Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

Posts

HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#1

Alan Young

HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

Alan Young

>I have several empty plastic coffee containers. They are no 2 HDPE. (High Density Poly ethylene I assume) I have a project coming up that where I will be using Transtint Liquid Dyes. I will need to make several different "flavors" ie samples of a particular color to test on scrap before the final decision is made on which tone is preferred. As a B minus C plus Chemistry student I am wondering if these will make acceptable conatainers if I mixed the dyes with alcohol.???

A mixture of distilled water would be OK I am guessing.

-Alan

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#2

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I don't know but I use 1 liter cleaned soda bottles and have had no problems.

Tom

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#3

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I have used those containers when I use denatured alcohol to soak freshly cut pen blanks, I sell on Ebay, to accelerate drying. I have left the alcohol in the container for weeks with just the cover that comes with it. HDPE is pretty tough stuff. In fact the acid I use in my swimming pool comes in bottles made of it as well as the liquid chlorine I use.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#4

HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

nailshooter

>Just make sure the tops fit well. I use them to mix lacquers and thinners and have no problems, but every once in a while I get on that doesn't have good fitting top. You can easily imagine the results.

Robert

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#5

plastic compatibility with solvents

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>HDPE is only soluble in hot aromatic solvents like xylene. I don't know of anything that will dissolve it at room temperature.

Soda bottles, PET, are not soluble in typical solvents, even hot. A few exotic solvents will dissolve it but you will never encounter them in a wood shop. PET will degrade in strong acids and bases, especially if hot. PET bottles are formed by stretch blow molding. Think blowing a balloon into a mold and then freezing the shape. If you get the bottle hot the plastic will soften and the "balloon" will deflate. You can impress you kids by putting a bottle into the microwave with a little water in it to make steam and then heating. A miniature soda bottle will emerge.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#6

Consider this...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>Several potent potables are available in plastic containers. Whether they are #2 HDPE or PET, I don't know, but generally the alcohol used in finishing is mostly ethanol--grain alcohol, the stuff you can drink, perhaps with a little methanol thrown in to make it poisonous (and non-taxable by your local excise authority).

Just don't try to mix anything containing lacquer thinner in a styrofoam cup. DAMHIKT.

Jason

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#7

JL

Re: Sort of seconding what Bill T. said...

JL

>HDPE would work well with any moderately polar solvent (alcohols, water, etc.). I would avoid its use with any non-polar solvent (toluene, xylene, most paint thinners). Even though HDPE may not dissolve with the non-polar solvents, it may soften or become embrittled.

So sure, use it. Just make sure the lid closes tightly.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#8

Re: plastic compatibility with solvents

john b. southwest Chicago burbs

>IT works. Okay how many of shrunk a pop bottle. john b.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#9

it will neither soften nor become brittle

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>Until one gets the stuff hot enough to melt the crystallinity it won't dissolve or soften in anything. So at room temperature one can store most anything in HDPE.

Think what modern gas "cans" are made from, or many gas tanks for that matter.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#10

Re: What about the colorant, Bill?

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Bill,

What about the colorant used to make the Folger's containers either red or green? Might woodworking solvents, possibly, cause those to leach from the container into the solvent?

Al

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#11

colorant discussion

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>The short answer is that I don't know. There are various ways to color plastic and some can extract with more or less difficulty while others can't. I don't know how these cans are colored.

Anything that has food contact either has very stringent requirements for not extracting, or the colorant must be food grad colorant(unlikely in this case). I would guess that the colorant in this case would not extract at room temperature. However, you raise a good point. One should check to see that the colorant does not extract.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#12

JL

Re: it will neither soften nor become brittle

JL

>Perhaps it depends on the plasticizers. I've had the milk jugs and some of the thinner gauge HDPE containers become brittle (it took several years though). Maybe it depends on the gauge.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#13

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

Craig in Silverdale

>I use the containers they put the cole slaw and bean salad in from Safeway. The lid snaps on to seal it and they don't take up a lot of space.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#14

brittle for different reasons, another experiment

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>HDPE does not contain plasticizers so there is nothing to extract and make the remaining plastic brittle, unlike PVC.

