Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Electrical Information CORRECTION

Posts

Electrical Information CORRECTION

#1

Electrical Information CORRECTION

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I'm posting this to bring it to the top of the Board because only a few people have seen the follow up message I put in the original thread started by Sawdust about allowed wiring.

"Well, Mr. Everywhere, I spoke to my local Code Dude and an electrician who I trust, and here's what I got back:

A. The 4-wire cable is, as before, absolutely REQUIRED for your double 110 setup.

B. You can switch the 220 circuit cable "upstream" with a Single-Throw-Double-Pole switch as long as it is disconnecting both hot leads of a single circuit and the switch is rated for the same or greater amperage as the circuit breaker.

C. You can have 2 circuits wired to separate halves of the same receptacle PROVIDED that both hot leads are controlled by a single breaker IN THE SERVICE PANEL, i.e. 2 breakers that are "bridged" like a 220 breaker, and the conductor tabs on the duplex ARE REMOVED to separate the 2 sockets from one another.

D. If the duplex receptacle being used is the only one on the circuit, it's rating must match the total amp load of the circuit breaker. So, if the 220 circuit's breaker is a 20 amp, then the duplex receptacal at the end of the line MUST be rated for 20 amps.

E. Even if you have a 4-wire cable, you shall NOT split it into two discrete circuits with independent breakers on each branch. The breakers MUST be linked/bridged. To use two independent breakers, the present cable must be removed from the service panel and replaced with 2 separately sheathed cables.

I think that corrects all the incorrect information I posted earlier."

I'll go back to my corner now. . . .

MM

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#2

Re: Thanks Mark

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Mark, I appreciate the time and effort you spent finding and posting the correct information (at least for your area) . Unfortunately misleading information regarding the proper wiring procedures is rampant on the web. Much of the information posted is quoted form second or third party postings � The original poster may have received his information from Uncle George. I have also found that some municipalities have requirements that do not in any way reflect the NEC manual. Often these requirements are set as local ordinances by people that have no personal knowledge of the NEC, but instead write the ordinances due to pressure from local interest groups. Case in point was that several years ago certain costal states (going from a long ago memory) passed a requirement that new residential wiring must be made in Conduit. A few year later the conduit corroded due to the salt air, lost the grounding capability and actually shorted to the high side. This caused electrocution of dome people before the conduit was banned. IMHO the original ordinance was passed due to the Electrical Union and conduit manufactures pressures. I have even ran into inane requirements in the city I now live in due to uneducated �inspectors� setting standards that are in no way related to the NEC requirements (or even common sense). However, you must follow them to have the wiring �approved� (I have actually changed some wiring after approval � to follow NEC code).

I received my wiring education starting in the 1950�s � working with a cousin that was a lineman � then head of the transformer shop, for NIPSCO. (One of the largest providers of electrical service in Indiana.) I also took courses in Electrical / Electronics at Coyne in Chicago, and then worked for about 40 years using the NEC manual � doing residential, commercial and industrial wiring. I haven�t kept up with the code for the last few years as I no longer do any wiring for anyone else � except family residential. One of my Grandson�s is currently working as an electrician and taking all the courses to become a Union Journeyman so I will probably pass these tasks on to him.

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#3

Re: Thank You!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Larry,

If you hadn't called me to task a little bit, I might have easily gone on relying on what amounted to what now begins to look like several "Uncle Georges" had told me over the years. I try to be accurate about what information I pass on, and am always willing to stop, back up, and check what I think I "know." I reeeeely hate giving inaccurate information, and think it is everyone's obligation to correct themselves whenever possible.

MM

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#4

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

Barry Irby

>Mark, as some of the people here on WC know, I am a Home Inspector in VA. A private one, not a Code Inspector employed by the government. From what I know, you got your information correct.

I spend a lot of time trying to sort out what is correct and what is simply believed to be true.

Using the four wire dual 120 volt set up was popular here in kitchens for a while but fell out of favor. Maybe because they also had to be GFCI protected and it just added a layer of complexity.

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#5

Thanks Mark

Sawdust Everywhere

>

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#6

Re: No Sweat

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I also sent you an e-mail with the same stuff. Misinformation, and especially wrong information must be corrected, so "he who dealt it . . . . "

|;-}}

mm

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#7

Re: GFCI - Yi Yi

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>When I ripped out our master bath and put a new soak tub, I had to put in two discrete 220 25amp GFCI circuits (pump and heater), each on a home run to the breakers on 8ga wire, and then the entire install and all tub components had to be bound with 6ga copper and separately grounded to the water system. Damn breakers were $50+ each!

|;-}

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#8

My local inspector said the same...

