Oil polyurethane varnish v. alkyd varnish?
Sgian Dubh
>Here's a follow up on the thread Michael Dresdner started about the perception that many workers have on the 'poor' adhesion characteristics of oil based polyurethane varnish.
It's often said in forums, and elsewhere, that polyurethane is in many ways inferior to alkyd varnishes such as the Pratt and Lambert 38 range. The charges are usually along a mixture of the following lines: it doesn't adhere well to wood, to other finishes nor to itself, which Michael commented on earlier. It's often further charged that polyurethane is cloudy, it's plasticky looking, difficult to apply, not as tough, difficult to rub out, etc..
Here in the UK all oil based interior varnishes that I can find are of the polyurethane type. I've searched hard for alternative types. There's no soya or alkyd resin varnish available as far as I know for interior use.
Therefore I have no choice but to use polyurethane varnish for interior applications. I seldom see or experience any of the alleged faults mentioned above when polyurethane varnishes are applied correctly, e.g., not slapped on with a stiff bristle yard broom with loose debris amongst the bristles, and the job is done in a clean atmosphere. That's a slight exaggeration of some people's method of application, but it's not so far off as you might think!
It's my experience that some cloudiness can occur with polyurethane varnishes, but to get this effect requires multiple coats of a matte or a satin formulation. Again, it's my experience that the plasticky look can be avoided by not applying too many coats to avoid too big a build up.
Two to four or five brushed on coats gives good protection with two to three coats being what I normally aim for. I will also spray the stuff, even though it can leave a sticky mess on flat surfaces and gum up your arm hairs.
Thinning the stuff out and wiping it on works well for me too. This I find works best on open textured woods where the openness of the grain helps disguise an application technique that's perhaps a bit less than perfect. When this application method is chosen I usually suggest to the learners I demonstrate this to that they apply between four coats, and perhaps up to seven or ten coats. The reason for this is that the student is usually aiming for a fairly low build up with reasonable protection, e.g., for a lightly used hall table or similar. For wiping on I always use gloss all through the process, except for perhaps the last one or two coats.
To avoid the milkiness on multi-coated items I apply gloss for the early coats and finish with a last coat of the sheen I want. I've never really found it necessary to rub out varnishes to the desired sheen, so I can't comment on how hard it is to rub out poly versus alkyd type varnishes. Slainte.



