Complementary woods (long)
Ellis Walentine
>Everybody has his or her own take on what woods go well together. It's part of the fun of designing your own projects. Sometimes two or three woods just seem to click together, for no obvious reason, but I think it has to do with three things: Hue, value and texture. Density and durability may enter the picture for other reasons, but hue, value and texture are the big ones IMO.
Wood hues tend to be blends of red, yellow, blue and black. Browns are all mixtures of the three primary colors, in different proportions. Blue never appears by itself, but it is responsible for purplish hues, as in mahogany and purpleheart. Cherry is red-brown with a fair amount of yellow warming it up, while walnut is brown-brown with a little purple if it is new and especially if it is air dried. White oak and English oak are also on the brown-brown axis, with yellow overtones; red oak has red and yellow overtones.
The value dimension has to do with lightness. White oak and walnut are both brown-brown, but the oak has a higher value, so it appears lighter. Tans and browns are all on the same brown spectrum but with different values. By combining woods of different values, you can make a design more dramatic or more restrained-looking.
To my eye, colors with similar hues complement each other better than those with dissimilar hues. Walnut looks better with oak than it does with cherry or mahogany, unless you are staining or otherwise altering the hue.
Texture is another dimension that is also subjective. This has to do with the "decorative" aspects of the wood, such as the grain patterns of open-pored woods (versus the more uniform grain of diffuse-porous woods like maple and cherry), or the prominent ray structure of lacewood or quartersawn white oak, or the spots of birdseye maple or the crazy swirls of burls.
Texture can also involve color differences; zebrawood and Macassar ebony are both stripey woods, claro walnut often has reds, golds browns and blacks juxtaposed, and ambrosia maple has dark streaks as a result of fungal activity.
"Figure" is another component that adds to the texture or visual interest. To me, figure is a measure of the chatoyance, or shimmer, that you see when the wood grain ducks in and out of the surface. Maple, satinwood, eucalyptus, sapele, makore, koa and other species often show high figure, in various patterns. They may be curly or fiddleback, flamed or quilted or mottled or blistered. It can be subtle or dramatic, and it can be in combination with some of the color and grain features I mentioned above.
Adding yet another layer of variability to this complexity, wood colors and values are subject to change due to oxidation, ultraviolet light and other environmental factors, so you have to think down the road a few years to what the piece will look like. Purpleheart turns brown, African padauk turns a dark brownish burgundy, maple yellows, walnut lightens and yellows in the sun but not in the shade. Etc., etc.
Don't forget to factor in the decor of the space you are building into. Architectural woodworking is subject to a lot of different constraints from freestanding furniture or treen, which can be moved to different surroundings. If your decorating theme is bright and light, you might not want to add the visual weight of a lot of walnut. If the decor is subtle (or even if it isn't), you don't want to add too much visual interest with your secondary woods, as the zebrawood itself will provide plenty of visual interest all by itself.
Sorry for the long-winded lecture, but I thought it would be good to have this sort of conceptual framework for choosing complementary woods. In the case of zebrawood, there is very little figure, but the texture is very dramatic with the narrow, contrasty stripes. I like Peruvian walnut, which is very dark, or one of the American walnuts to complement the brown-brown stripes of the zebrawood. I think the low values of the walnut (the darkness of the wood) frame the mixed values of the zebrawood well, without being too contrasty, as they might be if they framed a light-value wood like ash or maple. If you like a lot of contrast, you might pick a gold or ginger-ale colored wood to "pick up" or complement the gold hues of the zebrano. Mulberry would be an excellent choice for color, but the texture may be too heavy, and besides, you'll never find it at a lumber yard. Maple with a wash coat of a tannish dye stain might work for color, but the texture might be too flat. Birch with some figure might also be nice. Satinwood would be a knockout, depending on how much drama you can stand. The color is just right.
So, I suggest you cogitate on some of this stuff and see if any revelations pop out at you. You might want to visit the Woodfinder Wood Library to see some images of different woods and find suppliers that carry them. Whatever you do, I suggest you make up some samples of the combinations you want to use and finish them with your intended finish. Then, you and your spouse or customer can see in advance what the combination is going to look like.
Let us know what you decide.
Ellis Walentine, Host