Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

"Color" matching your wood.. before staining

Posts

"Color" matching your wood.. before staining

#1

JL

"Color" matching your wood.. before staining

JL

>How many of ya'll color match the wood that you are working with before staining.

As an example - say you are working with red oak. You are going to stain the project. Do you try to closely match the color? Or do you try to use the stain to blend the slightly different shades?

Ditto with maple.

For unstained woods, I alway try to match the colors (or buy a big enough board to complete the project).

Re: "Color" matching your wood.. before staining

#2

Re: "Color" matching your wood.. before staining

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Well, J L, first I match the wood for grain and color as closely as I can. Then I even out the color as best I can.

Re: "Color" matching your wood.. before staining

#3

not a straightforward task

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>One of the perils of attempting to match color is that what ever color you see on a fresh planed piece will not be the color it winds up. Of course there are exceptions, but in general this tendency is true for most species. The most striking example is the green in poplar. Once the sun hits it, it will be brown. The purple shades in walnut that some fancy are similarly fleeting. White maple and ash becomes light brown. Other than the permanent difference one sees between sap wood and heartwood, or color from "mineral stain", wood of a species typically winds up about the same color upon aging. This tendency is especially so in red oak, which is why it is used in furniture more than white oak.

Re: "Color" matching your wood.. before staining

#4

Re: "Color" matching your wood.. before staining

Jesse in New Mexico

>Hey JL,

I agree with the others, not an easy task.

While I'm milling, I pull out some scrap representative of the variety of the boards I'm using - heartwood/sapwood, straight grain/figured, etc. Then I resaw them to make lots of test pieces. I try a few different finishes, usually a combination of stains, dyes, and glazes to blend the varieties together.

Then when I'm selecting which board goes where, I try to make the transitions smooth, e.g. if a board has a sapwood edge, I match it to another sapwood edge.

I'm still surprised each and every time though!

Re: "Color" matching your wood.. before staining

#5

Re: "Color" matching your wood.. before staining

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I also try to match grain first and color second when I am making panels and tops for cabinets and such. Slight color variations tend to be less noticeable, particularly in red oak, when stain is going to be applied. Still If I have a choice, I will use boards of all the same hue and from the same board if I can (Note for Col. George: It should read: "...all of the same hue and same hew..." ). ;)

Lee

Re: "Color" matching your wood.. before staining

#6

Lee Said It All

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havefrtown PA

>Hello JL,

A lot of times it depends on which side of my face I shave first. It depends on so many different things and degrees of differences. Lately, most of my projects are in cherry and have been hewn from the same tree and have a common hue! True. Normally I select for grain pattern first, given slight tonal/color variation. Its difficult sometimes to anticipate how dark/how salmon/how red adjacent boards will become. Should there be tonal variation, I try to balance that when I sequence the boards for glue-up. Rarely use gel or penetrating stain or aniline dye to even up cherry. I have used potassium dichromate and it works very well.

George

George

Re: "Color" matching your wood.. before staining

#7

JL

Re: Thanks all

JL

>

Re: "Color" matching your wood.. before staining

#8

Re: not a straightforward task

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Bill, you are absolutely correct. I have had some interesting results over the years; some were even almost ok. But, it can be done alveit very carefully, . . . much of the time.