stains for birch??
Quebecnewf
>Has anyone tried these Minwax Polyshades stains on birch. how do they do with regard to splotching.
Any input and or pics of birch products you have stained with these products would be great
Paul
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
stains for birch??
Quebecnewf
>Has anyone tried these Minwax Polyshades stains on birch. how do they do with regard to splotching.
Any input and or pics of birch products you have stained with these products would be great
Paul
Re: stains for birch??
Rob Stokes in North Vancouver
>I've used Polyshades on pine with good results, but it sure was a pain in the butt to get them. So much so, that the product is off my shopping list for good.
And I've stained birch before and learned the hard way that unless you're using a gel stain and still willing to take risk, you're far better off to use a sanding sealer (Zinsser Sealcoat) first.
Your mileage may vary.
Rob
An Alternative
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>Good Evening Quebenewf,
Polyshades is a PITA, requiring very good hand/eye coordination with a brush: better control than I have, sad to say. Done well, polyshades can be very good looking. I would either use a gel or try a water based aniline dye, seal with a spit coat of shellac and top coat it. I am rarely disappointed using aniline dyes, and you can always erase them with chlorine bleach, or modify the color/shade with an overcoating of gel or oil based stain applied over the scuffed seal coat sealer. Then top coat with your favorite beverage. :<)
George
Re: stains for birch??
Steve Schoene
>PolyShades has probably gotten the most negative posts than any other finishing product. Deservedly in my opinion. It's a toned finish, but without particularly good brushing properties. Consequently, unless you are a wizard with a brush getting even coloration is very unlikely.
Gel stains and staining after wash coats both work to reduce blotching, but aren't good at getting dark shades if that is your goal. To get dark--try analine dye, mixed with distilled water, as likely to be the best bet.
Re: An Alternative
Steve Schoene
>You beat me to it. As I said above, I agree, right down the line.
Re: wipe-on
Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX
>Polyshades is darn good for wiping on as a stain for hard-to-stain woods. I demonstrate this in my "dyes and stains" class by using it on the lowest grade construction plywood I can find. I've not tried it specifically on birch though.
As an actual finish? I admire Rob's patience to get a good result out of the darn stuff. ;-)
Re: An Alternative
Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario
>Hi George,
I know you love that top coat!
Ditto on analine dyes, I would run the colouring on a test surface and I also use shellac as a sealer too on birch.
Sometimes you get a special piece of birch that requires only oil and a bleneded top coat..
:-)
Take care,
Jim
Re: An Alternative
Paul R
>very nice table top. Just for my info and when I am lucky enough to cut a few birch with this type of figure how did you finish the top.
Quebecnewf
Re: An Alternative
Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario
>Hi Paul,
The wood is figured flame birch. It had strong figure and I did not colour it. It was difficult to plane or machine, it had tear out all over the place. I had the top sanded on a wide belt sander and I then hand scraped it clean.
The finish for the top was an intial coat of bolied linseed oil followed by a top coat of a home made blend of several coats of a wipe-on mix of poly, boiled linseed oil, and thinner mix with a 3:2 ratio of boiled linseed oil to poly and about 30% thinner. The final step was to rub out the finish and buff with 0000 steel wool and wax. I have since looked at using pure tung oil as a replacement for the BLO and using dryers as well in the mix.
Take care,
Jim