Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Bandsaw Recommendations?

Posts

Bandsaw Recommendations?

#1

Bandsaw Recommendations?

Paul Mullis

>I am getting ready to purchase a new band saw, but the more I research the more confusing it gets. Right now I'm trying to decide between 3 models: Grizzly G0513 17", Grizzly G0513X Extreme 17", and the Jet 708749 16".

I would really like to be able to resaw wood, but I also don't want to loose the ability to do smaller work. I tend to buy rough hardwood and up until now have been resawing with my table saw, but of course that produces a lot of waste. So if anyone has any good practical recommendations, I'd really appreciate it. I can't afford to go any higher in price though. Also, any recommendations on where to buy? I'm in the Atlanta area.

Thanks,

Paul

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

#2

JL

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

JL

>Paul, to confuse things a little more - go to Redmond & Son. (www.redmond-machinery.com) They are off Fulton Industrial Blvd, south of I-20 outside of the perimeter. They carry Jet, Delta, Steel City, General and Powermatic. They may have one or two used bandsaws in stock. My friend Mike bought a Steel City 16" bandsaw a week and a half ago. He's set it up and likes it a lot. I don't think he's used it for resawing yet though.

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

#3

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Can't help you regarding the saws that you're contemplating, but you might want to consider buying another smaller band saw instead of switching blades in and out of your large saw. Every time you change the blade you will probably have to re-adjust tracking, fence drift, blade guides, etc., on top of changing the blade itself. It grows old very quickly. It's very frustrating to break your rhythm during a job because you don't have the right blade installed on the saw...

By having another band saw with a narrow blade set up permanently, the only time you need to adjust the saw is when blades get dull. And both saws are ready to go right there and then.

I bought a second saw, and would never go back.

DC

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

#4

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

Falberg saw Co

>Paul,

Buy the cheapest bandsaw you can find and put your money into an *assortment* of blades. You'll need a distinctly different blade for each distinctly different job. Learn to reset blades, as factory-set blades are totally inadequate for all but the easiest cuts. The results I'm getting with custom-set blades is phenominal and I plan to publish the results in an upcoming article on the subject. Meanwhile, get out your hammer and punch and put your check book away.

Bill

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

#5

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

Falberg saw Co

>Denis,

If you use the right blade there IS no fence drift, blade guide adj. , or tension adj.. You simply install new blade and go.

With the wrong blade it won't matter how you set up the saw; it's still going to be a hassle.

And floor space is scarce in most shops.

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

#6

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>If it's only the matter of replacing a blade with another of the same size and same brand, my experience has been that there little to no adjustments to make. But if you switch between say, a 3/4" and a 1/4" blade, there will be adjustments to make.

Just out of curiosity, what is the "right blade" that you have in mind?

DC

Floor space is quite scarce in my basement shop, yet I still think that the second bandsaw is worth it...

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

#7

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

Paul Mullis

>Thanks for the response and I'm sure that a good blade makes a huge difference, but I want a good saw as well.

If anyone has any specific recommendations for these 3 saws I mentioned or something else comparable, please let me know.

Thanks,

Paul

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

#8

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

Falberg saw Co

>Denis,

The "right" blade is the one that cuts flat with the least roughness. Beyond that you can tune the kerf width to accomplish the first two criteria and attain the fastest feed rate. Factory-set blades only rarely apply to the species and cut depth YOU need.

There are as many "right blades" as there are cutting solutions. To find the "right blade" for your next cut try tapping out the set in small increments until the blade acts like a hot knife through butter; then stop. Remember that setting next time you want the same cut. Do that every time you use the saw and you'll soon have an assortment of blades, one for every occasion. I guarantee you'll be as amazed as I was when I started doing this.

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

#9

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I bought and used a Jet 16" steel framed saw, for about 3 years. It did most of what I wanted it to do, when equipped with the right blade. When I bought it, it was a compromise. I wanted an Italian Laguna, and my wife wanted a new quilter's sewing machine...

Sold the saw to a young friend that needed a rugged saw for his contracting business. He's been really happy with it, and I'm trying to see when I can buy the Laguna.

But the Jet was worth the money.

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

#10

Cheap Saw and Good Blade

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Paul,

I can loan a little credence. My first bandsaw was a Craftsman 12" tilt top. It suited me fine until I outgrew it and work became beyond its capabilities. After I bought my first Jet 14" I ordered a Timberwolf blade for the Sears and then gave it to #1 son. The difference in performance was dramatic with the premium blade. The saw is still in the family and running well with premium blades.

George

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

#11

Re: the Jet 16

Denny

>I have the Jet 16 and it works very well. No drift, and no point fence needed for resawing. When I set the tension for a 1/2" blade the tension is correct, and it has plenty of power. Changing blades isn't as convenient as on some other saws, but it does everything I need. I think the price makes it an attractive alternative to buying a 14" saw and riser. I got mine from Amazon. Let me know if you have any specific questions.

Denny

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

#12

Re: Bandsaw Recommendations?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Paul,

Go talk to Phil Coulson over at Highland about that Rikon 14" Deluxe bandsaw that they have near the front door. I have one, and it is a fine piece of equipment that has a greater resaw capacity than most 16-17" BS (13") and has a 2hp motor. I love mine. AND it is a good deal cheaper and takes less shop real estate than the bigger ones.

Mark

P.S. If you want to come an hour and a half south, you can try mine as much as you want. We can put on any blade from an 3/8" to 3/4".