Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

Posts

Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#1

Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

John @ Doraville

>Fired up my 10" Delta BS up the other day and got "clackety clack". Seems the tires finally disintegrated. After pricing new ones I decided to take the plunge and upgrade. Trip to Highland Hardware put a Rikon 14" deluxe on board. Got her all put together in an evening but still have to do the guide bearing setup and give her a trial run. I also bought a 111" Woodslicer but it's too long for the saw. I plan to measure it today to see if I didn't get one that was mismarked. I measured the saw and it's right for the 111" recommended. Meantime I'm open for suggestions on other blades. Timberwolf comes to mind. I plan to use it mainly for ripping hardwood stiles and occasional resawing. Some curve cuts if the need arises. Figure to get at least 3 different blades to start. The Rikon sure has some nice features, including 13" resaw capacity without a riser block. Also 1 1/2hp motor and fairly nice fence and huge cast iron table.

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#2

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

Charles Self

>I've always had excellent results with Olsen (Olson?) blades, which are considerably lower in cost that the Timberwolf brand.

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#3

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

del schisler

>if we talking about a 10" saw the blade is 71 1/2" This what delta says

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#4

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

CharlesYawn

>John, I have had good results with the Timberwolf brand blade. The Woodslicer from Highland is also a blade worth the cost, and it has had good reviews by others. I used to think the bandsaw needed a 3/4" blade to do good resawing, but lately I have read opinions that a 1/2" is good enough. Have to try the 1/2" on some thick stuff and see. Charles in Duluth

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#5

for routine work....

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>For routine work a pricey blade makes no sense. For a 14" saw a Starrett or similar blade will do fine. In fact that is all I ever use for any band saw operation and one for your saw will be less than $10. Except for resawing I keep a 1/4" x 4tpi on the saw, or I may go 6 tpi for thin stock.

Somewhere in even a modest sized city will be a place that sells band saw blades and welds them on site to specifications. To find such a place ask at any cabinet shop or machine shop.

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#6

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

Curly Smith

>By all means measure the blade, sometimes you do get one that's a bit long (or short).

However, since it's a new saw you might want to check the blade tensioning "quick release" mechanism to make sure it's set up correctly. Maybe it's a really quick release...

FWIW, I use cheap blades (Olson) for my routine work and resharpen as needed. My bandsawing needs don't warrant the more expensive blades.

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#7

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

arw01

>He meant his new 14" Rikon, the old Delta he is not repairing.

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#8

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

arw01

>I bought a 3/4 Timberwolf some years ago and do not feel that I got a good life out of it. It was a fine and fast blade when sharp.

The 3/4 woodslicer is in a different league. WAY smoother cuts, but definetly slower.

After that I had a local shop weld up blades for under $10 each for various widths and tooth pitches.

Alan

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#9

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade? *LINK*

wilbur

>All you really need to know for bandsaw blade selection is that thick stock needs less teeth per inch, and curved cuts need thinner blades. A good rule of thumb is that for the smoothest cut, 6 teeth in the wood is best. For example, for cutting 3/4" thick stock, 6 teeth in 3/4" = 8 TPI.

I bought a set of Timberwolf blades for my bandsaw, mainly because I needed a custom length and they were the easiest way for me to get them. Also, they have a promotion right now that I took advantage of where if you buy 5 blades you get a free 3/4" 2-3 variable TPI blade.

I bought two 1/2" 6TPI blades for general cutting, two 1/4" 6 TPI blades for cutting curves, and a 3/4" 10 TPI blade for cutting plywood. The last was a wacky idea I had for cutting plywood because I don't have a tablesaw, but it works pretty well. The 3/4" 2-3 variable TPI blade is, of course, for resawing. If I had to do it over again, I'd probably get a 1/4" 6TPI and a 1/8" or 3/16" blade, instead of the two 1/4" blades.

