Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

Posts

OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#1

OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

Jim in N.Va.

>Are there any reviews out there that compare Honda's and Toyota's built-in navigation systems to each other and to the separate units from Garmin, etc.? Honda dealer said their system was best because it could be operated while the vehicle was moving (presumably by the passenger) while the Toyota can not and that Honda includes 7 million points of interest while Toyota has 1 million. I did notice that while driving down a residential street that the Toyota navigation system placed us accurately on the map, but did not indicate there was a road there. (It was a main street in a well established urban area.)

Anyway, it would be nice if I could find some objective reviews of the various systems. Any thoughts?

Thanks,

Jim

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#2

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>I have not seen any reviews to compare the various navigation systems. However I have seen comments in automobile reviews that said that the Honda/Acura system was the best one out there. I have a '05 Accord with Nav and I like it very much. Not that it is perfect because it is not. The maps will be somewhat out of date the day you buy any of the systems because of the lag between when new roads are built and that information gets into the systems. The audible directions has errors in it. Not a ot of errors but they are there. As an example mile post 262 will be called 252 on I17 north of Phoenix.

Howard

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#3

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

Vijay

>Having been through the buying process of an Odyssey recently, here was my thought process.

The purchase of the option would have pushed us in to the higher priced model for another 3k. I already have the Garmin Streetpilot that we used extensively on a 5000 mile trip to the national parks last summer. The Garmin never missed a beat including turn by turn to the nearest motel including telling you if it was located on the left side of the street. Plus updates to the device were always free--you needed an internet connection and about 30 minutes while the device got updated. I have done the updates only 3 times in over a year of ownership.

For the money and portability it for me it was hard to beat a high end Garmin.

Vijay

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#4

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

Jim in N.Va.

>Thanks for the tip. If you don't mind, which model Street Pilot do you have? I went to the Garmin site and was amazed at the number of different models. Hard to tell them apart.

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#5

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

Vijay

>I purchased the Garmin Streetpilot 2720 which now sells for 1/2 what I paid for about a year ago (10 months ago). But that is the way with all electronic goods. I would buy it again.

On the other hand if there were any units that would do voice recognition and had battery power in addition to 12 v input then that would be ideal. The Garmin 2720 has neither.

Vijay

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#6

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

Sgian Dubh

>The general opinion over here in the UK is that car company provided PratNav systems as they are disparagingly often called is a rip off. A built in SatNav can add �1000 to �1500 to the cost of the vehicle.

Free standing, stick on the windscreen type units from TomTom, Garmin and others cost from as little as �200 or �250. These units have systems for updating maps, loading maps in the system for mainland Europe, north America, etc., and can even pinpoint most of the fixed speed cameras the British government has sanctioned be placed along the roadside. This last is claimed as a safety measure, but most of us think it's just a cunning and underhand means of raising money to waste on some grandiose government scheme or other, ha, ha.

Not the thorough review that you asked for, but my wife, an American, often finds it tricky to find her way around our pokey British roads. She finds the PratNave very useful from time to time, and I've even been known to use it once in a while! Slainte.

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#7

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

Jim Dillon

>Jim,

I hesitated to post this because my poor memory can't remember where I read the relatively recent newspaper column (maybe it was the Washington Post's computer/tech guy) that said the in-car units cannot compare to the external units if you compare apples-to-apples cost-wise. In terms of cost, ease and frequency of updates, accuracy etc. etc., the external units excel in all categories. But the in-car units do look nice in your dashboard 8-). However, take this all for what it is worth as I can't reference the article for you to reach your own conclusion. Good luck in your shopping.

Jim

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#8

Garmin 660

Dave Herman, West Chester, PA

>We got the Garmin 660 at work and it's worked great for me. I let my daughter use it on a trip from PA to VA and around town and it's gotten her there everytime. There are little quirks in the software, like having to know the right town or zip code, but overall it's a great little system.

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#9

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

Mark Valsi

>We just got an ACURA TL and a LEXUS IS250 for my wife.

personally, I like my Acura Navi much better. Seems easier to use overall, and has more controls.

personal test I would guess

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#10

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

DP

>Two good resources for information on both OEM and portable GPS systems are the GPS passion forum, http://www.gpspassion.com/forumsen/default.asp?CAT_ID=2,

and GPS magazine online,

http://www.gpsmagazine.com/.

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#11

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Mark, your experience fits with other reports that I have heard about the differences between the two systems.

Howard

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#12

When you have trouble !!!

Frank on Chesnut Hill

>I have a Garmin 340 ( the one that names the streets as you go). On the first try out the unit blew a 2amp fuse. One call to the number on the web site and they had me overnight(they paid) the monitor and brains of the unit back to them for a quick replacement .

Next time out another fuse as blown, one more call to the Garmin and they sent me a new cadle and cable. It is fine. I was tickled to have such willing and frendly service.

Everything is not always perfect, it is great to know they are back there. First trip after the new cable was to 55 Church street NYC. It delivered us right to the front of the hotel, across the street from the old World Trade Center site. Bulls Eye.

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

#13

Re: OT Automobile navigation system reviews?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I have a Garmin C330 Street Pilot. I bought it for about $325. Never skips a beat. The worst it has done was tell me I was at my destination 200ft after I passed it, but that was a home in rural Georgia. I was probably on the property, but missed the driveway.

I bought one for a graduation gift for my daughters boyfriend, and he loves it.

Easy to use. The only thing it does not have that some have, is the abilty to enter a coordinates (Lat/Long).

I like that ability to move it from vehicle to vehicle, and even carry it when walking around (useful in a big city).

I also though I am basically a techno nut - I try to subscribe to the practice of buying only what I need - not bells and whistles, because something with all the bells and whistles will be much cheaper a year from now. Just ask the people that paid $4000 for LCD TVs that you can now get for $900.

Mark