Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

Posts

O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

#1

O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

Tom Norton

>I need some MP3 assistance ASAP, as I am getting ready to travel.

I downloaded a number of books on CD to Windows Media Player and then synced them to my MP3. No problem.

The other day we deleted the books from Windows Media Player. Tonight we went to add a music CD and it started deleting the Books from the MP3 . These are the ones that were deleted from WMP.

What did we do wrong?

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

#2

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

Tom

>Not sure I understand perfectly, but perhaps the mp3 player is/was full and you tried adding more?

Or, maybe it is a DRM issue (any chance you're using Vista)?

I'm of the opinion that music files can and should be treated as data. Any program that wants to sync, search for licenses, make itself the proprietary owner of a type of file, convert or any number of other things has no business on my pc's. Dragging and dropping is something that everyone learned to do with floppies. It is still the fastest, easiest and least complicated way to transfer data. Proprietary (to the device) programs and 'wizards'are useless, for me at least. I'll step off my soapbox now.

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

#3

Re-reading it...

Tom

>You ripped book cd's to your hard drive in mp3 or wmv (media player defaults to that) format?

You transferred the audio files to the mp3 player and listened to them to verify it?

When you went to add the new music files, did you drag and drop or just use some program that came with the player? If so, "sync" may mean to make the mp3 player mirror your folder on the hard drive. By deleting the books from the folder and then syncing, some program may have understood that to mean you didn't need them anymore. What device and software are you using?

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

#4

Re: Re-reading it...

Tom Norton

>Tom,

The device is a Sandisk e280. As for software. As I am a novice here my computer has Windows XP and I was using WMP 11.

Am I giving you the right info?

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

#5

Why did you delete it from your PC????

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Don't bother to answer that. I think I know why. You probably thought tht you had them on your PC and copied the to your MP3 player so you didn't need then in both places. I normal way to think.

And if you used Windows Explorer to COPY the MP3 files from one device to the other, then you should have had no problem.

But if you "syncronized" the devices using the WMP software or the SanDisk software (which is another good way to do it) then everything was problably fine until you tried to delete the songs from your computer. Then it saw you delete them from the computer and since you synced the devices it would have syncronized the deletions to your MP3 player.

Perhaps not logical to your way of thinking, but definitely logicial in the way "syncronization" is intended to work.

What you need to do (quickly) is undelete the songs from your computer or go and re-rip those CDs and get them back on your computer and then sync your devices to have them back on both devices.

Now, please bear in mind, there are alwyas a half dozen ways to do the same, or almost the same thing on a computer. So I could be wrong in my assessment of the situation. But if you ask "where did you go wrong", it's quite possible that your intent of deleting the songs from one device but leave them on the otehr device is contrary to what the "sync'ing" is going to do.

Hope that helps.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

#6

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

John McGaw

>It is really difficult to tell exactly what might have been going on with your books. But I have some suggestions that might help in the future. I give these as someone who has more gigabytes of audio books than you can possibly imagine. No really, I have more than any sane person could imagine which says something about me I guess.

1. Never store your books in any format other than MP3 -- it is the gold standard of compressed audio formats and every program and player is able to work with it. You can convert them to some other format for loading on your portable player if you must but always keep those MP3s on the computer's hard drive and always back them up like any other data.

2. Books _are_ data and should require no other software to manage. If you have a portable player that demands special software and does not look like just another disk drive when connected to your computer you made a mistake and will probably come to regret it if you don't already.

3. Avoid using any software that indulges in DRM manipulations of your data. You own it, you decide what to do with it. There are dozens of free applications available that don't play fast and loose with your files. I make it a rule to avoid WMP (any version) other than to do a quick playback of a file on the computer. The later the version of WMP the worse its behaviour and the more intrusive its actions.

Just my opinions of course but they are hard-won opinions.

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

#7

ebd

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

ebd

>Do what Mark Goodall said to get back the songs you lost. In order to keep that from happening again there is one other thing you need to do.

1. Start Media PLayer.

2. Left Click on the Tools menu Item.

3. Left click Options from the drop down list.

4. Left click on the Library tab in the window that comes up.

5. Uncheck the item Delete files from computer when deleted from library. (about half way down).

6. Left click OK.

7. Close Media Player.

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

#8

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

Tom Norton

>I think the problem has been solved. I called Sandisk and they walked me through a process. I needed to change my Sync setting from Automatic to Manual. I did need to go to the libray and reload a few books.

Thanks for all your assitance!

Re: O.T.Need some MP#3HELP!

#9

That's not enough

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"...I needed to change my Sync setting from Automatic to Manual..."

That's probably not enough. Because if you sync again, even manually, you're going to loose them again.

The key is to either COPY them and don't use any software thal will syncronize them, or understand the syncronize is not the same as copy. Synconize means make the same on both sides. If you add/change/delete anything on either side, it will do the same on the other side.

Can you guess what COULD happen if you delete them from your MP3 player and then sync with your PC? Yes, if the settings are set in such a way, the syncronization could delete it in both places depending on setting, software, etc.

But don't worry.... you're certainly not the first person to have this sort of thing happen to.

Happy Woodworking!