Re: Fitering air - Long somewhat contrary opinion *LINK*
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>I just went through much the same thing over the last 10 days.
I have a 20'x24' shop, I am also primarily a turner. A good deal of the year I use my cartridge filter equipped 1.5hp Grizzly G-1028Z DC to pick up chips around the lathe, run during anytime I am sanding on the lathe with the 4" hose as close to the sanding as a bungee cord will allow. I have ducting up to the planer, jointer, disk/belt sander, Profomax 16-32, but not so much with the Sears Contractor saw - at least until I can seal it up better. Most of the year the weather is nice enough to have shop windows and door open and a 22" fan running in the window in one end of the shop (opposite the door). Good air movement, and the shop is pretty clean, and when I do blow out the dust, it heads out that window pretty quickly.
NOW remember, the stuff that settles to the floor/bench quickly is not so much the health problem, it is the dust that takes forever to settle out, and is easily re-introduced to the shop air with the slightest air movement.
Remember, the standard Filter - even upgraded versions, will not filter out the sub-micron dust that stays in the air and enters your lungs. In fact, what happens when you have a DC running in the same room as you are working, is that it filters chunks out, and propels the small stuff back into the shop air.
I had this hammered home this last week or so, when it got hot enough down here to close up the shop and turn on the AC. I remembered that last year the cooling coils on the AC got totally clogged up when the condensation on them atracted the dust in the airstream, and made a dust mud. So, I bought a decent "pollen trapping" filter, and taped it to the intake of the AC (window AC).
Now, I use alot of red woods like Paduak and Bloodwood. When I taped that filter on, the shop was pretty clean, and I had done no work of any kind in the shop for about 5 hours. That filter was a deep red within about 60 minutes and got worse over the next 4 hours, again with no work being done in the shop.
BTW, my DC is in a seperate room with no door or other air flow between them - totally isolated.
SO, I was a little worried about all this dust in the air. Last year, I developed an allergy to Ebony wood. Minor, the skin on my forearms itches like crazy. But now I am much more sensitive to other wood dust. I started thinking about adding one or two good Air Cleaners like a Delta or a JDS ($325+ a pop). Our good WC friend H.C. Sakman gave me all the makings of an air cleaner system last year or a little longer ago (pre-filters, good deep filters, motor, etc, all but the wood) and I built one I had it running all the time I was in the shop, but did not see much effect. Benches still got dirty, and AC clogged up. So, not 3 months ago, I passed it on to a club member that has zero dust collection in is small shop.
But I started thinking about the $700 outlay for a couple of air cleaners, and remembering Bill Pentz saying on his webpage that if you really want to get rid of the dust, you must capture it at the source and not try to clean it up after the fact. Once into the open shop space, you need many, many more CFM of air movement to get it out. In emails back and forth, he told me of a friend that had just installed a new DC system (of Bill's design) in his garage shop but had yet to tweek the connections at the machines, and had some leaks. Within 3 minutes of using the TS, with the DC on, the shop was over OSHA standards, and Bill (who is super sensitive to wood dust) was heading for the door and his inhaler. He left his cyclone on, turned on his overhead big commercial air filter, and opened the large two car garage door, windows and side door to his shop. He also turned on a big air mover fan in the doorway to exhaust the shop. He said that they calculated that they were totally exchanging the air 3 or more times a MINUTE, and it took 20 minutes for the air in the shop to reach the same level as the outside air. The guy was pissed, but realized that unless he upgraded the hoods and ports on the tools, the rest was a waste.
As Bill wrote to me "What you need to get out of this is there is zero chance your 1.5 hp dust collector is really going to provide you with the airflow required and unless you did a very serious filter upgrade and change filters roughly every couple of hundred hours use, your filter is also not going to protect you."
In the end, the conclusion is that a 1.5hp DC with 4" ducting is not ever going to keep the dangerous dust out of the air, and an Air Cleaner might help keep the shop clean and your finishes cleaner, but it will not help much with your allergies. Once the stuff in in the air, is it hard as heck to trap it. You are not going to do much with a box fan and filter, as Forrest said, you are not going to suck enough air though a filter to do much. Totally moving contaminated air out of the shop is better, but heating and cooling is going to suffer.
I have decided to totally upgrade my DC. I ordered and they shipped an new ClearVue Cyclone today. Should have it by Monday or so. I will be upgrading my Ducting to 6" all the way to the machines. I will have the DC running most of the time, even with no machine being used, with several, if not all blast gates open to keep the air moving out. I have also decided that when I process batches of wood (cut, plane, joint), I will use the DC AND have the shop open with the fan screaming on high, regardless of the weather.
Basically for me, I am not ready to let my allergies drive me out of my hobby, and I am not willing to let my hobby slowly kill me.
OK, Just my experience and opinion folks. Read and convince yourself.
Mark
www.markkauder.com
Bill Pentz Dust Collection.