Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

Posts

Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

#1

Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

Sgian Dubh

>Here's a follow up on the thread Michael Dresdner started about the perception that many workers have on the 'poor' adhesion characteristics of oil based polyurethane varnish.

It's often said in forums, and elsewhere, that polyurethane is in many ways inferior to alkyd varnishes such as the Pratt and Lambert 38 range. The charges are usually along a mixture of the following lines: it doesn't adhere well to wood, to other finishes nor to itself, which Michael commented on earlier. It's often further charged that polyurethane is cloudy, it's plasticky looking, difficult to apply, not as tough, difficult to rub out, etc..

Here in the UK all oil based interior varnishes that I can find are of the polyurethane type. I've searched hard for alternative types. There's no soya or alkyd resin varnish available as far as I know for interior use.

Therefore I have no choice but to use polyurethane varnish for interior applications. I seldom see or experience any of the alleged faults mentioned above when polyurethane varnishes are applied correctly, e.g., not slapped on with a stiff bristle yard broom with loose debris amongst the bristles, and the job is done in a clean atmosphere. That's a slight exaggeration of some people's method of application, but it's not so far off as you might think!

It's my experience that some cloudiness can occur with polyurethane varnishes, but to get this effect requires multiple coats of a matte or a satin formulation. Again, it's my experience that the plasticky look can be avoided by not applying too many coats to avoid too big a build up.

Two to four or five brushed on coats gives good protection with two to three coats being what I normally aim for. I will also spray the stuff, even though it can leave a sticky mess on flat surfaces and gum up your arm hairs.

Thinning the stuff out and wiping it on works well for me too. This I find works best on open textured woods where the openness of the grain helps disguise an application technique that's perhaps a bit less than perfect. When this application method is chosen I usually suggest to the learners I demonstrate this to that they apply between four coats, and perhaps up to seven or ten coats. The reason for this is that the student is usually aiming for a fairly low build up with reasonable protection, e.g., for a lightly used hall table or similar. For wiping on I always use gloss all through the process, except for perhaps the last one or two coats.

To avoid the milkiness on multi-coated items I apply gloss for the early coats and finish with a last coat of the sheen I want. I've never really found it necessary to rub out varnishes to the desired sheen, so I can't comment on how hard it is to rub out poly versus alkyd type varnishes. Slainte.

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

#2

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>My computer sits on a teak and oak parsons table, finished in brushed-on gloss Varathane poly thinned down with a little Flecto Plastic Oil, that I made around 35 years ago. It was my favorite finish because it went on easily, leveled itself, required no rubout, was tough, and looked great. I also used it as a base for opaque colors by mixing in screen printing ink, for which it demonstrated the same qualities and worked just as well. It went over anything, including artists' oils and acrylics with no problem.

These days, I try to avoid it. Either the formulation has changed a lot or my technique has declined, because it always seems to bubble and show brush marks. Then it jells in the container.

Clint

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

#3

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

David Yoho

>Richard, regarding avoiding a cloudy or plastic look, my experience with poly has been the same. In fact, I use a tip Michael suggested a good while ago and follows what you mentioned. I always apply clear gloss up to the final few coats and then apply the desired sheen to finish.

Personally, while I've found poly easy to use with good results, I like the look of a varnish like Waterlox better. Either way, starting with a clear gloss and moving to the sheen of choice keeps the particles that reflects light (giving a satin or semi-gloss sheen its look) from clouding the finish so you see through to the wood better.

David

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

#4

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Richard, I am 100% in agreement with your assessment. When an object I finish has to withstand fairly hard use - I use poly. I have sprayed Minwax thinned 50% with Naptha or mineral spirits (depending on the temperature ect. and the orientation of the item being sprayed). I also have used Minwax with BLO & thinner 1/3 - 1/3 -1/3. as a wipe on - wipe off finish. IMHO the Minwax is one of the better Poly's available in the US. I have rubbed out Poly with steel wool & wax to achieve a satin finish. Only issue I've found is that if it is a heavy coat, you have to wait a couple weeks minimum or it is "gummy" and won't rub out properly.If the item isn't going to see a lot of hard use, I like shellac and / or Lacquer. Guess this is just personal preference.

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

#5

What's in a name?

John Pappas

>As a point of clarity I add this information from Bob Flexner's book, Understanding Wood Finishing.

"Pure polyurethane finishes come in two parts (like epoxy glue), or they cure with heat or by absorbing moisture. The polyurethane you most often see in paint stores is actually an alkyd varnish modified with polyurethane resin, a uralkyd. Since the base of the finish is alkyd varnish, it applies and cures like alkyd varnish."

Based on that, the discussion is really comparing a pure alkyd varnish with a alkyd/poly blend varnish. A fine point, but it seem that it is not an either/or situation.

Disclaimer: All I know is what I read.

