Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Telling Red Oak from White Oak

Posts

Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#1

Telling Red Oak from White Oak

Barry Irby

>Is there any sure fire way to tell Red oak from White Oak. I went to a saw mill and bought some "white oak" to make a trailer floor for my cousin. I was a little doubtful about the wood, but the sawyer seemed knowledgeable. When I asked if he had any 8/4 white oak 14' long he immediately asked if I were making a trailer floor. Said he sawed it as one of his stock items and had it stacked in the right quantities. Seemed to be my man. I bought it, knowing it was somewhat green, but did not care, because it could dry in place. When I saw it, I was a little skeptical, but I took him at his word. It rotted. Within a year or less. Before I get taken again, I want to know how to sort them out for sure. I heard there was a chemical that you could put on the wood and it turned black on one or the other. Anyone know how to tell for sure?

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#2

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

Gary Camp - Bend, Oregon

>Barry, you should be able to cut a small piece of Red oak with the grain, say 3/4" by 3/4 by 6" long (it should be fairly straight grained) and immerse one end in water and blow bubbles through it. The pores of White Oak are generally plugged with Tylosis and Red Oak pores are not.

have fun blowing bubbles

glc

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#3

JL

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

JL

>The only "chemical" that I am familiar with that will turn white oak black is a solution of an iron salt (or any iron compound). The iron will react with the tannic acid to turn black. Of course red oak has tannic acid also, just not as much. The grain of red oak is more open and also somewhat coarser than that of white oak. I usually go by color and if I am in doubt, I scrape it. If you have a small pocket plane, they come in handy.

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#4

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

Greg B�tit, Crown Point NY

>The reason red oak rots is because the pores run open for great lengths through the wood. You can cut off a 6-10" piece and use it as a straw. Not so white oak.

Looking at the end grain, the large earlywood pores of red oak are larger and can be up to four pores in width than white oak early wood pores, which are up to three pores in width. But the big difference is in the tiny latewood pores- red oak's are "countable", white oak's latewood pores are too tiny and numerous to be seen by this old guy's naked eye.

Hoadley's Understanding Wood has adjacent pictures of what I just described & a quick look will make you a red/white oak discerner for the rest of your life.

greg

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#5

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

eliot d

>Probably not as useful as the other answers , but turners all know that red oak is "chippy" when turned ,while white oak is not. So we like white oak -- not red oak -- for tool handles, for example.

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#6

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak,more

Barry Irby

>What I need is something I can use at the sawmill. I doubt I will be able to cut a small piece off a 2x8 14 and blow bubbles through it.

Maybe Hoadley's book will do the trick.

I am embarrassed that I allowed this guy to screw me on this pile of wood and I intend to get the right stuff and replace the crap I got last time. My cousin paid for it last time. This time I will pay for it myself and rectify my mistake.

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#7

Re: Try Black Locust

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have a lot of White Oak in my shop, also use some Black locust for outdoor projects. The locust is cheaper, harder and more rot resistance than the WO. If you have it in your area I would sure consider it as a better choice. It seems a little heavier than the Oak, and is just as pretty when finished. I really like working with it, think its cheaper because not too many people know about it & ask for it for furniture.

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: Barry....

Dale Lenz

>make sure you get heartwood in your white oak, browish in color. Sap wood, whitish in color, of either red or white oak will rot quickly outdoors.

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#9

Re: Try Black Locust

Barry Irby

>Larry, this is not furniture, it�s a trailer floor. The kind of trailer you haul a backhoe on. Maybe I should have made this an OT, but at least it is a wood question.

Black locust would probably be fine, but I wonder if you can find it 8/4 and 14' long?

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#10

Re: Barry....

Barry Irby

>Dale, thanks, this may be the Ah Ha! moment. I bought this wood from a guy who insisted it had only been sawed for a "little while", so recently that he had not stacked it properly yet. It had white mold on it which he insisted was just on the surface. The mold came right off in a sheet.

I (foolishly) took it and cut it down to size for the trailer and my cousin picked it up. I suggested they treat it with "green post preservative from the orange borg and even gave them a gallon. My thinking at the time was that if there were superficial mold on the surface that would knock it out. They did that and told me they put several gallons on it. Clearly it was worst than I thought and may have had more sapwood that I realized, and I did not know there was such a distinction in the rot resistance in the heart and sapwood.

This has been a year or two. I just remembered that I may have a piece of wood in the shop that was a scrap. If I come across it I may cut out a section and see if I can blow bubbles through it.

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#11

White Oak is best.

Basil

>....and floor the trailer length wise, not across. If you floor cross ways it's more subject to split and splinter up, especially with 'cleats'(buldozers and other tracked stuff). Bolt it down 'green' so when the dirt and mud get wet and hold moisture to the wood, it won't expand and push the trailer apart. It's according to what size boards you use as to what the width of the crack between the boards will be when they dry out. If it's dry when you put it on be sure to allow plenty of crack between boards for expansion.

The last lowboy I floored I used 3" X 12" X 17' white oak. Sawed the tree down in the morning, sawed log that afternoon and floored the trailer that night. That floor lasted until I sold the trailer 15 years later. Wish I had a dollar for every time I loaded a dozer or other piece of equipment on that trailer. Boy! Would I go shopping for some woodworking equipment.

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#12

Re: Try Black Locust

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Yeah Barry, Black locust is available in this area (Central IN) in 4/4 & 8/4. My son & I have picked up quite a few 8 - 12' lengths in 6 - 12" widths - we buy mostly 4/4 but did get a couple 8/4. The lumber yard where I buy is Hollingsworth in Russiaville. They do sell some green, though they stock a lot more KD. They told us a lot of people in the area have used the BL for decks. Per their information, it holds up better than Redwood or treated.

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#13

Forest Products Lab

Tom Dunlap in Atlanta

>Google to find the FPL website. I would bet dollars to donuts that there is something on their website to help with the ID.

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#14

The nose knows

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Red oak shavings or sawdust will have a definite smell of puke, stonger when fresh cut, weaker when dried. White oak smells like a barn filled with straw on a hot summer day.

Re: Telling Red Oak from White Oak

#15

& cinamon when sanded ( red oak ).

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>