However, any poly(ethylene) will become brittle with age at a rate that depends on how well it was stabilized in manufacturing. Light and oxygen will slowly degrade (break-up polymer chains) the plastic. As soon as the long spaghetti-like molecules of poly( ethylene) become chopped up short like macaroni by action of light, the material will become brittle and easily break.

An experiment. Wax and poly(ethylene) have exactly the same chemical formula and chemical composition. They only differ in the length of the molecules, with the poly(ethylene) molecules being 10000 times longer than wax molecules. These long molecules entangle with one another like a plate of spaghetti. To pull something apart that is made from these long molecules requires the atoms in these molecules (the polymer chains) to be broken apart, and these atoms are very strongly held together in this molecule. To break the short un-entagled molecules of wax apart it is only necessary to separate these short molecules which are held together with very weak forces. Hence, it is difficult to rip apart even a 0.003" thick sheet of poly(ethylene) because to do so requires breaking apart the atoms in the entangled molecules. But it is easy to break even a 1/2" thick slab of canning wax because one is only pulling molecules apart from one anotherin this case. Poly(ethylene) degraded by light becomes more like the wax as its molecules are broken apart by light into short less entangled molecules.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#15

Re: plastic compatibility with solvents

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>I'd be more impressed with the microwave trick if you could also provide me with a way to shrink the screw on cap at the same time. Sorry Bill, I just couldn't resist. ;-)

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#16

JL

Re:Was close to a fluorescent light for..

JL

>a number of years. They were 1/2 gallon milk jugs with the tops cut off and used to hold nails, drywall screws, etc. on the top shelf relatively near the fluorescent light. When they were picked up from where they had been, they fell apart.

Perhaps they didn't contain enough antioxidants or UV absorbers.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#17

why the threads do not shrink

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>The screw cap won't shrink because it is not stretch blow molded. To begin, molten polymer is injection molded into something that looks like a screw top test tube. The threads must be very precise so they must be injection molded. These test tubes, called parisons, are shipped to near the bottler for blow molding into bottles which are too expensive to ship very far.

The parison is heated in a bank of infra red heaters until it is soft and then it is moved to a clam shell female mold the shape of the bottle. A puff of nitrogen blows the rubbery polymer into the shape of the mold. When it hits the mold the polymer "freezes" into the mold shape. So only the bottle bottom has been stretched and frozen into the bottle shape. Upon gentle heating the bottle will try to return to the shape of the parison.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#18

Also called...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>"baby soda bottles". You can buy them filled with various science experiments geared towards young children--of which I have 3. I even turned one of the parisons into a nozzle, made a coupler, and used it for the Mentos/Diet Coke demo. I probably got a good 15'+ out of it.

Jason

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#19

Re: why the threads do not shrink

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>Hi Bill, Thanks for the comprehensive answer. I guess my remark was a little too tongue in cheek for you to pick up the fact I was kidding. Sorry.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#20

I got it, but

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>it was a good question on its own and deserved an answer. I thought some would find it interesting how the ubiquitous plastic bottle is made. Cool technology invented in the last 25 years that has largely replaced glass except in application where an oxygen barrier is required, for example beer and wine. PET is a screen door when it comes to oxygen permiability.

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

#21

Re: HDPE Folgers Coffee Cans for dyes

Jim Dillon

>Alan,

Broadly speaking, you should be just fine with your intended use for the HDPE container. You've gotten good advice from everyone and Bill has provided excellent hands-on experience and scientific understanding as well. HDPE resins, like all common commercial plastics, are often custom formulated for their intended application. This may mean that very little in the way of additives are used for "food/drink-grade" applications (usually less than 0.1% extractables), but more/other additives may be used for other types of commercial applications. Bill is also right that "plasticizers" as an additive group are generally not used in HDPE (or other polyolefins); however, other additive groups are commonly used in polyolefins such as processing aids (lubricants, slip agents, anti-scorch agents, etc.), shelf-life extenders such as anti-oxidants etc., as well as colorants. A thin-walled plastic milk bottle is not intended to last forever, nor should it. Whereas, a plastic gas tank will likely be with us awhile. Some polyolefins (garbage bags) are actually formulated (generally with the addition of a polysaccharide) to intentially degrade in a relatively short period of time - especially when buried in a garbage dump. Having said all this, the bottom will probably drop out of your plastic Folger coffee can when you add your "brew" 8-). Good luck.

Jim