Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

way OT.New car

Posts

way OT.New car

#1

way OT.New car

Sid

>Good Morning.

Am in the need for anew car,and am sure some of you guys know exactly what I need.

I would like smaller size,like the Civic,but want one that is comfortable enough for a cross country trip.How about suggestions?

Thanks Sid

Re: way OT.New car

#2

Re: way OT.New car

Bill Howatt

>Rather a hard question to answer because it is very subjective. When I was younger going a million miles in an econo-box would have been fun but not anymore. Small cars are much improved over what they used to be but they are still small cars. They also tend to be noisier than their bigger brothers.

I have a friend 60+ who bought a Toyota Corolla and liked it until he took it on a 2000 mile trip. When he got home he upgraded to the Camry.

If your cross-country trip is a one-time event and the car will be used for short trips etc why not consider a rental for the cross-country trip and get a smaller car to fit your major requirement?

Bill

Re: way OT.New car

#3

Re: way OT.New car

ScottS

>I've been very impressed with my Subaru. I wasn't sure about the all-wheel drive, but I have to say that it's fantastic! No matter what the weather conditions, the car never seems to loose traction. Lots of friends have them and I don't know of anyone who's had any problems...

Re: way OT.New car

#4

Re: way OT.New car

Craig Frasa

>I'm driving an '07 Chevy HHR, I have about 4k miles on it and so far its been a great car, decent room, good cargo space, I can fold the seats to carry an 8'board and it gets about 25mpg.

Re: way OT.New car

#5

Re: way OT.New car

Ray Newman

>Visit the dealerships & sit in & examine the vehicles you are seriously interested in.

Then go to Avis, or Hertz, etc., & rent the car for about 10-14 days. You'll soon find out whether you like it enough for long distance driving....

Re: way OT.New car

#6

Re: way OT.New car

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I've always found my MkIV VW Golf GLS TDI (the previous model) very comfortable on long distance drives. With the diesel engine, the car is MUCH quieter on the highway than my wife's Honda Accord. I've never liked Honda's on the highway. VW certainly knows how to make a nice drivable car that handles well at speed.

With the diesel engine I get 50 mpg in the city (and 50 mpg on the highway; but that's because I'm driving 120 km/h. If I slow down on the highway the fuel economy rises quite a bit).

On the flipside, the VW requires three times as much maintenance as the Honda :-( but the VW Golf is a nice, comfortable, drivable car even on long distance trips.

In Canada they are still selling the old MkIV Golf as a "City Golf", and they are selling them at a large discount. The new Golf was rebranded back to the old Rabbit name, with a large price increase.

I think the VW is worth a test drive, but the poor maintenance track record (and horrible VW service around here) are a big downside to consider.

Re: way OT.New car

#7

Subarus are hard to kill

Neal in San Jose

>I have 275K miles on my '90 Legacy and it still makes trips to the lumber yard, etc. when I don't want to get my "new" car dirty. I never went on any really long trips, but 4 hours up to ski country was a piece of cake.

Re: way OT.New car

#8

Re: way OT.New car

Craig Daymon

>I bought a 2006 Jetta TDI (turbo diesel) last year. I think you can probably find a few on the lots new and I suspect probably for a good price. It has, I suspect, a great deal more room than a Civic (since it's more in the Accord class) and since it is diesel, I'm getting about 35 city and suppose to get (haven't really taken a long trip yet) mid 40's highway. I'm told diesels have a break-n period of about 7,000 miles, after which I'm suppose to see even better mileage.

It has a HUGE trunk and the seats fold down, so there's still hope for hauling some (moderate sized) lumber. There's also a ski pass-through, which looks perfect for a few long boards, keeping them from bouncing about too much.

It's not real quick, but it moves OK. Probably comparable to the Civic. It is suppose to be one of the safer cars out there, with side-impact air bags and such.

VW is changing their diesels, so there aren't any 2007 models. They'll be back in 2008 with competition from several other manufacturers, from what I've read. Though most of the diesels in '08 are probably going to be SUVs in the US.

My BMW 318ti was more fun, and it got good mileage, but they aren't made anymore. I think the Jetta diesel was a good choice for me.

-Craig

Re: way OT.New car

#9

Another Subaru vote

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>I could do commercials for Subaru. I've been driving Subaru Foresters for 10 years or more. Probably, the only reason I've had more than one is that it was a leased business vehicle until recently. They don't change much, other than getting better, with more features. The handling is great--I've driven past many a 4x4 that has gotten stuck in a ditch or snowbank, while my Forester hugs the road. It hauls lumber and woodworking projects pretty well, and makes me smile and go "Ahhhh!" when I turn on the heated seat. :-)

Re: way OT.New car

#10

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Another Subaru vote

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Mine's an '04 Outback, with the 6 cyl engine. Great car. Only got 36K on it right now, but it's been pretty much bulletproof so far as maintenance.

