Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

Posts

OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#1

JL

OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

JL

>The 2nd floor has vents, but no return (just 2 bedrooms and a bathroom). The 1st floor has vents, a return and a separate zone control - the thermostat controls the heating and air to the 1st and 2nd floor. The basement has vents, a return and a separate zone control.

While we have a zone capacity open on the HVAC system, we don't have the room to put in any more ductwork without some really expensive rework.

Needless to say, it gets a bit warm upstairs in the summer. There is a window AC in one of the bedrooms, but nothing in the other. The LOML saw this product in the local EMC (Electrical Membership Cooperative) magazine. It "seems" like it would fit the bill quite nicely. Opinions please - the link is below


AFT Airflow

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#2

Re: OT - Heating and air question

David Yoho

>It looks to me like that product simply boosts the airflow from your current vents. Due to their size, I'd wonder how effective they'd really be. With your layout, the upstairs temperature is still dependent on the downstairs thermostat.

If your problem is the amount of air that the system sends upstairs, I'd look into booster fans and/or "gates" that can be installed into your existing ductwork that direct more of the air to the places you need it. The problem with a design like you have is one zone being dependent on another. I don't think you'll ever get satisfactory results with that setup.

David

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#3

Re: OT - Heating and air question

Curly Smith

>I think there are two schools of thought on auxiliary HVAC duct fans. One school says they work, the other says they only mask the problem. I belong to a third school that agrees with the other two mutually exclusive opinions. In my experience, most homes have undersized A/C units and undersized duct work as the builder cuts whatever costs he can during construction. The A/C is adequate, but only adequate and sometimes installing a duct fan on the end of a run is very beneficial.

Now, here's what I think will happen if you install the duct fan(s):

- you'll get more cold air to the upper story

- you'll be stealing that air from the lower story

- the "cold" air, in total, will be warmer because

- you only have x tons of cooling capacity

- by reducing the head in one duct you reduce the head in the system

- system air flow will increase (your squirrel cage moves more air because of the reduced head)

- more air flow with the same cooling capacity means warmer "cold" air

Maybe it's not a bad trade-off. You can't add more ducts and you probably don't want to buy a new a/c unit. However, depending on where your thermostat is you might be sending a lot more money to your local electrical utility as your a/c unit is now cooling a bunch more living space. You might want to consider bumping your thermostat up a few degrees.

You've only got so much cooling capacity and adding the duct fans will help redistribute it. As long as you understand the potential problems then there's no reason not to install the fans. However, before I spent the money on the fans I'd retape the joints in the ductwork, including those at the registers, add more insulation to the attic and make sure that my attic fans are properly sized. A bunch on the heat on the second story is from the heat gain on the roof. Finally, Sherwin Williams makes a "radiant barrier" paint that might be of some use in reducing the summer-time heat load on your house. However, I know nothing about it other than you spray it on the underside of the roof and supposedly save bags of money.

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#4

Re: OT - Heating and air question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I installed HVAC for several years as a side occupation. I don't believe the unit your looking at will provide much if any help in your situation. There are booster fans built for various size ductwork that come on with your air blower. These are sold at most heating houses and also at Grainger. Your best bet as you probably know is to install a return air from the upstairs. If you are handy (most woodworkers are fully capable of doing this), you can run a duct in the corner of a closet etc. A return air does not need to be metal. You can box this in plywood etc. - Actually doesn't matter too much if it isn't completely air tight as long as your filter is downstream from any air entering the return. Another option is to "box" the joists in the basement (opening the "box" to the return air, and using the space in the inside walls to return the air. Of course you have to install a grill in the wall and cap the opening above the grill. You may look your house over and find several inexpensive ways to return air from the upstairs to the furnace.

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#5

Re: OT - Heating and air question

Keith Newton

>While they might move the air when the unit fan is off, it looks to me like it would restrict the flow to those rooms when the AC is running.

Before you spend money on something like that, try setting the fan to run continuously rather than auto. It may help keep the air mixed up better, and keep it from getting stratified. All of the heat rises to the top unless you keep it mixed up.

You might also partially close some of the registers lower down, which would send more aloft.

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#6

Re: OT - Heating and air question

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Your second floor and main floor are considered one zone. The return air from the second floor comes down the stairs via the main floor return grill. I'm not sure what your floorplan is, but assuming the second floor is open to the first floor, this set-up should be fine. and in fact, may be favourable.

Some have suggested adding a return to the second floor - I'm not sure I agree but if you do, please check the code on wood/metal ductwork. We're no longer permitted to have a non-lined return.

Warm air rises. In the wintertime this means that with the system you have, adjusted as it is and assuming you have no heating complaints in the winter, is working just fine.

