>I need to make/replace a window sill for a senior citizen in the neighborhood who has one that has rotted in one corner. I'm thinking poplar as I can get it in 8/4. Any suggestions? Another option is to chisel out the rotted area,fill and coat the entire sill with several coats of epoxy that I have leftover from building a canoe.Anyone tried the epoxy method?
>I've done the excavate and fill routine and very satisfied. I used one of the epoxy wood restoration kits - I think most of the epoxy mfgrs have one. Solid epoxy sticks are also available as well as bondo from auto supply. Years ago when I got involved in a house rebuild I came across a quote that I still think is applicable " Remember, you're building a house, not a piano."
>There are a number of good restoration products out there, including Bondo. If you're replacing from scratch, go for mahogany or Spanish cedar or white oak. Cypress would probably do, too.
>I've used wood repair (like bondo for wood) with decent results although not on a sill (probably work better on a sill).
Befor you decide on a method and start spending money, excavate the bad spot and make sure you know what you're dealing with. You may find minor (or major) problems just below the sill and this will let you find the root problem if you haven't already.
>I am a former builder/now a Home Inspector and wood worker. Rotted window sills and brick molding are stock in trade for Home Inspectors. I tend to disagree with those who are suggesting repairs over replacement.
The rot is a living organism and needs wood to eat and water to survive. The part of the wood you can scrape away is the part the rot has already eaten. The living rot is actually in the stained and seemly sound wood that does not scrape away easily. My experience is that patching is a temporary fix. In six months or a year you may find that the rot around the perimeter of the patch has continued and the patch may fall out.
I commonly find patches with the rot expanding around them. This also applies to the ones where people cut away three or four inches of wood and put in a little splice. The Rot may run eighteen inches or two feet into what appears to be sound wood and if you don't cut it away it will continue.
The rot requires four things; wood (food source), water, oxygen, and the right temperature range. If you Perfectly seal up the wood and stop the supply of moisture you might stop the rot, but that is nearly impossible. (At least here in humid south side Virginia.)
If you want to do a patch, I would suggest you go to a boat supply place and talk to them. (Who can believe boats rot?) You may be able to get a kit that includes a Chemical to treat the wood as a preservative that kills the rot. It must soak deeply into the wood. Then a water thin epoxy that will soak in and harden the wood. And then a patching compound like Bondo. Then you provide excellent paint.
Otherwise, I would suggest you replace the entire piece of wood. (That way you know you got all of the rot. Home Depot (I think) carries window sill made of high density foam. Many places carry wooding window sills already milled. Some sills are in at least two pieces. Outer part of the sill is a separate piece and you may be able to replace that. The classic sill material is Ponderosa pine. I would not use poplar, it is probably more prone to rot. Others have suggested better woods that are more decay resistant.
>Thanks for the reality check on rot. When doing repairs or renovations for a customer, I always recommend replacement. But, replacing a sill isn't usually a simple task -- I just replaced a couple on my own house last year with mahogany replacements -- as it involves cutting off the rotted part and grafting a new piece onto the sound wood that remains; or, in the extreme case, digging out all the old sill and slipping a replacement in under the jambs. The windows in my house were installed in 1855, and they are a bear to renovate, so in off years, or when I just don't have the time, budget or patience to fix them right, I confess to taking the easy way out and doing the wood-hardener-body-filler routine.
>Epoxy and Bondo have both been mentioned in this thread.
In my area, Bondo, a polyester resin and filler mix designed for auto body work, is never used because it is porous and will actually attract and hold moisture thus speeding up degration of the surrounding wood.
Epoxy is used (the boat builder's "Get-Rot" is one) as are 2-part urethane resins like Polyall 2000. However, the mistake is often made in trying to apply resin to anything that's not near bone dry. Moisture in the wood will resist penetration of the resin and then the resin sets sealing in the moisture further promoting rot. Usually the piece to be "restored" must be removed, dried to below EMC, and then soaked in resin. It's usually easier to mill and install a new piece of wood.
>Thanks, did not know Bondo was porous and would hold water. Seems counter intuitive. It would cause cars to rust out if it were saturated. Maybe that's why soem body repairmen think putty patches are crap.
>None of the windows being installed today will last 150+ years. Its OK though, neither will the houses.
If I had windows that were that old or were of historic value, I might attempt to patch them or make some sort of preservation repair. I was at Monticello and got to see them working on a beam. In the end it was a few shards of wood encapsulated in epoxy, but since Mr. Jefferson had touched it, it was appropriate.