The Timberwolf folks have a nice chart on their website that shows what each type of blade they sell is good for cutting what type of wood. All you need to do is figure out what kind of cutting you're doing, and find a blade to match. Here's the link:


Timberwolf blade selection chart

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#10

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

Falberg saw Co

>The sad truth is that there isn't a good blade in any universal sense. The blades I've heard recommended the most are suitable for only the simplest of tasks. Just about every cut you undertake is going to call for a specialized blade. In our on-going blade tests we've identified fourteen distinct set/pitch combinations that satisfy the full range of feed rate, smoothness, trackability, durability, and radius requirements you're likely to experience in your shop. I can't reveal more than that. The results we're seeing are no less than mind-boggling. There are patents pending and help is on the way. I could use some investment capital, if you're in a position to help. To those of you who have tried re-setting blades: beware over-tensioning; you can squeeze the set right off the wheel-side teeth. There will be another article on that when the research is finished.

My sons quit college to help on all this. Hooray! They're already over-educated and leaning towards liberal.

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#11

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

Chuck Lenz

>I fired up my JET 14" bandsaw last spring and got the clackity clack also, it wasn't the tires. It was from leaveing the tension on a 3/4" blade all winter. It bent the wheel pivoter on the axle houseing. The part wasn't available seperatly, I had to buy the assembly for about $50, which took a week to get here. That was a costly lesson. I'll never leave the tension on a blade again. Which reminds me, The JET 14" doesn't say anything in the manual about releaseing the tension on the blade and it doesn't have a quick release. But I have a small Delta bench top bandsaw that probably cost a fifth of what the JET cost me and that has a quick release. Go figure.

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#12

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Chuck, I seriously doubt leaving the tension on the blade caused your problem. Unless the part that was damaged was plastic or wood, leaving pressure on it should not have "bent" the part. Steel / iron has a yield point at which it will deform at a certain temperature. Until and unless you reach that point it will support the load without deformation. When you exceed the yield point it bends - immediately. I never release the tension on my saws. I have left an old craftsman in storage for a couple of years before with tension. I did have some flattening of the tire, but it disappeared in a few minutes of operation. I base my use of my saws on the experience from my work - we had several metal cutting band saws in the Tool-room, maintenance, and model shop. None were de-tensioned in the nearly 40 years I worked there. NONE appeared to have any detrimental effects from this practice. I haven't seen any definitive studies on the effects of repeated tensioning and de-tensioning but my thought is that it may actually cause early blade failure as the blade is stretched and shrinks every time this occurs. This may cause fatigue in the metal. Not sure what caused your problem -possibly a defective design or part.

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#13

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

Chuck Lenz

>Larry, there was a 3/4" blade in there so the tension was set high, maybe too high, I can't remember. I've also heard some people say to release the tension after a days use, but that was after the part broke and I did some asking around. The issue seems to be as debateable as push sticks in the woodworking circles. I wonder what the blade or bandsaw manufacturers have to say. When I took the part into a well known woodworkers and contractor supply store, the parts guy said he never seen that particular part fail like that before when I asked him. After I finally got the part I looked at the failed part and the new part side by side. Jet had modified the new part where the old one failed. Coincedence ? That clickity clack was the spokes of the wheel rubbing on it. The part looks to me like cast aluminum. I wish it was steel.


img

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#14

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I would guess your right - seems odd they would modify an existing part unless they have had some failures in the field. As to your question of Band saw & blade manufacturer's recommendations - I have never seen any reference in the band saw manuals or books recommending blade de-tensioning after use. I do think the "quick release" was in response to the folk lore that the tension needed to be released on the blade when not in use. It makes no more sense to me than backing off the arbor nut on my Unisaw when it isn't in use. (take the tension off the shaft). I am a retired Manufacturing engineer, if there is any benefit to the release of tension - I don't know what it is. I wonder if the idea started when the bandsaw tires were make of an inferior rubber or urethane - possibly the tires "cold flowed" or flat spotted permanently on some old machines if high tension was left on the blade too long?

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

#15

Re: Bandsaw upgrade - which blade?

Chuck Lenz

>The quick release could be for quicker blade changes.