Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT:Our Curious People

Posts

OT:Our Curious People

#1

OT:Our Curious People

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Anyone here catch the PBS two part story on The American Experience about the Mormons? What did you think?

Stephen

N.B. As a disclaimer, I have been a Mormon, I am not currently an Active Mormon, but I do Play one on my day job.

Re: OT:Our Curious People

#2

Re: OT:Our Curious People

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>I often watch The American Experience, a great show, I missed this one..

Take care,

Jim

Re: OT:Our Curious People

#3

Re: OT:Our Curious People

CARL BARTON

>I enjoy watch PBS and this show, but it starts at 9pm and runs to 11pm, way too late for someone who gets up at 4am each day for work, I am in the Navy stationed in Virginia. I am orignally from Idaho and went to Snow College in Utah so shows like this I am very intrested in. I hope to catch this show at a better time.

Carl

Re: OT:Our Curious People

#4

Re: OT:Our Curious People

Rich Glisson, Durham NC

>Stephen--I watched most of it and was rather dumbfounded. For those not familiar, Joseph Smith dug up the "golden tablets" in Palmyra NY and translated them by putting a "special stone" in a top hat and sticking his face inside the hat. He wrote down what he saw in the stone and it came to 400 pages and that is the Book of Mormon.

Okaaaaayyyyy, well that seems plausible.

Oh, and they also believe the Garden of Eden was in Independence, Missouri.

Re: OT:Our Curious People

#5

Re: OT:Our Curious People

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>There's so much about LDS to understand, I don't think it's possible for an outsider to grasp it all. I have had several good friends who are, and it does help understand their beliefs better.

I'm a practicing agnostic, and have a high degree of skepticism about many religious claims, practices and beliefs. LDS is no different, except to say that I have a particularly difficult time with any religion that shrouds so much in secrecy and near mysticism. But that's just me.

All successful religions celebrate and support the values of the societies in which they are found. Mormonism is no different, perhaps with a better emphasis on the role of and support for families. It was interesting to note, though, how official practice of the church changed dramatically in several instances to reflect changing values in America, to wit, the acceptance of black members where previously they were claimed to be agents of Satan.

As far as founding myths are concerned, those myths are a matter of faith, (here, I'm using "myth" anthropologically, which is to say that myths are the stories we tell about ourselves that reveal some fundamental value, e.g., Joseph Campbell and The Power of Myth). I have a hard time accepting them, preferring fact and logic over very hard-to-swallow origin stories. But I don't need to accept them, because I'm a non-believer. It's only important insofar as they are fundamental to believers and to how those myths help explain the total package.

I watched the whole series and was fascinated. As usual, PBS did a wonderful job and service. More than that, though, is that LDS represents a significant and growing segment of the country and it's important that we understand it.

Apologies in advance if I have offended anyone.

Bruce, a practicing anthropologist.

Re: OT:Our Curious People

#6

Re: It is logical to state that.........

Jamie Donaldson

>....most of the religions of the world are creations of that society which encode the norms and ideals which reflect that society. Man often searches for a higher authority within that society other than himself,both as a means of establishing some rules of non-destructive social conduct,and as a vehicle for establishment and understanding of desired behavior for the benefit of the individual and the larger group.It's seldom that simple when societies collide, and the resulting conflicts as to which society prevails are the history of mankind.

And I'm a practicing philosopher!

Re: OT:Our Curious People

#7

Re: OT:Our Curious People

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>What did YOU think? Was it fair, honest, accurate, thorough?

bruce

Re: OT:Our Curious People

#8

Re: OT:Our Curious People

Tom Stockton

>Wow

This is the most civil post on religion I've ever seen. Sorry I missed the show I just finished reading a book on fundementalist mormoms (which in no way shape or form are associated with mainstream mormons or LDS) called "Under the banner of heaven" by Jon Krakuer he goes into the beginings of the church which I found interresting because I didn't know anything about it.