John in New Mexico

>The shared common can apparently confuse the GFIC circuit.

John

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#9

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

Rich in St. Louis

>Hello! If I understand what you are saying correctly you are feeding the two halves of an outlet from a two pole (bridged) breakerand breaking the tabs between them. If you check the voltage between the two hots on the outlet you should have 220 volts which you can not put on a outlet rated for 125 volts! Unless you are refering to a tandem breaker which is a double breaker that only takes up a single breaker space then your okay.

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#10

Confusion

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>No Rich, that's not what we're talking about. In order to get 220 out, you'd have to bridge the two sockets for some unknown reason, but each socket would still be "supplying" only half of the 220 you were pulling.

The original question was splitting a switched 220 feeder line to make a pair of 110 subcircuits, and then using them to feed each side of a single duplex receptacle, into which the poster was proposing to plug his 110 router table and 110 shopvac. While there is, indeed, 220 coming into the outlet box, only 110 is being fed to each socket of the duplex which is allowed so long as the duplex's amp rating matches the rating of the service panel's single breaker that controls the entire feed.

Scroll down the page to the "Is This Allowed" thread started by Sawdust Everywhere so you understand the original question.

mm

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#11

Re: Confusion

Rich in St. Louis

>Your not just bringing 220 to the box your your putting it on the device! You can not do that if the device is only rated for 125 volts!

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#12

Re: Confusion

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Rich - it's obvious your confused. Residential electrical entrances have 3 wires connected plus an earth ground. One is the neutral. It is normally colored white. The other two wires are the "hot or line". Either will measure 110V - 120 Volt to the neutral. The neutral (white wire) is connected to the earth ground (normally green or bare copper) so any measurement you make will be the same when using the "ground" or "neutral". When you measure between the two "hot" lines there is 220 - 240 volt. The line to your Electric range or clothes dryer has 220 volts at the heat elements, they connect it across the two "hot or Line" wires. The light bulb and timer motor run on 120 Volt - these are connected across one (either one will work) "hot or line" wires and the "neutral". The earth ground is not used to carry any current - it is there only for safety - in case of a short from a line to the case of an appliance it will keep you from getting electrocuted. The thread the above posts are in reference too, asked if you could use a 120 volt duplex (one outlet on top - one on the bottom) outlet by removing the tie bars of the receptacle (between the top and bottom outlets) and putting one hot line on the (brass) screws of the top and one hot line on the bottom outlet brass screw with the neutral on the other screws - This will result in two (2)120 Volt outlets fed by two (2) hot lines with one neutral. This has been - will be - and is done quite often. Some restrictions are required by code - such as the type breaker used etc. Read the original post for more information.

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#13

Re: Clarification [I hope]

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Rich,

When you break the duplex connectors off, each "socket" operates as a separte device. Thus, solong as the amperage rating of the entire device is rated to handle what the breaker will allow through, and so long as you connect the 2 separate hot leads only to the two separate "hot" terminals on the duplex, you are, in that situation only supplying 110 to either of the sockets.

As stated before, you must have a 4-wire feed to do this, such that the hot BLACK wire is connected to one socket's hot terminal, the hot RED wire is connected to the other socket's hot terminal, the WHITE common wire is split and connected to both white terminals, and the bare ground goes to both the box and the duplex strap. I suspect you are thinking about 220 lines that are only 3-wire where all you have are 2 hot feeds and a ground. In that instance you cannot, indeed, safely and legally spit and therefore reduce the voltage.

I hope this clears it up for you, but I certainly don't want to argue about it. I suggest you speak to a licensed electrician or electrical inspector for the explanation.

Peace

mm

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#14

Re: Confusion

Rich in St. Louis

>No I'm not confused!If you fed this duplex from a two pole breaker....one hot to each brass terminal with the connecting tab removed then you have 220 volts on that duplex and that is a code violation putting 220 volts on a device rated for only 125 volts! I'm not saying this isn't done but it is a violation and DANGEROUS! You can bring two circuits to a duplex if they are from the same hot leg in your panel but then you can not share the nuetral!

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#15

Re: Clarification [I hope]

Rich in St. Louis

>NO ! The duplex has a voltage rating which pertains to the insulating properties within the device. this device is not rated for 220 volts! Your current rating is not the problem.

