Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

Posts

Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#1

Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

Hub in Ontario

>Last fall, in an issue of Fine Woodworking, there was an article on that caught my eye on a country hutch built by Marty Milkovits. This article was especially timely as I was/am considering building just such a piece and the drawings for this piece could be purchased through FWW.

So I ordered them and waited anxiously. Now I must say that I live in Canada and the mail service between here and the US is notoriously slow and it was just prior to Christmas but ���... When they did arrive, I gave them a cursory glance and immediately noted a number of dimensional errors on one view. I sent an e-mail to the folks at FWW in late January and after a reminder e-mail, in late March they did send me a note saying that they had also found a couple of errors and would send corrected drawings. In the interim, I noticed some corrections in the editorial pages of a subsequent issue of FWW and on March 15 I received an e-mail from FWW telling me of an additional 20 errors and the corrections. I was also told that if in doubt, I should use the scale and measure the parts.

Low and behold about two weeks ago I received updated drawings and again I gave them a cursory glance and what do I find, yet more errors. I wrote to them about the errors and I was once again told that �when in doubt, follow the scale, not the text�. I was also told, and I paraphrase, that the drawings are a guideline and the error some folk make is following the drawings too closely ?????

After this lengthy explanation, I am left wondering if it is me. I was from an industry where the drawings were the rule and you followed the drawing. I admit, I am not as experienced or as talented as you folk hence my desire to buy the drawings but am I wondering I am wrong in that I should expect complete and correct drawings.

I will go on record as saying the folk at FWW have been very nice but I cannot buy their explanation and as a result, I don�t feel I can buy any more of their drawings. I am really hestitating committing the cherry to this project.

I also want to say that Marty Milkovits has been both very helpful and understanding of any questions I might have.

Am I just too inexperienced or expecting too much? � comments?

Thanks in advance

Mike

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#2

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Matt Berry

>While I do believe that drawings and such are just "guidelines" in my book, I also think that if you buy prints or measured drawings they should be correct. They should also allow you to recreate the piece being shown.

With that said, before I start a project, I either make my own drawings (Paper to Sketchup) or modify an existing plan. I try to think through the whole project, planning joinery (a lot of plans need joinery changes), and the whole execution of the project.

There is nothing wrong with following a print to the T, but once you get away from doing that it allows you a lot more freedom with all aspects of the project.

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#3

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Well, I would expect the drawings to be accurate, hey, you paid for them, right? I'd ask for my money back.

Seems like they're making the customer debug the drawings instead of checking them themselves. Reminds me of another company, this one in the software business...

DC

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#4

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Hub,

I understand your frustration. When I used to follow drawings published by magazines to the letter I found that at least once in the project that I discovered dimensional errors. I came to not trust plans for my dimensions after a few of those episodes. Woodsmith was the only magazine actually that never steered me wrong...

I have now found that if I like a plan I see in a magazine that I hand draw my own plans from them, developing my own measurements and lists...I am now more comfortable that way.

Any publication that produces a dimanesional cut list is a risk for error, they usually publish a discalimer that you need to verify the measurements yourself.

I know, you paid for the plans...but in the end it's still your wood and I know what it's like to recut or rescale a project becasue of a measurement error..

:-)

Welcome to the club.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#5

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Tim Caley - North Little Rock

>Do you by any chance mean the one the puts out a virus that claims to be an operating system? :-)

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#6

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Pete LaBelle

>I agree with the other guys. Suggest you ask for your money back. A purchased drawing is expected to be right.

If I give a supplier a drawing and the end product is not what I wanted, but was built to the drawing specs, they are legally right in the situation. A purchased drawing is kinda like a contract.

If someone in the design business intends on making money off his work, his work needs to be right, else he won't be making money for long.

The comment about "scaling the drawing" is a poor excuse. Dimensions need to be right. Copy processes do not always produce a drawing exactly as the master.

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#7

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>Marty is a great guy and is a valued member of our NH guild. I will be fortunate enough to spend a good bit of the Saturday after next in his shop in Mason, NH. He's always very helpful.

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#8

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Now, that would be harsh a bit, no? :-)

DC

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#9

QC process needed

Jesse in New Mexico

>The prevalence of errors in dimensional drawings leads me to suspect that the magazines have no process, or a very poor one, for checking drawings. If anyone out there has a good process, you could do us all a favor by sharing.

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#10

Get your money back

Brian in SLO

>I don't care what it is. If I buy a gallon of milk I expect a gallon. If they give you something that is not 100% do they discount it the appropriate amount? If you payed for something you expect it to be complete.

What is Taunton doing? Maybe they'll change the name of the magazine to KFWW (Kinda Fine Woodwoorking).

