Sand between coats? Rarely.
Michael Dresdner
>>> if a coat has dried more than 12 hours then lightly sand before recoating". (Instructions on a Varathane can)
They had to pick a number, a task that is pretty arbitrary, so that is the number they picked. It is not gospel. In my own writings, even for Varathane, I usually say you can go a week between coats before you have to sand.
Drying time is affected by temperature, humidity, type of wood, and how thickly it is applied. All those things working together can shrink or extend dry time enormously. For instance, some conditions can take an overnight dry time and extend it to seven days, and adding thick layers geometrically increases dry time. When you write labels you have to do a lot of guessing since there is no way to know how your customer will interpret your instructions, or the conditions under which he or she applies finish.
If it is any consolation, I have spoken with them at length about this, and the reality is that anything you write will be taken by some completely at face value and by others as something akin to 'serving suggestions' on food containers. You can't address everyone, so they err on the side of safety, and pretend that everyone is using the material correctly and in ideal environments.
Hey, that is no better or worse than assuming everyone will use it incorrectly and that all environments are disasters, right?
I should offer a disclaimer here. I write the answers for www.woodanswers.com the online help source hosted by the Rustoleum group, which includes Varathane, Watco, Zinsser, Wolman, Rustoleum, American Accents, Painter's Touch, and a bunch of other name brands.
Typically, when they redo a label, as they did recently on new Varathane designs, they send me the label before printing for my comments. Usually the end result is something between what the lab wants, what I want, and what the sales force wants. That's not a bad compromise, and probably better than most that take place in our halls of government.