Toughness, not hardness
Ellis Walentine, Host
>If this fellow is wearing them out from banging on the cymbals, maybe the first thing to look at is the edges of the cymbals themselves. Maybe a little fine sandpaper would roll the edges a bit and keep them from digging into the wood.
I agree with Forrest that you probably won't find a tougher wood than hickory for this application. Here's a case in point: A friend of mine has a black belt in aikido, the ancient Japanese martial art. They do a lot of fighting with wooden staffs, or "bo" (or "jo"), which are generally 15/16" or 1" in diameter and as tall as the user's shoulder. A lot of the commercial jo sticks are made of Japanese red oak. When they sustain a heavy blow, they tend to splinter as they break. Hickory does not. It has longer fibers than any of the other woods we've tried. Straight-grained pieces require a huge blow to break, and when they do, the wood fibers hang together. This is a critical feature of this type of stick, as the splintered pieces that break apart can become deadly weapons themselves.
Straight-grained blanks are the key, With hickory, you don't really need to rive the blanks to get straight grain, but you can usually tell if the grain runs out a bit, and if it does, the finished drum stick won't hold up to quite as powerful a rim shot as a straighter piece. Harder woods might hold up better against chipping forces, like the edges of cymbals, but they are generally more brittle and may break easier when subjected to heavy-duty rim shots.
Ellis