Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OT: Are big TVs Faster?

Posts

OT: Are big TVs Faster?

#1

OT: Are big TVs Faster?

Bill Howatt

>I recently upgraded to a LCD 42" TV. My wife is a hockey fan, I normally could care less, but did find myself watching parts of some games with her.

The other night we were at a friend's house and the last bit of the hockey game was on his smaller TV. I thought that the players didn't seem to be going as fast as when I watched my TV.

After thinking a bit about it, I came to this conclusion which I want to see if you think is right or wrong.

For this example TV40 has a 40" wide screen and TV20 has a 20" wide screen. They both get the same signal. For an object to go from the left of TV40's screen to the right takes 1 second. Since they both get the same signal at the same frame-rate it will also take 1 second on TV20. However, it had to go twice as far on TV40 in the 1 second so it would look like it went twice as fast.

Is that right?

Bill

Re: OT: Are big TVs Faster?

#2

Re: OT: Are big TVs Faster?

Scott in Montana

>Hello Bill,

While you didn't mention if your friend's TV was also a LCD technology model, artifacts are often less noticeable on smaller sets. Televised hockey is one of the toughest tests on any LCD television. As you may know, the LCD set works by opening and closing very small "gates" and no matter how small they are, these "gates" have mass and therefore have measureable reaction times. A black puck against white ice traveling at such high speeds will often leave a trailing ghost behind them. The color (or lack of it) white requires all gates open while the color black requires all gates to be closed; and this just doesn't happen as fast as a hockey puck moves across the ice. This may be the slowness that you�re noticing.

To give you one more example of this LCD artifact, imagine a high definition video being filmed from a moving car as it drives by a white picket fence. Because of the rate that the pickets would move by, the resulting film played on an LCD television might look as if you were driving by a cement wall due to the slurring caused by the inability of the LCD "gates" to open and shut at such a high rate. Plasma technologies have the advantage in this department as they have no moving parts and therefore can "turn on" and "turn off" much more rapidly.

Don't get me wrong, I am not in the anti-LCD camp. Both LCD and plasma have their advantages and disadvantages. I think the LCD camp has done a much better job of selling their technology.

Scott

Re: OT: Are big TVs Faster?

#3

No - but depends on definition

Derek

>In theory, each frame has the same image on either TV - in actuality there may be differences for technical reasons (progressive/interlace monitor effects, for example).

The skater moves across the screen at the same rate in either case. The fact that one screen is bigger than the other means that the skater moves further on one screen that the other but he still moved the same distance in real life.

Your perception may be that he is moving faster because you are looking at a bigger image but there is no change in his speed.

If you define faster as meaning how many inches per second does he move on the screen, then you are correct. If you define faster relative to your eye then it depends on how far from the screen you are and if you get closer with the smaller TV.

Re: OT: Are big TVs Faster?

#4

What you're seeing...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>You're comparing different linear rates, when in reality, you need to compare ANGULAR rates. If you sit twice as far from a 40" TV as from a 20" TV, then the angular rates of motion will be the same, and the players will appear to move the same speed. But, as you noticed, if you sit the same distance from the TV in both cases, the 40" will fill more of your FOV (field of view), and thus, the players will appear to move farther in the same amount of time on a 40" as compared to a 20".

You can spend a huge amount of money on the best HDTV, but if you sit too close to it, everything will look terrible. I have a 40" and sit about 10 feet from it. Anything over about a 52" at that distance would start to look pixelated because I would be too close. At 3' from my TV, even HD looks bad because I can see individual pixels at that distance. There are charts/calculators online that are designed to help you determine optimum seating distance vs. screen size. I was originally considering a 32" or 37" widescreen until I realized that with a flat panel sitting further from me than a tube, a standard picture would have been smaller than the 27" I was watching.

Jason (who spent WAY too much time researching TVs...)

Re: OT: Are big TVs Faster?

#5

In that case...

Dave Morris

>... if you were at the local cinema watching the theatrical release of a movie with a hockey scene in it, those guys would REALLY be moving! ;-)

Remember, the guys playing hockey on the 40" screen are also twice the size of the guys on the smaller 20" screen. Although it's twice the TV size, and twice the distance to cover point to point, it's all the same image. The only difference is your point of view has changed, relatively speaking.

Dave--- who thinks a top fuel dragster still looks incredibly fast, even when seen on a 13" portable TV from across the room

Re: OT: Are big TVs Faster?

#6

No, but the players are slower......

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>On the larger TV sets, the players tend to get tired sooner and then get slower . The ice is stretched out further so they have to skate farther to get from one blue line to the other.

Scores are often a bit higher, because the nets are are much wider on the 16:9 wide format screens. Those wider goals are harder to protect and the goalies have a much harder time, so the scores reflect that.

The games do last a little longer, because there is less heat buildup on the LCD screens compared to the CRT tubes, so the ice doesn't soften up as quickly so they can play longer periods.

Happy Woodworking!