Cool air drops, so if the system is balanced to flood the main floor with air knowing it will rise to the second floor, that balance won't be effective in cooling season. It sounds like your sytsem is marginal, so if it was me, I'd close down the main floor diffusers (grates) a bit and open the second floor ones. How much do you do this? If your ductwork sarts to oil-can (BONG!!!), you've gone too far. And if the sound of the air coming out of the upper diffusers is too loud, you've gone too far.

On the main floor, close down the registers nearest the return the most and leave the ones furthest away open the most. Cooling, or rather effective cooling has just as much to to with air moving across you as it does with the actual air temperature. By forcing a cross-breeze situation through managing the air paths, you can create airflow across you, effectively adding cooling (or the feeling of cooling, which is just as good).

Good luck!

Rob

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#7

8 watts/100 cfm-NO WAY JOSE'

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Nominal airflow is 400 cfm per ton. It takes 1/3 true fan HP to get 400 cfm. Absolute HP is 746 watts/HP, actual is more like 1200 watts/HP. Do the math: 100 cfm is 25% of 1/3 HP or in other words 100 watts, not EIGHT. What's a watt; amps times volts is watts. If this manufacturer has lied about this, what else have they stretched the truth about? This makes about as much sense as 7 HP shop vacuums and 3.5 HP routers plugged into a 20 amp wall outlet. There ain't no way. A 20 amp outlet will support only 1920 watts on a continuos basis. Not the 5200 watts for seven HP. Current manufacturing mode is to lie about all the things that the average consumer can't measure.

What they have probably tested for is that a big AC unit can push 100 cfm through this seriuos restriction. An efficient AC system needs a 20" x 20" return grille for each ton. How much do you have? Do you run the fan in constant mode? This will help reduce hot spots.

Bill

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#8

Ceiling fans can help quite a bit also.

Dan Donaldson

>

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#9

Re: OT - Heating and air question

Barry Irby

>You have what is called a "balancing problem". You have to balance the air flow to match the heat gain/heat loss. Warm air rises so in winter you want the vents downstairs wide open and the ones upstairs partially closed. In summer you want to open the ones upstairs and partially close the ones down stairs. (exactly what others have told you.

Also and return upstairs would be a big help but might be impractical.

There are alternatives, also mentioned by others. If the upper and lower systems have trunks that branch off, you can put system dampers in them and open and close them by season. These can be manual or you can have them automated and motorized. (Manual is much cheaper. The automated systems are often poorly installed and I see few that work properly)

You can also add booster fans designed to insert into the ductwork.

I seriously doubt the ones on the website will have a serious effect on your systems. Just not possible for such small under powered units to move much air.

If you can get into your attic, another option is to increase your second floor insulation. If you can significantly improve the insulation, you might be able to reduce the heat upstairs. This would benefit you year round. Look for poorly insulated area or even hatches that are not weather stripped or insulated.

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#10

JL

Re: OT - Thanks all, I'll look into something..

JL

>else. I'll first try to balance the airflows via the dampers. Then I'll see about a "booster" fan to put in line to the upstairs. I've got a place that I can cut into.

A return is not really practical at this time.

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#11

Re: 8 watts/100 cfm-NO WAY JOSE'

cjp

>Just wanted to respond to this post, yes way 100cfm! The unit consists of 2 12 volt fans that have a rating of 50 cfm each. The unit draws air from the duct increases air flow to the room. Often these hot/cold rooms have poor air flow in the duct and this will boost the air into the room give in some cases and 8 degree change in temp, it works and if your not satified you can return it for a refund.

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#12

Re: OT - Heating and air question

Tony - Memphis

>I recently installed an inline booster fan. The brand is Tgerlund or something like that and I got it via a supplier on Ebay called Patriot Supply. We have a room on the north side of the house that has lots and lots of glass and a 12' ceiling. The duct design bubbas did a poor job. I bought the 8" fan and installed it with their pressure relay control on the plenum (pretty cool!). It works great and my wife is happy with the results (this room is her workroom for painting and sewing). She used to freeze to death in the winter and sweat in the summer, but she says it is comfortable in there now. I haven't noticed any effect on the rest of the house or even that trunk. I think our unit was oversized a bit and the returns may be a little undersized. We live in suburbia where all the systems are designed by rules of thumb or what was on the truck that day. Anyway, good luck with your problem. One note, the fan is a little noisy, but only in the room that it is boosting.

Tony

Re: OT - Heating and air question *LINK*

#13

Re: 8 watts/100 cfm-NO WAY JOSE' *LINK*

cjp

>Here is what a very respectible maganize, The Family Handyman" said about the product.

See link: http://www.aftproducts.com/?page=thefamilyhandyman


http://www.aftproducts.com/?page=thefamilyhandyman