OTOH, just the other day I saw a house that had been horribly and amateurishly repaired because all the floor joists had rotted. The reason they tried to do it form under the floor was they wanted to preserve the 1960's hardwood flooring. (2 1/4" oak strip flooring). Could have saved thousands of dollars and done a better job by doing it from above. That's probably their next step.
The use of the patch kits is just a little too "high tech" for the repair people I have to follow behind. They don't understand how or why it works or doesn't work and don't care. If they replace the entire piece, I am reasonably sure the new owner (my client) is getting a fresh start.
I once pointed out rotted sills. (they were sort of withered). The seller said there was nothing wrong. I flashed hot and punched a hole in three or four with my finger. The nest day they called for a re-inspection. (???? Yesterday they did not admit or know they were rotted and today they are fixed???, I don't think so.) They had taken a caulking gun and filled the holes with latex caulk and smoothed it with their finger. You could have identified them from the perfect prints.
Every time I see the tell tale ripples of a putty patch or the short blocks or trim, I probe the area around them and unless they are fresh, I often find more rot.
>Like Crocodile Dundee said, You can eat it, but it tastes like $hit!!.
You can use treated yellow pine, but it really looks like crap and does not hold paint well. Even painted it seems to weather away sort of like stone. Just cracks and falls apart.
I resent the loss of lead based paint. They used to dip exterior trim in pentachlorophenol (sp?) and they stopped because they did not want to put the workers in PPE. About the same time they stopped using lead based paint. I suspect the wood is not as "naturally" decay resistant as it once was. (old growth vs second or third growth) Narrow overhangs on houses contribute (or no overhangs at all). The trim on houses built before the ban on lead paint that got even one coat of primer holds up better than the later stuff.
>Keeps out the bugs, but not especially good for a sill. Shrink and deformation in the first year make it questionalbe for use in a window sill that need to maintain a seal for the sash. Plus SYP needs to a good primer to prevent bleed of the chemicals and sap. There are better choices. "Real" mahogony (not Meranti), black locust, cyprus would be my choices.
>Caused by the filler that's added to body up the resin plus the mixing routine folds even more air into the batch with no time for it to work its way out. OK for feathering (junk over a 1/8" thick), but it needs to be well sealed. Mix a chunk, let it set, then put it to a belt sander and look at the sanded surface, looks like a sponge.
>I would respectfully disagree with not using pressure treated SYP. I have a source of kiln dried pressure treated SYP and it is millwork grade lumber at that. The stuff at the big box stores doesn�t even come close to being in the same category. It is hard so it splinters somewhat on cutting and need to be predrilled with pilot holes. It also takes and holds paint extremely well. Also need to use all stainless fasteners. I use it for long term fixes. All those good points however comes with a premium price.
>Years ago shortly after we moved into our present home, I discovered that the frame around the front windows was rotted and looked at ways to fix the window. There was a 4 x 4 picture window involved and two double hung windows. With some help from my father, we removed the front window unt from tthe house, removed the old sill board and two of the side frames. Using PT lumber, we made new pieces that matched the old ones. We painted the pieces as they were ready for assembly, assembled them into teh woindow unit and put it back into the wall. More than 20 years later, LOML and I decided to replace the windows in teh house with new ones for improved energy retention amoung other reasons. When tehy removed the window unit from teh front of the house, the two side frames and sill board will still in perfect condition.
My advise would be to use PT lumber instead of tring to patch teh rotted area. Select the mstraightest grained knot free piece of wood you can find and let it dry in your work shop for at least 3-4 weeks. Then do all your mill work on it, prime paint it before assembly and finish paint it upon installation. If the wood is dry when you apply the first paint, you should have no paint adhesion problems.
Now, here's the tricky part..... you must find the water leak that is the source of the rotting problem. If you don't you run the risk of water doing additional damage to the house framing or sill which will be much harder to repair.
Lots of good advice. I guess I took the easy way out and used an ordinary 2 x 4 of fir to construct the sill (I didn't want to mess with preserved lumber). And the windows were really an odd size to completely replace. I used a portable plane to give the sill some slope and fit better. Then used construction adhesive and long screws to fasten it in place. Followed that with some smaller cypress filler pieces and then Bondo. I doubly primed the sill before the install as well as all the other scraped areas. Then applied a quality oil-based exterior paint. Using Bondo was actually kinda fun. I did nine windows in all. The job isn't perfect, and they may or may not last 50 years (I know I sure won't), but after two years they still look great. Here are a couple of pics of the work in progress. Good luck.
