Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

Posts

OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#1

OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Sorry for the OT but I know there are a couple photographers her and I also am curious as to what others might have to say about the following - in other words I'm looking for opinions from non-photographers as well as photographers. I've been taking pictures since I was in junior high - I'm 45 now. I used to do all my black & white and color processing in the gold old days. Heck, I remember making shoe box cameras! I've been around cameras my whole life thanks to my dad. So I'm not a newB to photography but last night something happened to me that I've never had happen.

I took my 15 year old daughter to the local park last night to let her play around a little with my D70s and my new 70-300VR Nikkor lens. She was taking pictures of young children playing soccer. As we were leaving a women walked up and asked her what she was doing and what she was going to do with the pictures as her son was in the group of kids. My quick response was that she is just practicing and the images would probably be deleted. In todays day and age, the women has a valid concern and quite frankly I don't blame her. I would probably be concerned too.

Later though I was wondering to myself if I did anything wrong. Should we not have been taking pictures of kids in the park? Is there something wrong with that? Or, since you are in a public place are you fair game to have your picture taken? What if my daughter got one of those fantastic human interest shots that maybe she could have entered into a photo contest or something?

What are the social rules for this (here in the US)? What rights do I have and what rights do the subjects have? I suppose if I had plans on selling the photo I would have to have a release, but we were really doing photojournalism. My daughter could have been taking pictures to accompany a story of kids in the park playing for a local newspaper or something. Of course, if that was the case, I would have told the women that. But the point is, if you are in a public place, are you fair game to have your picture taken in the name of photojournalism?

I don't know the answer. I've posted a similar question on a Nikon/photography forum I like but I'm curious as to what some of my WC friends opinions are.

Thanks.

Joe

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#2

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

Doug

>Don't take pictures without the parent's permission... in advance

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#3

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

Paul Woolson

>Like you I have been around cameras my whole life. My dad owned/edited/published a newspaper as his dad before him and his dad before him.

I don't know the legality of what you are asking but I know the policy of one, and I'm guessing many newspapers.

Did you ever notice that the photo caption almost always has the person's name in it? That's because the photographer has to seek permission to print the phtoto and by printing the name, he/she has shown that he has talked to the person and that person has agreed to have their photo printed.

You are correct that a public place is pretty much fair game to take pics of whatever/whomever you want. But for those pics to be published, one has to get permission. This is true in pretty much all cases. For example, if a plane crashes and there are a bunch of people standing around the wreckage when the photo is taken, the photographer must do all he/she can to get permission from everyone that will appear in the photo. The caption might read John Doe, his wife Jane and their children Manny, Moe and Jack look on with several unidentified people as a plane burns.

Now, as I said before, I have no idea of the legalities of this mess. But I know this is the policy of many news agancies.

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#4

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

Scott in Douglassville

>You're in public, you lose your right to anonymity. If you were going to sell the photos, you'd need a release, mainly to cover the publisher's tail. Or, you could turn around and offer prints to the parents of the kids in the shots. But you can take the photos for private use without any parental authorization.

That said, it always pays to be friendly and accomodating. I, too, would be pissed if someone was taking shots of my kids and using them without my knowing. Wouldn't change my rights at all, but pissed I'd be.

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#5

Re: Where you cross the line is.......

Jamie Donaldson

>... when you attempt to market the person's image as a commercial product, such as an advertising campaign, without their permission. That becomes an invasion of privacy, but these days so many people are sensitive about all manner of loss of personal privacy that the best policy is to always get mermission and releases.

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#6

Re: Dang it, another typo-"permission!"

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#7

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

Hank Knight from SC

>Jamie is correct: the legal issue involved is the privacy interest. Generally one has a right to privacy where there is "reasonable expectation" (lawyer words) of privacy. If one appears in public, the "reasonable expectation" is diminished, I.E., one probably does not have an invasion of privacy complaint if his/her photograph is taken in a public place. However, one's privact interest in his/her image or likeness is a little different. One has the right to not have his or her image or likeness misappropriated, I.E., used for someone else's personal advantage, whether financial or otherwise, without permission. In short, you can probably take photos of a soccer game, but before you use the images for your own gain or personal advantage, you need permission from the subject. I don't think "personal advantage" extends to keeping the photographs in your personal photo album or collection for your private viewing. It would extend to selling the image or publishing the it, whether or not you are paid for it.

That is the legal analysis. From a practical standpoint, given the hypersensitivity we all have to privacy issues these days, it's probably not a bad idea, where practical, to assure the subject(s) of your photographs that you have no evil motive or intent, especially if the subject matter involves children (talk to the parents). You may have the legal right to take the photograph, but it's often easier to convey your good will and innocent motive at the outset to avoid ruffled feathers or worse, having to prove you had the right in court.

