Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

need opinion

Posts

need opinion

#1

need opinion

Patrick Capobianco

>I'm making my daughter a bed, I need 4 posts 3 1/2" x 3 1/2" x 48". The posts will be painted I was thinking of gluing up some common 2x4's or should I glue up some pine boards?

Re: need opinion

#2

Re: need opinion

Jim Dillon

>Patrick,

Shouldn't be any problem, but keep in mind that regular 2 x 4s have slightly rounded edges and are 3 1/2 inches wide to begin with. So if you are shooting for a leg with no surface "defects", then you will have to cut off 1/8 inch or so from each edge. On-the-other-hand, leaving the 2x4 as is might be just fine for your purpose. If you have a router, you could chamfer or round over the edges to add a decorative touch - and to prevent your daughter getting from getting any splinters. Try to pick the very best 2 x 4s you can to avoid problems later on. Prime them first before painting to minimize bleed at the knots. Have fun.

Jim

Re: need opinion

#3

Re: need opinion

Charles Sharp

>I don't see a problem using 2x4's, however make sure they are KD (Kiln Dried) or you may have problems with the sap coming out.

I made the mistake of using a common 2x12 when making a headboard for my son. The paint kept bubbling up.

Re: need opinion

#4

Re: need opinion

Sawdust Everywhere!

>Patrick,

if you glue up 2x4's, you will have a groove (or "flute") running down the middle of 2 of the 4 sides because the 2x4 is rounded over on all 4 sides.

I don't know if that was included in the design, or if you wanted a flat surface on all 4 sides of the post. Well, you could take that off at the jointer if you didn't want the groove, but your post will be less than 3-1/2 square, probably close to 3-1/8 x 3-1/2. If you glue up pine boards that have been ripped to width, the groove will not ba a problem.

Structually in your case, it will not make any difference whether you glue up two 2x4's or a series of pine boards.

Would it be easier to buy pine or douglas fir posts that are 4x4?

JW

Re: need opinion

#5

Re: need opinion

Steve Roxberg

>Why not glue up Poplar, it paints really nice and you would get the exact size you need. Around here I can get Kiln Dried Poplar for $1.60 a BF so it's cheap as well.

Re: need opinion

#6

Re: need opinion

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>The issues I would have are: (1) KD 2X4's are construction lumber and are only dried to (as I remember) 16%. There may be some issues with warp / shrinkage etc. unless they are acclimated to your house (several weeks). Second - the 2X4's have rounded edges so unless jointed will have a gap in the center etc. As was mentioned Poplar is pretty cheap & might make a better choice.

Re: need opinion

#7

Not the same Kiln Dried...

Grant Smith

>Constructions lumber, even if Kiln Dried is usually on dried down to 25% MC. Contrast this with Kiln dried hardwood at between 8-10% MC. There should be no issues so long as the construction grade lumber is properly dried before use, which might take a while if you intend to air dry it, since it is 1.5" thick. You might have luck finding and using old 2x4"s.

If it were me, I'd visit a local hardwood supplier and find some Poplar or something else cheap to use and glue that up.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: need opinion

#8

Re: need opinion

Matt Berry

>I'm more on the side of avoiding using a 2x4 myself, and agree with using poplar, pine boards or something similar.

Here is the reasons, most 2x4 may or may not be pine, they are grown super quick (wide growth rings) and are really weak. They are so prone to splitting and movement it's not even funny. Other issues are high moisture content, sap leakage, rounded edges, did I mention the fast growth?

Personally I use #1 soft maple for hidden or painted projects. Why, because it is reasonably hard, paints well, easy to work, and most places have it available relatively cheap (of course you must break away from the borg)

Re: need opinion

#9

Consider...

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>making the legs hollow by gluing up equal width strips of poplar in a box pattern. Any decent lumber yard will have trim grade finger jointed 4/4 poplar in 4x,6x,8x,etc. Just rip it to the right width. If you want something heavier, try 5/4 yellow pine stair tread stock.

Clint

Re: need opinion

#10

Re: need opinion

Barry Irby

>I have made a bunch of pine furniture out of construction lumber. I found that I liked the yellow pine better than the Spruce/Pine/Fir (SPF) stuff studs were made of. What I found was that 2 x8's or 2 x 10's could be ripped nicely into 3 1/2" stock. Larger boards, almost by definition came out of larger (older) trees. They were straighter and tighter grained. What I did was bring the lumber home and sometimes just store it in the house a while to let it acclimate or sometimes I rough cut it down into "blanks" and them let them dry or acclimate before final sizing. If you are careful, I think you can get 3 3/8� square posts with little trouble. Stay away from Pine 4x4's. They almost always include the pith or center of the tree and are very prone to warp. The wood near the pith grew quickly when the tree was juvenile and its bad news.

Re: need opinion

#11

My Thoughts Exactly, Steve

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Patrick,

Poplar is popular for good reasons. In your case you'll have an exact dimension to mill to, and no problems with rounded edges when gluing up. It paints exceedingly well, as Steve indicated.

George

Re: need opinion

#12

Re: need opinion

Howard Acheson

>Construction dimensional lumber (2x4's) are air dried to about 19% to reduce their weight for shipping purposes. Air dried lumber is not marked "KD". The 2x4's marked "DK" are further dried to either 16% or to 12%. Generally, for US lumber, the "KD" in the latter cases are marked "KD16" or "KD12". If you are working in a time where the relative humidity is above 75% - 80%, wood dried to 12% is perfect. If you are at a lower RH, then you need to further dry the wood in your shop.