My only complaint is/was the OEM tires. They were Bridgestone Potenzas, which were great on dry or wet pavement, but terrible on snow. Michelin replacements are much better.

Jim D.

Re: way OT.New car

#11

JL

Yet another Subaru vote

JL

>I have a Forester. I've had it for several years now. I like the all wheel drive and the hill holder clutch (mine is a manual). Holds four people comfortably. I've had it on multiple road trips of 500 miles or greater. I like the removeable tray in the back in the cargo area. Great for holding log sections or short pieces of lumber. It also holds plants and bags of soil conditioner. When it gets too dirty, I vacuum it out or take it out and hose it off.

Re: way OT.New car

#12

One "ding" on Subarus...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>A good friend of mine is coming partially out of retirement to work at the local Subaru/Toyota factory. He will actually work for a contractor that inspects the Toyotas once they are on the rail car for ANY damage. As of last week, Toyota had not yet gotten any cars off the line, so to "practice" his new job, he and his boss went out and inspected the Subarus in a similar fashion. Toyotas policy is that no cars leave if they are even the slightest bit damaged--everything gets fixed one way or another (no Bondo, though). So they went out and found a bunch of scratches, dings and dents on some Subarus that were on rail cars. They filled out their paperwork and went back to the office to give the paperwork to their Subaru mirrors/counterparts. The Subaru guys laughed and promptly dumped the papers in the trash. Apparently it's the dealer's responsibility to fix that stuff (I'm sure there's plenty of Bondo involved...)

I just wish I had time to share a bunch of my friend's stories from his career at Eli Lilly & Co. I think he could wipe out OSHA if he told those stories in the OSHA offices (would cause too many heart attacks).

Jason

Re: way OT.New car

#13

Re: way OT.New car

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I only got 300k miles out of my '81 VW diesel Rabbit...

These (TDIs) aren't available in California, but a few of the Berkeley earthfirst types are running reimported ones on biodiesel, and getting writeups in the local papers.

My son's gas 2002 VW Golf has been a pretty good car, and he's 6'4", defensive tackle build. I drove that thing 2000 miles when it was brand new, around the Pacific Northwest and over to Montana, to take a vacation, and then retrieve my pickup truck. I'd buy another one.

Re: way OT.New car

#14

Re: way OT.New car

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Well, Sid, we are on our 2nd Ford Focus. It is about the size of the Civic, gets about 35mpg highway, 30mpg suburban driving. We are small, about 5'6" each, not heavy, and find the car very comfortable for long or short trips. It is a 4 and has enough pep to get out of dicey situations which sometimes happen.

Re: way OT.New car

#15

That's a feature

Neal in San Jose

>You won't have to worry about when you will get your first scratch. It's factory installed!

Re: way OT.New car

#16

Yet another vote for ...

Jim Dillon

>... Subaru. My wife was partial to Subarus and after 125K miles I'm convinced. A wagon fits our needs very well and long trips are very nice. I've had long-trip experience with the Honda Accord, Toyota Corolla, and most recently the Subaru. Also drove a Toyota Camry on a 2K road-trip. Difficult to compare since my driving with these cars was over a 25 year period and cars improve over time. Having said that, the Camry seemed the smoothest long-distance traveler, with the Honda a close second IMHO. The Subaru's suspension is just a tad harder but is also superb on the interstates and the full-time all-wheel drive is fantastic; just a very solid feeling auto.

In yesterdays newspaper, there was a review of the 1997 Toyota Corolla. Alternative suggestions in that category were the Honda Civic, Chevrolet Cobalt, Ford Focus, Mazda 3, Nissan Sentra, and Hyundia Elantra. I've read a lot of good things about the Hyundia brand and how they offer excellent value and quality.

The Subaru wagon can also haul lumber as shown in the attached pic. Yes, there was still some spring left in the springs and I drove it 70 miles like that 8-). Good luck.

Jim


img

Re: way OT.New car

#17

Element

Mike Fitterling

>We have a Honda Element and love it. We have an Accord and there is not a lot of difference in driving the two. The only thing is you cannot take more than four people because of the back seat configuration, other than that it is a very comfortable and versatile car. You sit up higher than in a car, which I find more comfortable. With the back seats folded up against the sides there is tons of space inside for hauling stuff. With the front and back seats reclined you have a place to sleep. On a road trip, if you get tired, just stop and open the back and put on the tent (takes about two minutes) and you have a nice little camoper for two. We have the four wheel drive and it is always on and comes into play as needed. Even here in Florida we get slick spots in the rain and you can tell that the car is using 4 WD when it hits one. IIRC it gets about 26 on the highway.