again the other option would be to take the motor off the compressor and bring it to a shop, which I'd like to avoid if possible. anything I should be concerned about when removing the motor end cap?

Any comments/suggestions are welcome...

TIA,

DC

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#2

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Dennis, something doesn't ring true. If the thermal breaker in the motor is open you should not see continuity at the motor leads. If there is continuity at the motor leads and your sure you are getting power there, the motor should "hum" & should start if you manually spin the shaft with the power applied - even if the start switch is malfunctioning. One other possibility. It is possible the start (pressure) switch is still the problem. It may be the "voltage" you are seeing is dropping out when a load is applied (bad contacts in the start switch). If you can hook everything up normally and add your meter test leads to the circuit so you are measuring the voltage at the motor with it hooked up. This will tell you if the motor load is causing the voltage to disappear. Another method would be to hook up a cord to the motor directly and plug it in the wall - be sure all other wires are disconnected. This will pin it down to the motor or pressure switch circuit.

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#3

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

Keith Newton

>I don't put much faith in continuity readings for this kind of trouble-shooting. You can get a reading with a bad contact that won't carry enough volts, amps to run.

I would disconnect the motor, and turn the power on, then check the volts on each line at the breaker, then before the switch, then behind the contacts, then at the motor connections. If you find a drop at any of those places, you can isolate the problem by process of elimination.

It is easy to open a motor. Just take the four long bolts that connect the ends out, then hold the motor shaft vertical, and bump the end of the shaft down on a soft-wood board. The end will just pop right off while the field windings and bottom ends slide down the shaft.

But before you take it apart, I would connect it to another power source. If it runs, you will know the problem is not the motor.

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#4

I'd do what Keith said

Curly Smith

>"But before you take it apart, I would connect it to another power source. If it runs, you will know the problem is not the motor."

Disconnect all of the other stuff and connect the motor leads to a power cord. If it starts you've ruled out a lot of potential problems. If it doesn't start, you've ruled out a lot of potential problems.

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#5

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I'm not testing the continuity at the motor leads, but rather at the capacitor leads themselves, which I believe are beyond the thermal switch in the circuit. At the motor leads themselves I get no continuity, but because of the capacitors in the circuit I don't think I would get any.

Clear as mud? :-)

DC

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#6

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Keith, I worked in a couple of motor repair shops for a year or so when I was a lad. You are correct in that it is easy to dismantle (most) motors. However, at both facilities where I was trained, one of the first things we did was to mark both ends of the motor and bell housings with a punch at the motor bell housing seam. we put one mark on the drive end / bell housing and two marks on the other end / bell housing. This served as alignment marks when reassembling. I did not "drive off" the end caps by hitting the end of the shaft, we used sharp chisels to remove the end bells (inserted at the seam against the bells) so as not to damage the shaft. We also carefully removed the spacer washers from both ends of the shafts and bearings (sometimes the spacers come out on the shaft - other times stick to the bearings), these were marked as to location. These steps are necessary to insure the motor is reassembled in the correct orientation and that the rotor / armature is centered in the field. If you rotate the end bells you take a chance of misaligning the bearings. If it turns out that the motor is the culprit, I personally would not recommend Dennis disassemble the motor - The cost of having the motor problem analyzed and repaired - replacing the thermal breaker etc. would probably not be that expensive. Without any experience Dennis may end up damaging the motor - and would probably not have the parts to repair it anyhow. A competent motor repair shop will check the caps, windings, bearings, starting switch, centrifugal actuator, ensure that everything is functioning properly (test it under full load with a dynamotor) and warranty the work.

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#7

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>In any single phase capacitor start motors the run winding is directly across the input lines at all times. In capacitor run motors the "run" winding is in parallel with the capacitor - still directly across the line. If you don't get continuity at the L1 & L2 connections you either have a faulty thermal switch or an open run winding.

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#8

Re: Dennis - I sent an email

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I sent you a typical schematic for a capacitor start motor and a capacitor start / run motor. These may make it a little easier to see what / how you need to measure the continuity to determine your problem.

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#9

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

Barry Irby

>Does the motor feel hot when it quits? I have a Radial Arm saw that does fine if I use it in short bursts, but if I use it in long runs, it over heats and cuts off. The motor feels hot when it does it.

Try blowing out the motor. I blow mine out occasionally and am sometimes surprised at the amount of dust that comes out. That might help the motor run cooler. the dirt may be causing some friction and actually creating heat and it may be acting as insulation, retaining the heat.

