A few things.... long and hopefully informative...
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>First idea of wrapped verbiage.
Yes, sometimes, depending on the sender's email software and settings, and also the receivers software and settings, long URL links can get cut off and not work as planned (ie, they don't work when you click on the lin ki nthe email). This is why often companies link Amazon and Hallmark will give specific instructions saying if the link doesn't work to copy/paste the link. In this wonderful wide and wild world of the web, you can't count on everyone's email programs to work the same way.
But, big but...... that only applies to super long URL's like this:
http://www.thesharedphotobucket.com/paidsubscribers/a_thru_m/classification_B/group_F/yourwebsitenamehere.index.html
See a problem here? That's a fairly ridiculously long (but unfortunately too common) website address. With a professional and realistic web address of: www.bobthewoodturner.com/index.html the whole idea of a URL not working because it's too long, well is impossible.
If you're talkign about using a button because your website address link is that long, well you have bigger problems that just the "email site to friend" button issue.
So, point #1 is a non issue. And he is either trying to sell his services, or many not ralize what he is talking about.
Now, #2 is a little more complicated. "Send Link to a friend" buttons can be done several ways. Any "email link" button can work a couple of ways. One is that the button can invokce the surfer's email software, let's say Outlook. When they clikc the link, it simply starts up Outlook and prefills a few things in Outlook makig it easy to send. Then the surfer simply takes his friend's email address from his address book, clicks send and Outlook sends the email with the link and it is all done. This isn't the best way to do it because it assumes (not a good things to do) that the surfer has an email program setup on the computer he is using. This is a bad assumption because many people use a web-based email service, like googlemail, or hotmail, or yahoo mail, or may be usign a computer that is not their own. Either way Outlook (or other) is not setup so that kind of button a website is useless.
Another way is to have a button that takes the surfer to a place where they can enter the friends email address and then the web server actually does the sending. This is much more effective beacuse the server sends the email, but the big downside to that is, well, alot of people don't trust "giving" a webserver their friend's email address. With the first method, using Outlook, the webserver never knows your friend's email address. With this second method you give you email address to the server. Well if you fear that the server will collect the email address, your fear is justified. Certainly not all do, but I can tell you about many websites are simply email harvesting services that collect email addresses for spammers and marketers. So there are many places where you wouldn't want to use a "email my site to a friend" button beaucse of that fear.
Certainly, a "email this site to a firned" button will help the percentage of people who simply have no idea about how to copy/paste a address URL link from a browser and use their email to send it to someone. You'd be amazed at how many people have no idea how to do that. A one-click button will help those type of people immessly.
But you can also see how such a button could cause problems and even bee compeltely useless, either becuase the surfer doen't have email setup on that particular computer is happens to be using, or the websurfer doesn't trust the site and doesnt' want to risk placing his friend's email address in a spammer's list.
So there you have it: a compelte non-answer from your's truly ;)
if you want/need to see exaplmes of this, let me know. I do just about all types of web programming and can show you examples of both types of buttons.
The thign is dislike most about how some web programmers operate is that they tell you how things should be done. The truth of the matter is that in many cases with technology, there is no one right answer. In some cases there are definite right and wrogn ways of doing things, but in other's it depends on the situation or the circumstances, and it depends on what the web owner wants.
Happy Woodworking!