Ask for correct plans or get your money back.

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#11

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Charles Sharp

>I would have no trouble asking for a refund.

If the furniture maker is not a draftsman, he should hire one if he's going to sell the drawings.

Having grown up in a machine shop I was taught to NEVER scale drawings. Most of the drawings I have seen had a note to that effect on them.

I design in AutoCad because for me it's faster, but also when it's time to add dimensions, they are correct. The other reason is that I find I usually leave some dimension off that I need when I start construction and it's easy to get it.

It's too bad that such a fine publication makes excuses for selling a shoddy product.

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#12

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Hub in Ontario

>Thanks for all of your comments and I wasnt to be sure I am clear, Marty Milkovots did not do the drawings. They were done by FWW personnel.

Again, thanks and I am glad to see I should have expected more.

Mike

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#13

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Tim Caley - North Little Rock

>Noun 1. computer virus - a software program capable of causing great harm to files or other programs on the same computer without human assistance.

I rest my case.........

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#14

Ellis Walentine

Speaking as a magazine editor...

Ellis Walentine

>... I can tell you that when I was where the buck stopped, I personally looked at every drawing and every piece of "arttype" as it was known at our magazine. Part of the problem is typographical. When an editor edits an article, he/she creates a separate arttype list for each illustration. The list includes all drawing titles, text, captions and dimensions -- that's all. There could easily be typos in there, and by the time the art director gets done marrying all that gobbledygook to the illustrator's drawing, more info may have been lost or corrupted. Nothing short of fastidious checking will catch all the errors. (Also, many times, the illustrator may have made his/her own errors of scaling or positioning of elements, etc. that further confuse the reader.)

Jim Cummins was a real ace at proofing drawings. When he was a contributing editor for American Woodworker, we'd send him drawings to proof for us. He said it took several hours to do it right, and I suspect he knew what he was talking about.

Whether making drawings for my own use or proofing others' drawings, the important thing is to make sure that all the little dimensions add up to the big ones. If they don't, something is wrong. Also be sure that critical dimensions are correct, such as door or drawer opening dimensions or clearance dimensions for parts that swing or retract. Once you have the corrected drawing in front of you, make sure that you make any necessary changes to the dimensions on the drawing as a result of material variances from the specs.There are probably more rules of thumb, but I'm tapped out for now.

Hope this puts things in perspective.

Ellis

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#15

Always check the numbers.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Having done drawings off and on for forty plus years rarely have I seen a drawing that didn't have errors. Even back when we had checkers to go over everything in great detail they missed things. Having said that if the drawing is done to scale then missing dimensions should not be a problem. Always check some of the dimensions to make sure the drawing is done to scale, then it is easy to find any missing dimensions. This is not 100% reliable but probably the closest you will find. I have found that solid modeling will give the most accurate drawings but very few folks have that kind of software available.

Ray

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#16

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Anatole Burkin

>To say the least, we hit a few bumps in the road with this plan. I apologize to anyone who has been frustrated with the product. If you spot errors, let us know. The goal is to have these plans 100% accurate. When mistakes are found, we will reprint them and reissue replacements to our customers.

Plans are a new venture for us. We actually don't do the CAD files in house; we outsource them. The CAD files are then transferred into Illustrator here. Between working with new authors, new draftsmen, and a whole new process, some errors were made. Since then we have created a new process with more checks and balances to insure a high level of accuracy. And we're training our customer service reps to be more helpful when problems arise.

We're also looking for a few good men and women to hire as proofreaders for plans. If you are interested, send me an email and give me a bit of background on your woodworking and drawing experience. Serious amateurs and pros alike will be considered.

--Anatole Burkin

Publisher

Fine Woodworking

aburkin@taunton.com

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#17

We're On The Same Page, Jim

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Hub,

I've also ordered plans/drawings over the internet and found errors in dimensions. I am neither prolific nor expert, but the thought soon occurred to me to place my trust in my own reconing. Therefore, I draw my own plans and sketches and rely on mags and internet-acquired plans for general guidance. Current project provided me only with pix and overall LWH dimensions. The first try came out pretty good!

George

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#18

Good post, now, any takers?

Martin from Granbury

>

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#19

Re: Good post, now, any takers?

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>Sure thing, Martin. Already emailed him.

FWIW, I have not had to correct any of the dimensions in the plans in my book, "Router Joinery Workshop," and its been out several years now.

Sufficient credentials?

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#20

Yes, Carol, you are well qualified!

Martin from Granbury

>

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and question

#21

Re: Purchased drawings - long explanation and ques

Hub in Ontario

>Thank you for your post.