Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

interior walnut beams; how dry?

Posts

interior walnut beams; how dry?

#1

interior walnut beams; how dry?

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>I have someone asking me to custom saw some walnut 8x8s (and some smaller sizes too) for a home interior. He wants the material to be at least air dry ~12%, which is logical based upon everything we all know about using dry wood. But since the wood is now in log form, this would take months or years to get that dry even using my solar kiln (which dries plenty fast this time of year).

So before I go back to him, what MC do you think is really necessary here? If these are decorative beams with little attached that might be affected by some shrinkage (and remember walnut is quite stable and would dry without much movement), do I really even need to remove all the free water? Knowing it would take forever to remove the free water 4 inches deep, can I just get the surface free water out and call these usable for the purpose I describe? I need some ammo to convince him I can deliver this in a reasonable time; it would be a nice order.

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

#2

frought with peril

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>This all has the sound of a bad idea (on buyers part) that is going to not end well. An 8 x 8 is going to check, probably severely so, and may twist and turn upon throughly drying, which will take years under even favorable conditions. But as far as mechanical integrity, I doubt that any log framed barn was ever build from anything except partially air dried beams. I think you would be wise to offer to sell the beams from the saw and have the buyer responsible from there forward. If they install the beams and turn on the heat causing them to dry so fast that they twist off the wall, it will not be your problem.

Personal experience: I sawed 6 x 6 and 4 x 8 hemlock beams for an outside porch. Hemlock dries faster than walnut and it tends to be the most stable beams one can dry. I air dried it under favorable conditions for 6 months and it still was loaded with water. The material dried fairly straight, as hemlock tends to do, but the 6 x 6's developed 1/4" wide cracks after a year or do. The 4 x 8 dried well as they did not have the pith in them. All the drying was outdoors so the drying rate was moderate. I expect things would not have gone as well with forced drying like in a heated room.

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

#3

Re: frought with peril

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I agree with Bill. A twisting 8X8 can be a powerful force. Better to hire a good trim carpenter who can make a stable beam with a wrapped walnut cladding look like a solid piece.

Tom

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

#4

No cause for alarm

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Go for it. Explain the perils (in writing if necessary) and let the customer make the decision.

Clint

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

#5

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

Rick Christopherson

>I don't think I would try to deliver these at a higher moisture content. The dryer the wood is, the more stable it will be, even if it re-absorbs moisture once in place. As long as you have the solar kiln, I recommend bringing the moisture content down to 8% before squaring the log. Even if it re-absorbes moisture, it will still be more stable than if you install it at the higher MC.

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

#6

time to dry?

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>How long do you think it would take to dry a 8 x 8 from green to 8% ? I can only guess. To keep from developing drying stress in the piece I would speculate the drying rate might need to be less than 1 % MC per day. It takes about 30 days to dry 4/4 fresh sawn oak in a dehumidificaiton kiln. Extrapolate to an 8 x 8..........

The price of even 16/4 lumber is staggering because it takes so long to dry it and the downgrade in drying is so great.

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

#7

The capabilities for twisting alone make me

Howard In Toronto

>what the value to the client is....

Will it be being able to brag that they're solid?

Are they from trees on a special proprty?

8x8s in any species are pretty heavy.

I'd show your client these responses.

Then I'd price out beams that are actually three-sided MDF or plywood boxes with wrapped sop-made veneer using those trees.

Howard

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

#8

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

Jim Dillon

>Tom,

In keeping with the suggestions by Thomas and Howard, Fine Homebuilding (September 2006, No. 181, pp 58-63) had a nice article on building box beam ceilings using various styles of intersections, running electrical wires etc. Don't know exactly what your client had in mind, but maybe you can convince him that this approach might work as well. As an aside, the 8 x 8 approach sure sounds like a waste of a beautiful hardwood, not to mention the drying difficulties mentioned by Bill and others. If you are interested in that article and can't get it, I can sure make a copy and send it to you. Good luck.

Jim

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

#9

he backed off

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>I told him he was asking the near-impossible, especially with time short, and he retreated and is rethinking how to build what he wants. I offered alternatives as discussed here.

Thanks to all for your feedback; it was most useful and appreciated.

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

#10

On the contrary....

Jesse in New Mexico

>Hey Tom,

I know its too late and besides that the advice above was good.

However, out here in the southwest we put green pine wood in houses all the time. The expectation is that it will check, twist, and shrink. We caulk the gaps for a couple of years, and then it stabilizes.

All in what you expect, I suspect your customer would not have been happy with checked stock.

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

#11

Re: interior walnut beams; how dry?

janderr

>how about you tell those folks the 8x8"s will crack an let me have em. e-mail me if you have any more walnut and you think getting the stock to asheville, nc is easy.