Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

table saw vs band saw

Posts

table saw vs band saw

#1

table saw vs band saw

Lee Ohmart

>I stopped in NH to look at band saws on the way back from picking my son up from college. In talking with the salesman, he offered that one of the big debates in woodworking circles is whether the table saw or the band saw is the core machine in the shop. I guess I missed that topic. Anyway, his position was that the band saw could do almost anything the table saw could do more cleanly and more accurately. According to him, customers who bought a bandsaw found that they were using it more and their table saw less. He sounded convincing. My table saw is a 70's vintage Craftsman that I've made some upgrades to and it serves me well. Given the salesman's advice, the logical choice from his inventory is the Rikon 10-325. My area of interest is Mission and Arts and Crafts style furniture so the ease of tenoning on a bandsaw appeals to me. As O'Reilly would say, "What say you?"

Re: table saw vs band saw

#2

Re: table saw vs band saw

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I'm an intermediate woodworker so take my view for what it's worth. I had an old tilt head Craftsman bandsaw, I recently purchased a MiniMax MM-16. Comparing the two would be like comparing a Cadillac to roller skates. I have used the MM16 for various tasks, but I also have a Unisaw I purchased new 3 or 4 years ago. I personally think they complement - not duplicate or replace the other. I would not want to do all my ripping on the band saw. It would be very inconvenient in my opinion - I also am sure it would not cut a straight glue line joint like the Uni. Neither do I want to use the Uni for slicing veneer. The MM16 will slice a 1/16 off of a 16" thick board - the Uni won't. The Uni will dado - The bandsaw won't. IMHO - it would be kind of like saying my ROS will sand so I don't need a belt sander, disk sander, drum or Oscillating Spindle Sander etc. Yes both the Unisaw and the Bandsaw are made to make little boards out of big boards - but both do some things very well - others not so well.

Re: table saw vs band saw

#3

Re: table saw vs band saw

Hoa Dinh

>"his position was that the band saw could do almost anything the table saw could do more cleanly and more accurately."

He's wrong!

I think he mis-interprets or misunderstands the argument. It is, "If you could have one and only one stationary power saw, what would that be?"

How does he cut sheetgoods? How does he cuts boards ready for glue-up? How does he cut dados and rabbets? How does he cross-cut boards, say, 30" long?

The BS is arguably more versatile, but in general, not "more cleanly and more accurately."

The fact is that most of us start with a TS and add a BS later, and rightfully so. They compliment, not replace, each other. There is some overlap of their tasks, but one is better at a particular task than the other.

I still use my TS much more than my BS. There are projects in which I don't use the BS at all.

-- Hoa

Re: table saw vs band saw

#4

Re: table saw vs band saw

Barry Irby

>I don't want to hijack this thread, but I was about to post the very same question. I have a 14" Delta bandsaw and an ancient Rockwell/Delta contractors saw. I have a sort of love/hate relationship with the bandsaw. I think Larry nailed this. I can slice veneer with the bandsaw, but if I rip something with the BS, I have to joint it, but with a good blade on the TS I can often rip and glue up without jointing. The TS is therefore faster and saves me jointing each side of the BS cut. Perhaps I need to lean toward the Love side of the relationship and learn to get the most out of the BS. Can some of you who love the bandsaw share the magic?

Re: table saw vs band saw

#5

I don't understand why there should be a debate

Forrest Addy

>I don't understand why there should be a debate. A tablesaw and a bandsaw are complementary machines; one does what the other cannot conveniently do. They do not normally compete and the only debate for the woodworker is which to get first. That is decided by the first few projects.

Usually the table saw wins because more newbie woodworkers are interested in furniture and cabinetry. The boat builder would be more likely to need a bandsaw first but rest assured what ever machine is bought first the other is soon to follow.

The sales guy you spoke to is as usual for sales guys fulla - um - fertility.

Re: table saw vs band saw

#6

Re: table saw vs band saw

Chuck Lenz

>Aparently the sale person didn't know what he was selling. Does that surprise anyone ? The tablesaw gets wayyyyy more use in my shop than my band saw does. But thats just me. When you go into these places you need to know what you need. Don't depend on the sales people to know.

Re: table saw vs band saw

#7

Re: I don't understand why there should be a debat

Gary B

>I find this one interesting. I remember reading a bandsaw article by micheal fortune, where his old professor would claim that the bandsaw was the most important tool in the shop. I have used tablesaws in my professional carreer far more then a bandsaw. My conclusion is it must depend on what you build. If your a Chairmaker, then a bandsaw is probably it. If you do any straight furniture (especially mission style) or cabinets your going to want a tablesaw in your arsenal as well.

Re: table saw vs band saw

#8

Actually...

David Yoho

>Actually, to me it sounds like this salesman knew exactly what he was selling, or trying to sell.

I'm in agreement with Hoa. The debate should probably be about if you were starting from scratch and could only afford one saw, which would be the better purchase? I still think it would be the tablesaw. I also believe the two compliment each other but I've also built many projects where I never touched the band saw.

I suspect this guy had an agenda and fabricated something that sounded good to sell what he was trying to sell for whatever reason.

David

Re: table saw vs band saw

#9

Re: table saw vs bs

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Lee,

You can't cut curves on a table saw; if you try, you're asking for a trip to the hospital.

You can't match a table saw for its ability to make precisely repeated cuts with parallel edges. You can rip-cut on a bandsaw, but not with precision.

You can't match a good bandsaw for resawing and cutting veneer. I've seen people advocate resawing on a table saw, but, frankly, they scare the___out of me!

In the end, a well equipped wood shop should have both.

