Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

Posts

Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#1

Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

Ed in Lawrence, KS

>Sometime in the not too distant future I'm going to build a Morris chair from some of Bob Lang's Craftsman Furniture plans. To get revved up, I'm going to build his Prairie chair first. Both chairs have rather stout legs that should have four quartersawn faces to be authentic. I've read several articles on producing quartersawn faced legs. Some describe the Gustav Stickley method of laminating two QS pieces and facing the plain sawn faces with QS veneer. This method is evidently prone to developing cracks in the veneer over time as the core pieces expand and contract in thickness. Others describe some variant of the L&JG Stickley method of cutting wedge-shaped pieces and gluing them together to form the square leg. This method is generally aided by using some sort of mitered rabbet, lock-miter, etc to aid in aligning the pieces during glue-up and usually results in a void in the middle of the leg where all 4 pieces don't meet up. I'm leaning towards using the L&JG method to avoid the potential for future cracking and to be able to utilize 5/4 or 6/4 wood instead of 8/4. My question is this - since the Morris chair legs have through tenons through the arms, how should I make the tenon? Should I just construct my leg so that there is no void in the middle and make the tenon as usual? If I do this, won't the glue lines from the separate leg pieces show and look odd? If I construct the leg leaving a void, can I just make my through tenon by cutting a one piece loose tenon with an end that fits the void? If I glue the loose tenon into the void in the leg, will the loose tenon expanding and contracting cause cracks in the legs? Is there a minimum size on the void so that the loose tenon has enough strength? Thanks in advance for any words of wisdom.

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#2

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs *LINK*

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Ed,

I built a pair of Morris Chairs a number of years ago. To make the legs I used figured wood with boards wide enough to rip the four leg sides and mitre lock them together.

Here is a link to the chairs and an image of the mitre locked legs.

take care,

Jim


Morris Chairs

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#3

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

Bob Lang

>Hi Ed,

I favor the L&JG Stickley "quadrilinear" leg. Several variations of how to do it are described in my second book "More Shop Drawings for Craftsman Furniture" and an additional method is in the April 2006 issue of "Popular Woodworking". I personally don't have the patience to use the lock miter router bit, but it does work.

Where you have a through tenon, I think stuffing the void with a small piece and then forming the tenon is the best option. If you use a piece of scrap from the other parts of the legs you should be able to match the end grain so it looks good, and if you do that, wood movement shouldn't be an issue. Quartersawn White Oak is pretty stable so I don't think there is much risk of the leg coming apart.

Although I have pointed out that the "veneered" legs can crack, a lot of people have done it this way successfully (so far). A fair number of original Gus Stickley pieces with laminated legs have cracks 6"-8" up, starting at the very bottome of the leg. However, a lot of these pieces were put down in damp basements when the style went out of fashion. This method might well stay intact if the bottom of the leg doesn't ever get really wet. If you do it this way, and take both pieces of the lamination from the same board it's easy to match the end grain. This will look better from the top of the through tenon.

I've always used the quadrilinear method, but last fall I made a couple tables with veneered legs. I'll let you know how they hold up in another 80 years or so.

Bob Lang

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#4

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

Tom Stockton

>I use the veneer technique and use sawn veneers. I've never had a problem with cracks. I cut mine 1/16" to 3/32" thick at this thickness any glue line will vanish when the edge is broken with sandpaper. As Bob said if they get real wet there could be a problem but it would take either a lot of water or sitting in a puddle to do harm and the other style of leg could have the same problems.

Bottom line whichever technique you are comfortable with and will get the best results is the one to use because I think they are both good choices.

Tom

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#5

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

Clay Foster

>Ed,

A few years ago I made a bunch of furniture for a church. The legs were made in the quadrilinear style as Bob calls it, and were also tapered. I used biscuits rather than a spline for gluing them together, and it worked slicker than snot on a pump handle.

I would make a mortise in the top of the legs and put a tenon in it. QS white oak is so stable there shouldn't be a problem. To save weight and material, each leg side could be as thin as 5/8" and still have all the strength you would need.

Here's a picture of the lectern. The top section has a motorized lift, so it can go down to a wheel chair accessable position. Altogether there were 7 pieces of furniture that had glued up tapered legs.


img

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#6

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

mdclor

>I have cut 3/4 inch boards with a 45* miter on both edges and then ripped a 1/8" groove on the ts for a spline and they have worked great. I intend to use this for 4" square legs for a bed frame since it is impossible to find 12/4 qswo in my area.

Good luck,

Merle

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#7

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

DickL

>>I'll let you know how they hold up in another 80 years or so.

Bob, I'll be waiting for your report on this.

Regards,

Dick

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#8

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

Paul Dwight

>Ed, I like your idea of making a loose tenon that could be inserted into the void of a quadrilateral leg. If you can make the loose tenon out of solid stock (not a glue-up), the appearance of the through tenon on the top of the arm would be a little nicer.

If you decide to use the veneer method, instead, I seriously doubt you will have any problems with cracking. I built our Morris chairs using the veneer method and they show no signs of cracking after 7 years or so.

I have also built legs using the quadrilateral method and in my experience, the veneer method is a lot more straightforward and a lot faster. If you expect to continue producing Morris chairs over the years, it makes sense to build the jigs needed to safely produce the mitered stock for the quadrilateral method. If you're only building one or two chairs, the veneer method is a lot more efficient (IMHO).

Good luck, whatever you decide! -- Paul

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#9

Spline method

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Here is one I did in cherry with splines. Second pic is jig to cut the slots.

Ray

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#10

Jig 

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>


img

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#11

Spline

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Don't know what happened to the pic first time.


img

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#12

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

David Mathias - Central OH

>With thick stock, such as the 12/4 you mention, is it really necessary to get quartersawn? I just finished a Stickley inspired kitchen table. While at a local lumber mill I spied a hunk of 12/4 white oak. Not quartersawn (that would have been one heckuva tree). I suspected that the "edges" (3" thick) would show quartersawn figure. I was right. I suppose I could have been unluckly and gotten bastard grain but that wouldn't have been all bad either.

BTW, I cut veneers for the plain sawn faces and it worked quite nicely.

David

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

#13

Re: Quartersawn WO Stickley legs

Bob Lang

>There's the rub-it's hard to find thick stuff that is quartersawn, but you can find it in portions of thick stuff. If you look at the end grain you can get a better idea. Quartered stuff will be close to vertical on the end. Rift sawn material (where the grain is roughly 45 degrees to the face) will make an attractive leg because the grain pattern on the front and sides will be similar. It's the difference between adjacent faces in plain sawn stock that's objectionable in appearance.

Bob Lang