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#16

Re: Clarification [I hope]

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Rich, it is obvious to me that you don't understand the properties of the insulator that is used in outlets. It is the same insulator used in the referenced outlet that is used in any of the 220 identified outlets.

What makes the referenced outlet a 110v outlet is the configuration of the outlet prongs not the insulation material.

Howard

Materials Engineer by training and 40+ years of experience

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#17

Re: Clarification [I hope]

Rich in St. Louis

>Howard...clearly you don't understand the NEC. which clearly states not to use devices or equipment for voltages or loads they are not designed for. These codes are designed primarily for the safety of the user and the person servicing the equipment or devices! I'm an electrician not an engineer!

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#18

Where do you expect to measure the 220?

John in New Mexico

>You will get either 110 or 220 with the set up described, depending on where you place the test leads. This sort of set up is done all the time, is 2005 NEC compliant, and my local inspector did actually suggest it to me when we were discussing wiring a laundry room. The only reason I ran two cables instead is that if I find that arc fault breakers don't have lots of nuisance trips I may slowly upgrade my breakers til they're all arc faulters -- and I'm assuming I could have the same problems with them as with GFCI's on a shared common.

John

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#19

Re: Clarification [I hope]

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Rich, I am an Engineer - also worked as an electrician for several years on the side. In my job at Emerson - (Mallory Appliance controls) I built many 120 and 220 volt switches and components (UL and CSA compliant) The voltage rating of a receptacle is not totally related to the insulation capability. In fact almost all devices rated 120 will withstand a 1500 Volt Hipot test. This is required from ground to any portion of the device that may be connected to a hot wire. When the connector buss is removed there is about a 1/4 " between the now disconnected devices screws - way more than required for 220V. I do not have an NEC code manual in my possession any longer as I am retired, but several people did check and I was assured it is legal and according to code.

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#20

GENTLEMEN . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>May I suggest that you Sparkies move this "discussion" to your e-mail accounts, fire NEC code sections, chapters, and verse at each other at will, and perhaps arrive at a consensus on the issue that you can then report back to us, whilst preserving Ellis' bandwidth for woodworking? Frankly, I'm feeling a bit guilty that I even started this thread.

C'mon, guys, let's lighten up a bit here.

mm

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#21

Re: GENTLEMEN . . .

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Mark, no reason to feel guilty at all. It is a legitimate discussion that just shows that tradesmen/inspectors around the country do not always follow the same rules. As someone who spent 20 years representing their employer on an international standards setting board I realize that standards are not always interpreted the same by everyone.

Howard

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#22

Re: Clarification [I hope]

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Larry, I know that you are correct. I also know that the NEC is interpreted differently by different people. I spent 20 years representing my employer on International Standard Committees. It isn't easy getting industry agreement on what words should be used in a standard and I appreciate how tradesmen/inspectors can have problems with the intent of standards.

Howard

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#23

Please cite…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…which section of the NEC you assert is being violated. It seems to me that the situation described is specifically addressed by the NEC, in part as to the circuit breaker requirement (duplex breaker) for opposite phase feeds to a single yoke (the term the NEC uses to describe exactly what's going on here), and the multiwire provision (shared neutral).

The fact that the device (yoke) is rated at 120V means that in the case of a duplex receptacle, each section is rated at 120V. It would have to be. The voltage on a duplex receptacle is not divided. Since each of the sections is rated at 120V it does not matter one whit (and cite the NEC if you're going to disagree) which bus the 120V comes from so long as the tab is broken if each section is fed from opposite buses.

Rod

Addy Protocol: experienced amateur electrician

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#24

1990 NEC 210-4 Multiwire Branch Circuits

DB

>Clearly allows this wiring system.

When you break the tabs on the outlet it is like you are making two seperate outlets and niether half should ever see more than 110 volts.

If you had the two hot conductors on the same polarity (phases) then you will need to double the current carrying capacity of the neutral conductor.

But then, your local codes may very from the NEC. What is better is to be determined by your local AHJ.

DB with 20 years of electrical experience.

Re: Electrical Information CORRECTION

#25

Well . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Since I wanted to make sure the corrections were posted in a way that afforded the most people who might have read the other thread to now see the correction, getting this thread stuck at the top of the Board for 3 days kind of fulfilled my goal. Just don't want anybody going postal over this.

Peace

MM