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

#6

Lee Grindinger

Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

Lee Grindinger

>I prefer alkyd for most things because it levels better and is softer to the touch, not as cold as poly. The early polys were crap compared to a good quality alkyd but they have improved recently. I will say I have largely switched to polyurethane for table tops because of it's durability and heat resistance. However I still opt for the alkyd for surfaces not exposed to such rigors because it's tactile superiority.

Lee

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

#7

Re: poly vs. traditional resin --long

Steve Schoene

>I prefer the alkyd (or phenolic) resin varnishes to polyurethane for just about everything except floors. Single part consumer grade polyurethane has proved more difficult to rub out evenly compared to the traditional resin varnishes and was subtly less attractive, at least with films that gave moderate �depth�. If the esthetic calls for very thin total coatings, then I think the differences are pretty minor.

I tested varnishes side by side before a project I did a several years ago when I was looking for a table top coating. I used Behlen Rockhard, and Ronan Quick Rubbing Varnish, both of which are phenolic resin varnishes, and Pratt & Lambert 38 which is alkyd with a Soya base. For polyurethane varnish I used a Minwax product, and another oil based polyurethane which I can�t remember. I only compared appearance, since any of the varnishes would be sufficiently durable. I applied 4 brushed on coats, sanded between each, with fairly heavy sanding on coats 2 and 3 to get really good leveling�consequently total dry film was not excessive, but it was more than a very thin coating. The substrate was cherry heartwood.

The Rockhard was nicest to apply, flowing and leveling nicely. It did need about 10% thinning however. The two other traditional resin varnishes were very good. The P & L 38 was substantially lighter in color, and considerably less amber. That wasn�t a virtue on the cherry but it would be on other woods. The two poly�s weren�t as nice to brush, but not disastrously so. They did want to pill 320 grit sandpaper more readily (I waited 24 hours between sanding and recoating.). (There is a bit of unfairness, since the poly�s were consumer grade from big boxes.)

There was very little appearance difference, other than color, after just 2 coats (before sanding).

I waited only 2 weeks before rubbing out the final coat. The two phenolic resin varnishes excelled in the ease at which they were rubbed out. (600 grit sandpaper followed by 1200 grit paper lubricated with water, then rottenstone lubricated with paraffin oil.) The P & L did OK and the poly�s ended up OK, but took longer, especially with the rottenstone to get an even sheen. The results were mellow glosses, not as high gloss as un-rubbed varnish, but without the nibs.

Head on, the poly�s and the traditional resin varnishes were quite similar and hard to tell apart. But, at an angle, the poly�s could be readily identified. Perhaps it was haziness, perhaps it was chatoyance that differed under the poly compared to the traditional resin varnishes. In any event I flipped a coin between the Rockhard and the Ronan Quick Rubbing Varnish. The Ronan seems very similar to the discontinued Behlen 4 hour rubbing varnish.

Of course, really proper tests of appearance should be double blind and these were not.

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

#8

Re: poly vs. traditional resin --long

Howard Acheson

>Steve, your results pretty much parallel the result we got in the shop I used to be involved with. We did our tests in the early 1990's so the products are probably quite different now.

When we became aware of thinned varnish and wiping it on we tested that process using a alkyd/soya varnish, a phenolic/tung oil marine non-poly varnish and two "consumer grade" poly varnishes. All the products were thinned 50/50 with mineral spirits. The regimen was to wipe on two coats of the thinned finish, dry for 24 hours and then flat sand with 320 paper. Then three more coats applied one after the other. Let it dry 24 hours and lighly sand again with 320 paper. Then a final, carefully wiped on coat. We did not attempt any "rub out" as we were a production shop making high end custom cabinetry.

The results showed very little difference between the products with the exception of color. Of course, we ended up with a fairly thin film but it was more than enough for the application we had. While not part of the specific test, we did have some sample boards that had brushed on varnish and poly varnish. Compared to our test boards, the finish was quite a bit thicker. The wiped on finish was actually nicer looking overall as it tended to give the look of a varnish finish. The brushed on varnish and poly varnish, when compared to each other, were different. The poly did have a distinct, cloudy look when viewed with slanting back light.

So, I would conclude that a three or more brushed on coat of either varnish or poly varnish will create a sort of "encased in finish" or plasticty look. The non-poly varnish was clearer. The wiped on finishes all looked more natural on the wood but they were not as thick a film.

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

#9

Re: Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?

Sgian Dubh

>Thanks for all the commentary and for some interesting experiments and observations. I did want to try and dispel what I believe is quite a bit of negative commentary on the oil based polyurethane varnishes. This I think has led to many people simply dismissing the finish as inferior, which it is not.

It is, to me, just one of a range of finishes that has its use in the right place. Shellac is not appropriate for every job, nor is boiled linseed, and nor is pre-catalysed lacquer. Slainte.