In my case, I try not to use the saw for long runs. I assume this is an age/wear related problem or that the thermal overload protector has become too sensitive. (the saw is forty years old.) When I want to run it for a long time, I sometimes ice the motor down with bags of ice to help cool it. Not sure it works.

I have taken the ends off a number of motors and reassembled them without problems. I did it to change the bearings and in one case to remove an errant screw I had managed to drop into a motor through the vent slots.

OTOH, I would have though you would not have to disassemble the motor to change out the thermal over load switch. I guess it depends on where it is located.

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#10

Found the culprit?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Thanks Larry for the e-mail..

I took the end bell off the motor (wasn't too hard).

Here's a question that might pinpoint the problem: should I get continuity through the thermal protection switch in normal circumstances, i.e. switch not tripped? I get none...

Another thing that surprises me is that there is only one lead going through that switch and one going out to the motor. Shouldn't there be two, given that it's a 230V motor? I'll check Larry's layouts, maybe that'll answer my question...

Thnx again,

DC

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#11

Re: Found the culprit?

Curly Smith

>There should only be one lead to the thermal switch. The thermal switch is a fuse and you connect a fuse across one leg.

And yes, you should read continuity. If you don't then the fuse is blown.

I'd take it to a motor shop for repair as there may be something else wrong.

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#12

Re: Found the culprit?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Dennis - First there is only one line that goes to the thermal breaker. (Remember you only have 220 volt across the two (2) hot lines - 120 volt is from either "hot Line" to the neutral / ground). Second the thermal breaker is shot if your not getting continuity across it. I would remove it, purchase a new one and replace it. They do go bad without any other motor problem. If it hasn't been "kicking out" often, you probably don't have any other issues. - I hope you did mark the motor as I suggested as it may affect the bearing operation if it is rotated when re-assembled.

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#13

Problem solved...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>However I'm not sure I'm too fond of the solution...

I called the electrical shop that tested my capacitors, and they said that they could get me a replacement thermal overload switch, but it could take a week to get it.

This afternoon I dropped my tablesaw to get repaired at a service center (another story), and while there, since I was in an industrial district I asked if there was any electrical shop nearby. I was directed to a compressor shop, the guy told me that they don't stock electrical supplies, and directed me to the motor shop they use, which was nearby.

Once I got there, I showed the gentleman my switch, and right away he cut me off saying that they don't carry that kind of switch, because they're too unreliable. Either they break down for no reason, or they don't do the job they're supposed to do, and let motors overheat. He suggested that I forget about that switch, and just connect the two wires together. If I really wanted thermal protection, he suggested something else that I didn't understand, but in essence he told me that I would be no worse off without that switch.

So I did connect the two wires together, closed the bell end (I didn't pick on the mark thing Larry, fortunately I didn't run into problems), and put the power back on. It works! The motor quit while filling the tank when the problem occured, it picked up where it was, filled the tank to its capacity, and the pressure switch worked normally.

So I'm back in business. I guess the morale of this story is that I shouldn't drive the compressor too hard like I did when the problem occured, and respect the duty cycle. In any case, I don't leave the power on to the compressor when I'm not around.

Thanks for all the help,

DC

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#14

Re: Problem solved...

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Denis,

You must be living under a cloud if both the compressor and table saw crumped out simultaneously. It always gave me a lift when things began to ravel back up to where they were. It sounds as though the motor shop gave you a fine bubble gum fix. I use duct tape. Either way, the price is right and the results are long lasting. Glad you feel better.

George

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#15

Interesting....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I hope that it was because the thermal protection switch was inferior and failed. If it burnt out and did it's job stopping the motor becaue the motor was legitamately overheating because of anohter problem, now it won't be there next time to do it again. I'd keep a close eye on it.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Motor trouble follow-up

#16

Re: Problem solved...Glad you got it fixed.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Dennis, I'm not too surprised. I have seen bad thermal switches. In reality if the switch was mounted on the end bell - it is not a true thermal switch. The true thermal switch is located in the windings and actually heats up with the windings. The switch you removed is a bi-metal combination load and thermal switch. This type switch will generate its own heat due to carrying the current for the motor windings, as the ambient temperature rises (due to the motor getting warm or just due to the room temperature) it starts to "bend" the bi-metal current carrier / contact holder. Sometimes the contacts will arc a little contributing to the heat. When the current is too high / and /or the temperature is high the breaker opens. If you really want to protect your motor, install a socket and a fusetron time delay fuse of the proper size. IMHO they provide the best protection for a motor available. You can buy a fuse holder that fits a "handy box" and install it on the compressor, interrupting either line into the motor.