Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Square or round...what is your favorite...

Posts

Square or round...what is your favorite...

#1

Square or round...what is your favorite...

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Hey all,

For those of you who have already built your workbenches, why did you choose the shape of dog holes that you did? After putting a chisel into my finger again this weekend, I have decided its finally time for a bench. I have almost everything laid out excspt the dog holes. I can certainly see the advantages and disadvantages of each dog hole type. I am just trying to make up my mind which one I want on my bench.

Thanks in advance,

Rob Hix

Re: Square or round...what is your favorite...

#2

Re: Square or round...what is your favorite...

john lucas

>Rob I prefer round holes. I have the Lee Valley bench dogs and they are flat on one side so you have the option of round or flat for clamping purposes. Being able to twist the dog so the flat side faces irregular shaped pieces is also handy. I also use Holdfasts which have a round shank so I can position them any direction I want.

Re: Square or round...what is your favorite...

#3

JL

Re: Square or round...what is your favorite...

JL

>I (like John) have the Lee Valley round ones. I put the glued up aprons up on the drill press before attaching them to the top.

I have a "set" of the non-marring "bench dog muzzles" also. Though I need to get more. I have a couple of hold fasts also.

I figured I could drill better and straighter then I could dado.

Re: Square or round...what is your favorite...

#4

Re: Square or round...what is your favorite...

Scott in Douglassville

>I used round on both my benches. I have the LV brass dogs, but will only use them to hold my horizontanl router table. I touched one with a hand plane a while back while planing, and the iron was toast. Now, for actual work, I only use 3/4" dowel-stock dogs. I bought a buncho of little bullet catches cheap from LV and installed them in the "dogs" to make them lock snugly in the holes.

The 3/4" holes are easy to add, fast to drill, and can be put anywhere. Not traditional, but that's not always a bad thing...

Re: Square or round...what is your favorite...

#5

Square. The dogs are easier and cheaper to make

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>Hello Rob,

square holes are just as easy to make as round holes when you're building the bench. And square dogs are much easier and faster to make than round.

Using round holes to do double duty for both dogs and holdfasts may sound like a good idea but you'll soon discover that 3 or 4 holdfast holes are best put near the middle and back of the bench, while a whole row of dog holes is needed right near the front edge.

To make a square dog, grab almost any scrap of oak, ash, beech or any other hardwood, plane a 4-6 inch piece until it is a slightly loose fit in your dog holes, attach a flexible piece of thin wood to the side and you're done.

For this dog I glued a flexible offcut of Kauri in a slightly angled notch in an offcut of White Oak. The whole thing took about 5 minutes to make and has lasted about 3 years so far. The painter's masking tape used to hold it together while the glue dried wore away after about a year.

regards

Angus Barclay


img

Re: Square or round...what is your favorite...

#6

Re: Square or round...what is your favorite...

Andre Mallegol

>Rob,

I went round. I used 2 layers of MDF and a sheet of hardboard for the bench top. Drilled the MDF to size and then epoxied in copper pipe to hold the dogs without damaging the MDF. I use Lee Valley holddowns and bench dogs and wood dowels.

Andre Mallegol

Re: Square or round...what is your favorite...

#7

Re: Square. The dogs are easier and cheaper to mak

Vijay

>I went with square because

1. They are more traditional-- I like the look better

2. Dogs are easy to make.

3. Square dogs provide a flat surface for the workpiece to push against.

4. And for all the reasons Angus said.

Vijay