Regarding the porosity of Bondo, I think what one sees are not interconnecting pores, but simply small surface voids due to the mixing process etc. At least I sure hope Bondo isn't porous to water.
>Two distinctly different things that will have a large effect on your theory. I don't use bondo on wood 'cause it won't stick worth a darn, but I never heard that it "attracts" moisture before.
>It'll rot quickly if not kept scrupulously painted.
In your shoes, I'd replace the sill with a decay resistent wood, cheapest probably being western red cedar, unless you live near a mill source of locust or catalpa or something like that. Out here, that stuff costs even more than oak.
Alternatively, there's a resin product that is designed for what you want to do, supposed to be better than regular epoxy (can't remember the name now, but I can find it if you're interested). Pitfalls with this technique are what Barry outlined, and though probably less of a perminent fix, done well it should be a sound repair that would last as long as the original sill.
The basic ingredients in Bondo are about 50% polyester resin and 45% talc, with a little silica powder mixed in and some pigment. Talc's adsorbtive (with a "d") properties have been keeping babies dry for a 100 years or more, because it attracts moisture. Same goes for silica (silica gel desicant is simply a powdered form of the mineral). Mix all of that into the resin, and you've got a compound putty that is cheap, light weight, easily workable, and hardened but non-brittle in use. The mineral body, however, doesn't loose its ability to attract and hold moisture. I didn't say that it was permeable, only hyroscopic, and therefore much slower to release accumulated moisture than the surrounding wood it's applied to fix. Hense, the bondo/wood interface will stay wetter longer as the wood drys and pulls the moisture out of the resin. That wet interface will be especially prone to microscopic growth of mold, mildew, etc., and most likely explains what you see as lousy adhesion.
>But I believe talc is fairly hydrophobic, and acts to prevent outside moisture from reaching the skin when applied before diapering. It also has astringent properties, which if I understand them correctly, cause the skin to shrink, closing pores. Perhaps Wilbur will chime in, as in his field, he probably knows a bit more about it than I. If I had any around, I'd put a drop of water on it to test my theory. May be able to scare some up in the shop later.
Silica gel is not powdered silica (SiO2). It is sinthetically produced amorphous silica that owes its hygroscopic nature to its high surface area. Crystaline silica is not hygrocsopic. I've no idea which they use in bondo, but I'd suspect crystaline silica as its probably cheeper.
For what its worth, I'm not trying to start a p@@@ing match here, just keeping terminology as straight as possible :)
Gee, you got me worried now about Bondo. Maybe I should replace those 5 year old Bondo repaired bird baths that are showing absolutely no signs of deterioration 8-). Granted, they are stone (or something), not wood. I actually think the weak link in all this, from a practical standpoint - and as you implied - is the near impossibility of getting all the rotted wood out; thus it is best to replace entire pieces like the sill - if time, skill and money allow.
The issue of talc is more difficult to discern because we really don't know what Bondo is using (and they make lots of different products). John is right that talc, per se, is highly crystalline and hydroscopic. Having said that, talc is sometimes chemically altered producing what is know as fumed silica. The crystallinity in fumed silica is very, very low. More importantly, it is then used to strengthen the interaction between certain types of polymer chains. So it may be that what talc is in Bondo ends up being rather tightly bonded to the peroxide-catalyzed crosslinked polyester/styrene/divinyl benzene mix (or whatever they are using), rather than just an inert filler.
I guess for now, I will continue to use Bondo for my hacker-style home repairs. If those sills start to fall out, I will then go - with tail between my legs - to using a higher priced spread 8-).
The "Bondo" autobody formula is, by weight, 50% resin, 44% talc, 1% fumed silica, 2% Titanium Dioxide, and 3% glass microspheres.
Not that it's a sponge, mind you. I use it for filling carpenter bee holes and such and it does well where it won't get wet. It should do well against the stone because the base material is impervious and not seasonally expanding and contracting as is a wood interface. If it works for you, that's fine. I'm certainly not suggesting that everybody run out and rip it off their bondo-repaired sills, only passing on what I seen and been told. A friend was going to use it to mend a inset roof balcony floor that was leaking into his garage below. I prevailed upon him to do a full layup fiberglass job. We then duckboarded a deck over that. Been 8 years years and narry a drop gets through.