In order to "match" a good salesman's ability to create a nonissue to reinforce his pitch, you have to question his core premise. Most people fail to do that because it's the low-key part of the spiel, and they assume, since the guy "does this all the time," that he has more contact with the issues than they do. The "debate" he mentioned is a figment of his own imagination. A smart consumer will pass this kind of guy by because, having based his shtick on a lie, there's little reason to trust the rest of what he says to reinforce it.

mm

Re: table saw vs band saw

#10

One vote for bandsaw

wilbur

>My shop is small enough that I decided that I had room for one powered saw. I went with a bandsaw. Certainly, there are things that a tablesaw can do that a bandsaw cannot. Most of them have already been mentioned: cutting a glue line edge, cutting dadoes, quickly dealing with sheet goods, wide crosscutting. What made me go with a bandsaw was the realization that all of the above could be done with methods not involving a tablesaw:

Glue line edge: hand plane or jointer

Dadoes/rabbets: router or router plane

Cutting down sheet goods: circular saw to get close, then use bandsaw to cut to the line, or circular saw with straightedge guide

Wide crosscuts: same method as above

Also, as far as glue line edges go, try a 3/4" 10 tpi blade on plywood. You'll be surprised at the quality of the edge.

On the other hand, the one thing that a tablesaw is not good at -- cutting curves -- would require a bandsaw. Or, I guess, a jigsaw, but I'd rather have a bandsaw than a jigsaw. A jigsaw can't do resawing.

Besides, it's nice not having to worry about kickback.

One last thought: this decision ultimately depends on what you plan to make. If I were just knocking out 8 foot tall bookcases, I probably would be voting for tablesaw.

Re: table saw vs band saw

#11

As I said...

Forrest Addy

>As I said, there should be no debate on the topic of tablesaws Vs bandsaws among the sensible and competent. Tablesaws and bandsaws are complementary workshop machines. They each perform operations not easily performed on the other machine but with plenty of overlap.

Those who debate their merits too strenuously remind me of those medieval clerics who debated how many angels could dance on the head of a pin. Why choose up feature sets pertinent to shop machinery and defend/oppose them beyond rationality? Sooner or later the shop owner will need both machines to accomplish his work. They're shop equipment not tax money for school improvements Vs hiring more cops or flouridation or whatever issue spins your router.

Which machine is acquired first on a budget driven either/basis in a start-up shop is a decision that should be based on initial need.

However cool reason is often blown away by responses to "which is best..." questions. The question is asked out of innocent ignorance by someone needing to be informed so he can make a sensible purchase decision. Instead he's often overwhelmed by a deluge of insistant partisanship.

Re: table saw vs band saw

#12

Re: table saw vs band saw

David Sparks

>I used a Minimax bandsaw for many years to make craft items and some furniture before buying a table saw. I'm glad I have both now. As others have mentioned, if you use the bandsaw to rip wood to size you will have to joint the edges. The table saw is quicker because you can often skip te edge jointing. In my opinion the bandsaw is safer to use.

I have have friend who has a 36" Faye and Egan bandsaw that he has used to make some very fine furniture . He also saws bowl blanks and does a variety of other work. He doesn't own a table saw.

Re: table saw vs band saw

#13

Re: One vote for bandsaw

JimG

>Same here. Since space was a consideration for me I have a bandsaw and a Festool plunge saw/multifunction table.

jim

Re: table saw vs band saw

#14

Re: table saw vs band saw

Bartee ( Metro Atlanta )

>I have a Laguna HD16 with 4.5 HP motor and a trimaster blade.

I have found it excellent for all kinds of tenon work and ripping stock to size.

I too have a very old craftsman saw that does serve me well. I rather use it for cross cuts than the BS. Also ripping wide stock goes better on the TS rather than the BS.

The BS is the best investment I have made in my shop.

So I will always have both in my shop.

I recommend that you buy all you can. The Rikon's are getting good reviews. I have seen a lot of guys buying MM 16 bandsaws also.

Here is pic of my HD 16 and a little bit of my table saw. (click on image for full picture)


This is my table saw setup.


Re: table saw vs band saw

#15

Re: table saw vs band saw

Lee Ohmart

>Thanks for all the responses. In fact, I had already surmised that I was getting a "pitch." On the other hand, I really needed, and received, from the forum's collective wisdom whether or not I should buy a band saw that met the minimum or go for the best model I could afford. As a result of the discussion, I chose the latter. It's always interesting to me to toss out questions of this sort. They never fail to engender vigorous debate from which can all benefit.

Re: table saw vs band saw

#16

Re: table saw vs band saw

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Lee, I feel like I am like many others on this forum. I started out woodworking many years ago. I bought a lot of "gadgets" from Sears (Crapsman). Most didn't do work of the quality I wanted. I didn't have a lot of disposable income when raising my 6 children, so bought mostly cheap tools. Actually I would have been far better off buying used tools at auctions, as I ended up replacing almost every tool I purchased then. I now wait until I have the cash to buy a top quality tool. I have never feel regret a few months later - and often did when buying "Cheap" tools. If your limited on cash (and who isn't) for purchasing tools, and need several items, watch for estate sales and classified ads. You can often purchase a good saw for less than 1/2 price - if you need a table saw to start our with, I have bought old Craftsman, (IMHO better than their offerings today) for $5.00 at auctions. I have given away 2 of these - have a Unisaw now. It doesn't hurt as much to replace a $5 saw or a $75 band saw when you can afford better, and these are often better than todays "cheap" new tools.

Re: table saw vs band saw

#17

Oh, you can't leave us hanging

wilbur

>"On the other hand, I really needed, and received, from the forum's collective wisdom whether or not I should buy a band saw that met the minimum or go for the best model I could afford. As a result of the discussion, I chose the latter."

So, which bandsaw did you (or are planning to) get?

Re: table saw vs band saw

#18

Re: Oh, you can't leave us hanging

Lee Ohmart

>The Rikon 10-325