I think what is interesting is that it is a modern relegion in that it was founded in the last 300 years, so the documentation and written history are relativly fresh so it's easy to find history on it.

Tom

Re: OT:Our Curious People

#9

Re:It'll probably repeat

Kneale Brownson in Northern MI

>I watched some on and off. I think I saw most of it previously.

Pretty typical story of the development of any religion.

Re: OT:Our Curious People

#10

Re:A 2 part presentation

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>the second two hours hit the TiVo in the middle of the night last night. Watching it with interest.

Re: OT:Our Curious People

#11

Re: It is logical to state that.........

Don in Central Illinois

>Jamie, the last 'practicing philosopher' I heard about was Mel Brooks in "History of Earth, Part 1" but the lady at the unemployment office used different wording. Just curious.

Re: OT:Our Curious People

#12

Re: OT:Our Curious People

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>What did YOU think? Was it fair, honest, accurate, thorough?

What do I think, well�

Was it fair? I do think that it showed a decent history and discussed most of the relevant issues. The �mysteries� or �secret ceremonies� I think get a little too much attention, they are merely sacred religious rites that are not generally shared with the public. There is nothing weird or unusual about them, believe me.

Was it honest? Again there was nothing I could disagree with in the presentation; I do think that they did portray �a curious people� in a good light. While some examples were mentioned like the �Mountain Meadow Massacre� not enough detail of the incident was accurately explained, perhaps this fall when a major motion picture is to be released about the event will shed some new light. Not sure but I think it will be called �September Dawn� which occurred on September 11, 1857. One hundred twenty two men, women and children were slaughtered by a group of rouge Mormons (and alleged Native Americans, the Piute, dispute the claim) with less than 2 dozen children surviving. Greatest act of domestic violence, only eclipsed by the Oklahoma bombing.

Was it accurate? Yes, it was accurate, the women in charge of production did her homework, and she was granted complete access to the historic records, which by the way are better than anywhere else. Done any genealogy lately? Personal history is very important around here and extensive records were made and subsequently collected. The Church, as it is referred to around here has acquired more birth, death, marriage, emigration, census, poll, etc. records than anyone else in the world. When the US government put together the restoration of Ellis Island, the LDS Church provided the emigration records (and computers) for Ellis Island, which they purchased from the government. They own original copies of many countries records, the originals!

Was it thorough?

No. When Joseph Smith was �martyred� by the mob in 1844 he was a candidate for the presidency of the United States, so it was a political �assassination�. Few are aware of this.

Was there any mention of the Utah War? James Buchanan sent 2500 United States Army troops to Utah in 1857 to eliminate the twin barbarisms of Slavery and Polygamy. Later reinforced with 3000 more troops to eradicate the Mormon problem. Enslaving people is just wrong, having more than one wife is a matter of personal preference, happens all over the world. Comparing slavery to polygamy is like comparing apples to dominoes. Buchanan�s idea besides being carried along by the Republican sentiment in the House and Senate was to remove the army from the union, remember this is after the Missouri Compromise and the problems in Kansas, seeds of the civil war growing. Many in his administration went to the Confederacy. Fortunately cooler heads prevailed, Van Buren and Thomas Kane convinced Congress of the misguided efforts of the Administration and public outcry soon shifted and the Utah War never happened. Political cartoons of the period are hilarious. Ten Mormon boys holding the entire United States Army from entering the Territory was not far from the truth. When the Civil War started 60% of Army forces were in Utah protecting overland travelers heading to California from the Mormons. Of the 99 officers in Utah at the outbreak of hostilities, 49 became Union Generals and 50 became Confederate Generals.

We were the �State of Deseret� in 1847; we became a territory in 1850 and a state in 1896. California became a state in 1850 without ever being a territory, what is up with that? They beat us up because we like women. So what is wrong with that?

What do I think? We are a curious people.

Brother Stephen Shepherd