Re: OT - Heating and air question
Curly Smith
>I think there are two schools of thought on auxiliary HVAC duct fans. One school says they work, the other says they only mask the problem. I belong to a third school that agrees with the other two mutually exclusive opinions. In my experience, most homes have undersized A/C units and undersized duct work as the builder cuts whatever costs he can during construction. The A/C is adequate, but only adequate and sometimes installing a duct fan on the end of a run is very beneficial.
Now, here's what I think will happen if you install the duct fan(s):
- you'll get more cold air to the upper story
- you'll be stealing that air from the lower story
- the "cold" air, in total, will be warmer because
- you only have x tons of cooling capacity
- by reducing the head in one duct you reduce the head in the system
- system air flow will increase (your squirrel cage moves more air because of the reduced head)
- more air flow with the same cooling capacity means warmer "cold" air
Maybe it's not a bad trade-off. You can't add more ducts and you probably don't want to buy a new a/c unit. However, depending on where your thermostat is you might be sending a lot more money to your local electrical utility as your a/c unit is now cooling a bunch more living space. You might want to consider bumping your thermostat up a few degrees.
You've only got so much cooling capacity and adding the duct fans will help redistribute it. As long as you understand the potential problems then there's no reason not to install the fans. However, before I spent the money on the fans I'd retape the joints in the ductwork, including those at the registers, add more insulation to the attic and make sure that my attic fans are properly sized. A bunch on the heat on the second story is from the heat gain on the roof. Finally, Sherwin Williams makes a "radiant barrier" paint that might be of some use in reducing the summer-time heat load on your house. However, I know nothing about it other than you spray it on the underside of the roof and supposedly save bags of money.