Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

Posts

Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#1

Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

Michael Dresdner

>I frequently read, embedded as a side comment in various threads, that various drying oils or Danish oils can go over themselves, but that oil based polyurethane will not adhere to itself.

This is completely untrue. In fact, oil based polyurethane has excellent adhesion both to itself and to other coatings. This is true for both gel and liquid oil based polyurethanes.

The only thing required is to clean, degrease, and lightly abrade the surface. You can do all three in one step by scrubbing with TSP on nylon abrasive pads (such as Scotchbrite.) The TSP cleans and degreases and the pads abrade.

Thank you.

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#2

Now you tell me!

Hoa Dinh in Alameda

>13 years ago we moved into the current house.

My SWMBO wanted me to add more protection to the kitchen cabinets. I asked the builder what they'd used and was told oil-based poly.

I added two coats of semi-gloss MinWax poly. For preping, I just wiped clean the cabinets with paint thinner. I didn't know enough to scrub sand them.

The added poly is still there today.

-- Hoa

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#3

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

Ted Wong

>I've never had problems adding subsequent coats of poly to surfaces already coated with poly. A simple light sanding is frequently all that is needed. However the "burn-in" quality of poly is nonexistent as far as I can tell. Rubbing out a surface treated with polyurethane often shows featheredging revealing various layers. The way I've found to work around this is to build up several light coats followed by a very heavy finish coat that will allow me to rubout the surface.

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#4

Question for MD

John Pappas

>Michael, most instructions concerning poly say to lightly sand between coats. However, instructions on a can of Varathane Premium Poly says "let dry for 4 hours and recoat......if a coat has dried more than 12 hours then lightly sand before recoating". Might this apply to any poly or is this something that is unique in Varathanes's formulation? Some items are tedious to sand and so eliminating one or two sandings sure would be a plus.

Thanks.

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#5

One take on it...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>I've never been a big fan of sanding between coats unless there is some absolutely obvious reason to do so (i.e., a problem, or elapsed time as you mentioned). The reason for this thinking is that it doesn't make much sense to put on a coat of something then sand it right back off--you'll never get any build that way. This is especially true if your first finishing steps are something like stain and shellac to be followed by poly--it's real easy to sand through the shellac and stain, particularly on edges. If at all possible, I refrain from sanding until right before the final finish coat, and that is just a very light "scuff-sanding" to give it a little mechanical bond and to knock off any dust nibs that might be there (generally few, as I prefer quick-drying waterborne finishes).

Jason

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#6

Sand between coats? Rarely.

Michael Dresdner

>>> if a coat has dried more than 12 hours then lightly sand before recoating". (Instructions on a Varathane can)

They had to pick a number, a task that is pretty arbitrary, so that is the number they picked. It is not gospel. In my own writings, even for Varathane, I usually say you can go a week between coats before you have to sand.

Drying time is affected by temperature, humidity, type of wood, and how thickly it is applied. All those things working together can shrink or extend dry time enormously. For instance, some conditions can take an overnight dry time and extend it to seven days, and adding thick layers geometrically increases dry time. When you write labels you have to do a lot of guessing since there is no way to know how your customer will interpret your instructions, or the conditions under which he or she applies finish.

If it is any consolation, I have spoken with them at length about this, and the reality is that anything you write will be taken by some completely at face value and by others as something akin to 'serving suggestions' on food containers. You can't address everyone, so they err on the side of safety, and pretend that everyone is using the material correctly and in ideal environments.

Hey, that is no better or worse than assuming everyone will use it incorrectly and that all environments are disasters, right?

I should offer a disclaimer here. I write the answers for www.woodanswers.com the online help source hosted by the Rustoleum group, which includes Varathane, Watco, Zinsser, Wolman, Rustoleum, American Accents, Painter's Touch, and a bunch of other name brands.

Typically, when they redo a label, as they did recently on new Varathane designs, they send me the label before printing for my comments. Usually the end result is something between what the lab wants, what I want, and what the sales force wants. That's not a bad compromise, and probably better than most that take place in our halls of government.

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#7

Thanks, Michael

Joe Pack

>Thanks for taking your time to fill us in. I appreciate having an "expert" to turn to for information. Sort of like having our own "Snopes.com" for finishing. :-)

Thanks again.

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#8

I second the thanks, Michael

nailshooter

>I think it odd that you would post this out of the clear blue. And I have to say if you weren't of the notoriety and certainly as well respected as you are, you would be getting blasted to pieces for that statement.

On different forums, I have posted what you did about sanding and adhesion. Over the years that I have been professionally finishing and refinishing, and all the gallons of finish I have applied, I have never had adhesion problems with coatings unless the surface was not clean.

Never.

But people sanding between coats, just a little, maybe with a really fine piece of sandpaper, only for a minute, just in a place or two, is so well ingrained into finishing today it is just a part of it. I have been shouted down enough times I only say sanding isn't necessary between coats in public when I am around friends.

I learned long ago it was better to learn how to apply the finish correctly (thickness and viscosity), and to save sanding for errors.

Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwyn Williams industrial coatings specialists told me the same thing SEVERAL years ago. Who would have thunk it... pretty much the same thing you said. This same revolutionary "no sand" process has also worked for me with Defthane, Coronado products, whatever it is they sell at ICI, and even Minwax.

I spray most of the time now, and dont' sand in between coats of anything unless I goof something up, have a winged invader, or something stirs the dust. For me, the magic window for additional is different with all the products I use (quick dry super high VOC industrial enamels for metal to polyurethane conversion lacquers) but I just don't sand unless needed. Today's products are so good, they just don't need the help to adhere if applied properly.

I think you should post your message once every two weeks for a couple of years!

Robert

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#9

Re: Sand between coats? Rarely.

Sgian Dubh

>Michael, I'd also appreciate it if you'd make a few comments on what some perceive as the poor quality of finish you get from polyurethane type varnishes.

I get a bit tired of the mantra that polyurethane by its very nature is inferior to alkyd varnishes such as the Pratt and Lambert 38 range. The charges are usually along a mixture of the following lines: polyurethane is cloudy, plasticky looking, difficult to apply, not as tough, etc..

It's all very well for you guys on the west side of the pond having the choice between the different varnish types, but here in the UK all oil based interior varnishes that I can find are of the polyurethane type-- and I have searched and searched for alternative types. There's no soya or alkyd resin varnish available as far as I know for interior use.

Anyway, I seldom see or experience any of the alleged faults mentioned above when polyurethane varnishes are applied correctly, e.g., not slapped on with a stiff bristle yard broom with loose debris amongst the bristles, and the job done in a clean atmosphere, ha, ha. That's a slight exaggeration of some people's method of application, but it's not so far off as you might think! Slainte.

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#10

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

Steve Schoene

>The thing I see much more often in many sources is that polyurethane varnish doesn't adhere well over shellac that hasn't been dewaxed. Where does this dicta stack up, truth or fiction?

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#11

My experience...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>...is that this is true with WB poly over non-dewaxed (waxed!?) shellac. It can flake right off under a small amount of stress. I would think that the solvents in a solvent-based poly help to counter the effects of the wax in shellac.

Jason

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#12

Re: Per Michael Dresdner the waxed does

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>pose adhesion problems with oil based polyurethane. See his comments (copied from the Woodworkers Journal ezine) - http://www.woodworkersjournal.com/ezine/qanda.cfm

Advantages of Dewaxed Shellac vs. Shellac With Wax

Q: What are the advantages of dewaxed shellac over shellac with the wax still in it?

Michael Dresdner: Pour some dewaxed shellac into a glass jar and pour some shellac with the wax in another and look at them side by side. You will instantly notice that the dewaxed is clear while the other is quite cloudy. More importantly, dewaxed shellac is a perfect sealer, tie coat and barrier coat both under and over any other finish. Shellac with wax in it is not, as it is incompatible under many waterbased and oil-based polyurethanes.

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#13

Re: Per Michael Dresdner the waxed does

Steve Schoene

>That's what I assumed. Also, you see admonitions not to apply the polyurethane varnish over shellac (or lacquer) on a number of labels, since that implies selling less product, we can be pretty sure that there would be a problem. (Labels simplify a bit, since they don't mention that dewaxed shellac would be OK. But that's too hard a concept for consumers to grasp.)

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#14

Not clear blue

Michael Dresdner

>>> I think it odd that you would post this out of the clear blue.

It was not out of the clear blue. The day I posted it one of my online friends made mention of it in passing. I did not want to let the misconception stand, but I also did not want to embarrass my friend by pointing out his error in public in that thread, so I started another thread.

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#15

Polyurethane vs alkyd

Michael Dresdner

>Richard wrote:

Michael, I'd also appreciate it if you'd make a few comments on what some perceive as the poor quality of finish you get from polyurethane type varnishes. I get a bit tired of the mantra that polyurethane by its very nature is inferior to alkyd varnishes such as the Pratt and Lambert 38 range. The charges are usually along a mixture of the following lines: polyurethane is cloudy, plasticky looking, difficult to apply, not as tough, etc..

Sounds like another thread, Richard. Would you like to start it or shall I? (If you start it, drop me an email to let me know it exists. I don't always get in here but I will make the time.)

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#16

Re: Polyurethane vs alkyd

Sgian Dubh

>Michael, I'll start a new thread on the topic tonight after work and drop you a note. Slainte.

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#17

What is TSP ?

Bartee (metro Atlanta)

>I have to ask ?

Thinner ?

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#18

Re: What is TSP ?

Dan Donaldson

>trisodiumphosphate. It is a strong detergent that works well for stuff like cleaning walls prior to painting etc. to remove all of the grease/oils/dirt.

Re: Can we please end this polyurethane myth?

#19

Re: What is TSP ?

Jim Dillon

>Bartee,

TSP (trisodiumphosphate) is a strong cleaning agent that is often used in getting read of stubborn grime. It can be found your local Borg, hardware, or paint store.

Jim