Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Hardest wood question

Posts

Hardest wood question

#1

Hardest wood question

Barry Irby

>A young friend of mine is an aspiring drummer. He breaks and wears out a lot of drumsticks. The ones he buys are made of hickory.

Is there anything that woudl make tougher drum sticks? He wers trhoguh them on the edge of the symbols. Obviously he needs to learn better technique, but I have no control over that. But I could turn drum sticks. Any Ideas?

Re: Hardest wood question

#2

JL

Re: Hardest wood question

JL

>Black locust comes to mind. Lignum vitae is a bit expensive. If you want to go for other exotics, how about Brazilian cherry (Jatoba). I've used dogwood for mallets and it has worked fine.

Re: Hardest wood question

#3

Re: Hardest wood question

Barry Irby

>I know nothing about "drumming". I wonder what difference the weight makes? Wonder if there is some sort of tone (?) factor?

If the wood were heavier, would you make the stick thinner?

Dogwood and Brasillian Cherry? Hmmm? I have some locust.

Re: Hardest wood question

#4

Take your pick *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>The problem is the harder the wood the more brittle it is.

Hickory is a good choice, it's what has been used for hammers with success .


Janka Hardness

Re: Hardest wood question

#5

Al alternate suggestion

Derek

>Something to consider, rather than using another type of wood, is to make them differently.

Instead of using lumber which has been prepared the normal modern way, how about using a technique used for chair parts and other parts which need to be very strong for their dimensions - rive them from a blank so that the grain does not exit the "stick" at it's sides?

I'm certainly no expert, but I think green wood is preferred for this. Green wood is certainly easier to turn on a lathe as well.

This would make them MUCH stronger with the same type of wood and dimensions.

Re: Hardest wood question

#6

Send him to a good drumming teacher

Forrest Addy

>Drumsticks are a consumable item among drummers they do have to be replaced. I have a friend who works five nights a week in a rock and roll band. He tells me a pair of sticks last maybe 10 days. Rick is a strong and frenzied drummer. Seems to me if your young friend is useing up stick faster than a pair every 10 sessions it might be possible he's trying to substitute volume for drumming skill.

That's said, there are few woods better suited for drumstick than American hickory. There are many that are harder but more brittle, Many that are as tough but not as durable. Rick tells me that space age materials even graphite/epoxy doesn't hold up as well as hickory and they are vastly more expensive.

So my suggestion is to send the kid to a good drumming coach where he can learn the business so he gets the performance without using up his equipment.

Re: Hardest wood question

#7

Re: Hardest wood question

Falberg saw Co

>You might sometimes want drumsticks of alternative composition to get a different "sound", for specific use with non-traditional percussion instruments(i.e.,timbales), or to minimize bounce-back; but the traditional trap set is designed to be played with oak or hickory sticks shaped like "drumsticks". You could get into custom-shaping drumsticks out of oak or hickory but the cost in time would make it a labor of love, and not economically viable. Commercially available drumsticks are so cheap and of such high quality that I gave up the project of custom turning them long ago when I couldn't find any significant improvement over the existing products. It was fun though. I made a lot of noise. I still have my trap set in the living room and now "jam" with my sons. It sounds like your young friend needs fatter sticks, more microphones, and a mixer.

Shredding sticks is almost as much fun as kicking holes in your bass drum so just go with it and always carry spares. I do.

Re: Hardest wood question

#8

Re: Hardest wood question

Brodie Brickey

>The drummers here know more about drum sticks than I ever will, but if I were purchasing sticks, I'd look for straight running grain. I'm sure that in a commercial operation, they will often miss some turned pieces where the grain hooked a left a quarter of the way down the stick.

Regards,

Brodie

Re: Hardest wood question

#9

Lee Gordon

Re: Hardest wood question

Lee Gordon

>They used to make baseball bats and golf club shafts out of hickory, so I doubt that you're going to find too many choices that are more suitable. But, along those lines, you might consider using the material currently used for baseball bats: northern white ash or hard maple. In fact, if you could get your hands on some broken baseball bats you ought to be able to make mountains of drum sticks out of them.

Re: Hardest wood question

#10

Consider Osage Orange

Craig Daymon

>It's plenty tough and, like Hickory, has a bendable quality, making it more resistant to perpendicular stress. (Was used for bows by the Osage indians.)

This would seem like a good choice to me, but someone else probably has a better understanding of whether it fits the application.

-Craig

Re: Hardest wood question

#11

P.S. Baseball bats were also Osage Orange.

Craig Daymon

>Quite a while ago, but true. Must have weighed a tone!

I think you'll find the maple bats used today also break more frequently than the hickory bats.

Re: Hardest wood question

#12

Re: Hardest wood question

Ray Binnicker

>Persimmon may work. They use it, or at least used to, for golf club heads.

Re: Hardest wood question

#13

Toughness, not hardness

Ellis Walentine, Host

>If this fellow is wearing them out from banging on the cymbals, maybe the first thing to look at is the edges of the cymbals themselves. Maybe a little fine sandpaper would roll the edges a bit and keep them from digging into the wood.

I agree with Forrest that you probably won't find a tougher wood than hickory for this application. Here's a case in point: A friend of mine has a black belt in aikido, the ancient Japanese martial art. They do a lot of fighting with wooden staffs, or "bo" (or "jo"), which are generally 15/16" or 1" in diameter and as tall as the user's shoulder. A lot of the commercial jo sticks are made of Japanese red oak. When they sustain a heavy blow, they tend to splinter as they break. Hickory does not. It has longer fibers than any of the other woods we've tried. Straight-grained pieces require a huge blow to break, and when they do, the wood fibers hang together. This is a critical feature of this type of stick, as the splintered pieces that break apart can become deadly weapons themselves.

Straight-grained blanks are the key, With hickory, you don't really need to rive the blanks to get straight grain, but you can usually tell if the grain runs out a bit, and if it does, the finished drum stick won't hold up to quite as powerful a rim shot as a straighter piece. Harder woods might hold up better against chipping forces, like the edges of cymbals, but they are generally more brittle and may break easier when subjected to heavy-duty rim shots.

Ellis

Re: Hardest wood question

#14

Re: Hardest wood question

Leewhope

>Someone mentioned tropical woods and two that come to mind are basralocus and greenheart. Greenheart would probably be "cooler" though.