Hank

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#8

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Thanks for that Hank.

On another topic -highjscking my own post- didn't you tell me you saw Bob Dylan at Newport way back when?

He is (finally) coming to Cleveland. I bought tickets for myself and my daughter (she's 15 and we are both fans). We can't wait. She is so excited!

Joe

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#9

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

Hank Knight from SC

>Yes, I've seen Dylan several times. He continues to be great. He was in Columbia a couple of years ago and LOML and I got tickets. His son's band (Blues Traveler IIRC)was booked the next day and our daugher had come home from D.C. to see him. Kaye and I took a deep breath and gave her our Dylan tickets, so she got to see father and son, back to back.

BTW, I read that Joan Baez was barred from performing for the troops at Walter Reed Hospital this week. What a shame.

Let me know how the Cleveland Concert goes.

Hank

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#10

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

John Lucas

>A good question and you and your kid did no wrong. "In the public domain" covers your taking the pictures. If they wanted not to be in the pics, they could politely ask you but not demand. You could say I am shooting kids in the playground for my own shooting enjoyment and you can walk away.

Where that changes when you are taking them and plan to use them. If you will use them on a web page, as I do, you need a model release which is a contract between the two of you and you usually pay $1.00 or more for the contract to be valid. The contract will also specify the intended use. For people on my site I say "for use on the website and/or DVDs pertaining to woodworking.

When I am at Woodcraft or somewhere in the public, I always ask for permission but do not drag out a model release. If one of the people sees the picture and they don't like it, I will gladly pull it down, but I have not been unlawful in my actions. My asking the person is a form of contract.

I hope this is clear. I have been doing this since 1955 or so and I have always had a packet of model releases with me. Camera stores sell them or you can get on line.

Here is one I use. I have just insert my info in it.

(my letterhead)

Model Release

For valuable consideration, I hereby consent to and authorize the use and reproduction by you, of anybody authorized by you, of any and all photographs, motion pictures, and/or video footage which you have taken of me this day or subsequent days for any purpose whatsoever, without further compensation to me. All negative and positives, together with prints, copies or other resulting materials, shall constitutes our property, solely and completely.

(signatures, etc)

I hope this helps

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#11

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

david cramer

>I didn't read all the responses, but I can tell you this first hand. If you're out in the public, you're fair game. I have been to the police station 5 times in the last year over this exact situation. If someone wants to videotape you and put you on YouTube or GoogleVideo, they can and you are helpless to do anything. I didn't say it was right or wrong, but that's the way it is. I didn't like it either, but the police department said there is nothing you can do unless they are videotaping you from the outside and zooming "in" on your house. The outside of your house is okay, believe it or not.

Let's just say I've gotten to know a lot of law enforcement people as of late, and that is the answer I've been given over and over. I was helpless to do anything about it, period. Fair it ain't, but unfortunately it's not illegal or even considered a grey area. For those who go over the line and with bad intentions, they have the upperhand. I was told "to bad for you pal". When you involve someone's children, like mine, I get a little angry. They said they felt my pain, but could do nothing.

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#12

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

Charles Self

>Actually, permission of the subject is not normally needed for editorial use of the photographs. For advertising or other commercial purposes, a signed model release is essential. For editorial, no. That said, most editors want one simply because it eliminates one possible wrinkle that could mess up a smooth transaction fabric.

In today's world, taking shots of children whose parents you don't know, and without advance permission, is a pretty bad idea, though. It's not illegal, but that's not going to help if some over-wrought and over-protective mother maces you and calls you a pervert.

I am not sure how bad a problem child porn actually is, but today's parents often act as if any shots of their kids might end up on a porn site on-line. And, too, there are the real pervs out there. Again, I'm not sure how much of a danger that is, either.

Child protection is an emotion-ridden subject and facts often get lost in the discussion.

Best bet: don't take shots, or let your kids take shots, of other people's kids unless you ask in advance.

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#13

Thanks all!

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#14

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

Hank Knight from SC

>David,

Publishing your photograph or image without your permission is not a criminal act, so the police have no interest in complaints of that sort. It may, however, be a tort ( a civil wrong ) for whch you may have a remedy in civil court. The tort is invasion of privacy by misappropriation of your image or likeness.

Hank

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

#15

Re: OT - John Lucas and other Photogs - LONG

david cramer

>Thanks Hank. I've talked to 3 attorneys and one who specializes in defamation type of lawsuits. The police told me over and over that I can go after this guy in a civil suit, but it will be very difficult to win in this day and age of technology and the laws or lack of that go along with it. Thanks for the reply. Much appreciated!

David