Router Verse Shaper
GarryVA
>I have been told for a small "hobby" shop all you need to do raised panels and other non production type routing is a 3 horse power router & a good table...verse an expensive shaper Thoughts anyone?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Router Verse Shaper
GarryVA
>I have been told for a small "hobby" shop all you need to do raised panels and other non production type routing is a 3 horse power router & a good table...verse an expensive shaper Thoughts anyone?
Re: Router Verse Shaper
Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana
>There has been several discussions on the advantages / disadvantages of Shapers vs Router tables. In essence it boils down to this: A Shaper is an "Industrial" machine - you can do virtually miles of molding etc. It will run larger diameter cutters due to its rigidity and slower RPM's. However the cutters are quite a lot more expensive and there are somewhat less choices. By the time you build or purchase a router table, router, fence etc, you approach the cost of a 1 1/2 hp shaper. However the router table with a 3 - 3 1/4 hp variable speed router will indeed do just about everything a shaper will do, and the bits are far less expensive. It just won't hold up to daily production runs of large trim cuts etc. To answer your initial question - many here do all there woodworking without a shaper. I have built and are in process of building more raised panels on my router table. You do need a variable speed router to run the larger bits used for horizontal panel raising. Do a search on this board for routers & / or shapers and you will find a lot of good information as to preferences of routers, fences, tables etc..
Re: Router Verse Shaper
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>Good Evening Gary,
For that "small hobby shop" you mention, a big variable speed router in a table is indeed all you need to raise panels with large diameter bits safely. In fact, you can buy smaller diameter raised panel bits which are vertically oriented to run the work thru on edge, and get away with a router of far less than 3 hp. You can also raise panels having a flat profile on your table saw. No need for a shaper.
George
Re: Router Verse Shaper
JL
>With the more powerful variable speed routers (2 1/4 hp and up) you can do raised panels with the vertical raised panel bits. I got a nice Amana vertical bit on "clearance" sale. It works quite nicely with my 2 1/4 hp router. I haven't tried a horizontal raised panel bit.
Shaper is faster and smoother
Ellis Walentine
>The large diameter is the main advantage of the shaper, IMO. The wider cutting arc leaves a smoother surface and results in less tearout than a similar profile with a smaller root diameter. The shaper also is a lot faster for things like panel raising, but that isn't usually an issue for a hobbyist.
Regardless of whether you get yourself a shaper, you need a router table for all kinds of stuff, so I'd start there.
Ellis Walentine, Host
Re: Router Verse Shaper
John Renzetti
>Hi, With a good router and a stable well made table you can accomplish pretty much the same thing that a shaper can do. But just not as fast. Both have their place. I really like using the shaper. One of the advantages as Ellis mentioned is that with the mass of the cutterhead and the power behind it, I am able to raise panels or cut profiles that are very smooth in one pass. As someone once described to me, a shaper cutter that can weigh 10-15lbs doesn' cut the wood, it melts it. If you ever need to cut a lot of moulding, the shaper stands out. A did a job for a friend were we cut a lot of 10-12 ft long boards for moulding. I stood on one end and fed the material, he caught. The power feeder kept the material tight to the table and the job was done in minutes.
As with a lot of things that are done as a hobby, the pleasure factor comes into play and if the budget allows, the item purchased can be very expensive-i.e bass boats, pick up trucks, computers, golf, boats, etc.
If you do decide to get a shaper get one that has at least a 3hp motor and can handle 1.25" bore cutters.
take care,
John
Re: Router Verse Shaper
Tom Stockton
>Garry
A lot of good advice. A basic very sturdy router table doesn't need to cost a fortune. For a first table I would not spend my money on fancy fences and router lifts make the table and use it , then figure what upgrades you want.
I worked in a shop with both a router and a shaper and the router table was used 95% of the time. The shaper was used mostly for pattern shaping chair legs and stuff like that.
The other consideration is tooling even premium quality router bits are fairly reasonable while good quality shaper cutters are astonishingly expensive. If you do production work or use the same cutter a lot this is less of a problem but if you only need it once paying for the cutter hurts. If I know I'm going to use a router bit for one job I have no problem buying a decent quality Taiwanese bit because they are half the cost of the premium ones.
With a little planning you should be able to make a router table that works well for $150 in a weekend not including the router.
Tom
Heck, I was expecting some poetry.
Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI
>