Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

which glue

Posts

which glue

#1

which glue

Paul R

>I need to glue up some laminated curved arms out of birch for a Morris Chair i am making for my daughter. (plans in Wood Mag.) What would be the best type of glue for this I have heard problems of creep with reg woodworkers yellow glue . Any thoughts???

Re: which glue

#2

Re: which glue

David Yoho

>I like Titebond liquid hide glue. It has the added advantage of a little longer open time and cleans up easily.

David

Re: which glue

#3

Re: which glue

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>And liquid hide glue or hot hide glue do not suffer from creep. It is largely transparent to stains and finishes, does not cause swarf to clog up tools and as David said easy to clean up and it washes out of your clothes.

Stephen Shepherd

why anyone uses anything else is beyond me.

Re: which glue

#4

liquid hide glue ?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I've been a convert to the liquid hide glue I can get locally, usually Franklin's stuff. However, in your experience, are there brands of liquid hide glue that are better?

For instance, the Old Brown Glue made by Patrick Edwards seems on its face to be a cut better, but I don't have direct experience with it.

Any thoughts?

Re: which glue

#5

Re: liquid hide glue ?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I do not want to endorse one product over another but as far as I am concerned Patrick's Old Brown Glue is the best liquid hide glue in the world! I must get more. It is great stuff but in the cold weather it needs to be warmed to get it out of the bottle. What was left of my 5 gallon bucket of Franklin hide glue froze solid this winter. Didn't seem to effect the glue.

If you use a lot consider buying 5 gallons, good price and it is always fresh. They only sell it when they make batches so it is always new but some times you have to wait a month or two until they make it up.

Stephen

Re: which glue

#6

Re: which glue

Howard Acheson

>A frequently used adhesive for laminating is a urea formaldehyde adhesive like DAP/Weldwood Plastic Resin. It's slow setting and has no creep. It's also more long lasting than hide glues which deteriorate over time.

Re: which glue

#7

Re: which glue - long lasting???

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Howard, I'm sure you are far more of an expert than I - but I would have to disagree with your statement that Hide glue is not long lasting from everything I have researched - a Casket removed from King Tut's tomb was still intact after 2,000 years - assembled with Hide glue. The proof will be if the current offerings of adhesives are still holding wood together after a few centuries. I use hide glue for many reasons. It has an amazing track record, it is easy to clean up, it stains well, it is reversible. I'm rather surprised you have the opinion that it deteriorates. Most if not all of the most valuable antiques in the world were assembled using hide glue and still seem to be solid. Why do you have the dislike of this glue?

Re: which glue

#8

Outlast 8000 years

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>An artifact in the middle east was found to be glued together with hide glue and is over 8000 years old. How long have they had the others 50-60 Years?

Stephen

Re: which glue

#9

Though I too am a big fan of hide glue...

John in New Mexico

>bear in mind that a desert environment will preserve lots of things for thousands of years. Now if that same 8000 year old piece were found in southeast asia, you'd have a point.

John

Re: which glue

#10

Re: Though I too am a big fan of hide glue...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>John,

You are correct the earliest examples are in arid enviorns. There are examples in Europe of furniture 400-500 years old and conditions are not ideal there.

I'll take 500 years, still better record than others. And hide glue out performs the others in every aspect, modern glues were introduced to 'replace' hide glue because the new glues are cheaper. I believe that to be true. Why wouldn't you use the best?

Stephen

Re: which glue

#11

Weldwood or epoxy...

John in NM

>Especially if you haven't done a lot of laminating, the long open time will really save the day. I've seen these done with West System 2 hour and a vacuum bag, super easy if you've got one. Otherwise, its just a question of making a form with matching cauls and having lots of heavy clamps on hand. Hide glue should work, but I've never tried it in this sort of application, so have no advice to offer. I regularly use hot hide glue for joinery, but wouldn't try to use it for thick laminations, because I'm just not that fast clamping it up. Maybe you could hammer veneer the whole thing if the lams are thin enough.

John