Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

efficiency of air filters in series

Posts

efficiency of air filters in series

#1

efficiency of air filters in series

billfrommich

>I have a question about how combining air filters in series (so that air passes through the first filter before passing through the second filter)affects there overall efficiency. Suppose I stack 2 filters that individually remove 99% of particles above 1 micron in size. Is the combined effectiveness then 99.99% at removing particles above 1 micron in size? This is not a mathematical question so much as a question of whether air filters behave in this manner, if you follow me.

Re: efficiency of air filters in series

#2

More of cost efficiency?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Not sure, but I think the main reason for stacking air filters in series like that (assuming you're talking about a hanging-type workshop air filter) is that you can use cheaper coarser filters in the front and replace them more often, easing the burden on the more expensive filters and increasing their life.

For instance, I replace 3 of the $1 filters before I have to replace the $9 filter.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: efficiency of air filters in series

#3

Re: More of cost efficiency?

billfrommich

>Thanks for the reply Mark. Actually what prompted my question was some opinions voiced in various forms that even a cyclone separator followed by a bag or cannister filter that is 99% effective at removing dust 1 micron or larger is still not good enough - that you should have better than HEPA standard filtering or else exhaust the collector air outside (not always an option). But I see your point that you can use cheaper coarse filters (as prefilters) to protect your more expensive fine filter.

Re: efficiency of air filters in series

#4

Re: More of cost efficiency?

Phil Joines Krum,TX

>It's the super fine dust that really gets into your lungs. No filter can be 100% effective, especially something like a cyclone that has to move a lot of air. That's why N95 and N100 dust masks and things like the airstream helmets are available.

But to answer your question, there are three stage filters. The outer catches the coarse bits, the second gets the smaller and the third, usually a bag filter, gets the fines but nothing gets it all.

Re: efficiency of air filters in series

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Not quite.....

Jesper, Denmark

>The filter efficiency is based on total removal so the large particles, that are easy to remove count in the efficiency calculations.

The primary filter will remove most of the dust, but as the mean particle size of the dust the comes through to the second filter is now much smaller, the efficiency of the second filter is no longer 99%.

It may only remove 50% of the now average 1 micrin size dust, so your efficiency should be something like 99% plus half of the remaing 1% = 99.5%.

Like Mark stated, the primary reason for two stages is that the last stage lasts much longer.

Typical industrial filtration systems for paint dust would look like this:

Primary ASHRAE 50% - takes all the "big" stuff and is replaced weekly.

Secondary ASHRAE 65% - takes the bulk of the rest and is replaced monthly.

Final ASHRAE 95% - provides the final filtrsation down to around 1 micron and is replaced annually.

Removing particles less than 0.5 micron is very difficult and requires HEPA style filters, which are very expensive and not really applicable to WW.

To get down around 0.25 microns requires high pressure drop Venturi scrubbers - also not in WW applications and certainly not in small shops.

Re: efficiency of air filters in series

#6

Re: Not quite.....

billfrommich

>Jesper, I understand your point as it would apply to filters that are characterised with a single "efficiency" value for their aggragate performance on a wide ranging particle size distribution. I should have further explained that I am reffering to filters that give the efficiency for each particle size in the distribution, and the efficiency is 99% (or better) for all particles above 1 micron in size (which is to say that if you fed the filter pure 1 micron size dust, 99% would be removed). But I was encouraged by your information on industry practices - if the third (finest) filter is only replaced yearly in an industrial environment then perhaps this won't be as costly as I thought it might be!

Re: efficiency of air filters in series

#7

Re: Not quite.....

Barry Irby

>I'm not an expert, but I suspect the answer to your question is that if you stack two equal filters and the first one catches 99 percent, leaving only particle 1 micron and smaller, the second one will not capture nearly 99 percent of those. Probably more like ten or twenty percent.

I have a homemade air scrubber and it has three filters that the air comes in through and one that it exits through. The three filters get really coated with a physical layer of dust maybe an 1/8" thick if I don't clean it regularly, but the other filter that is of equal quality only gets dirty, with very little apparent buildup.

I suspect that part of Jesper's "equation" is that the area of the filters in the industrial systems gets larger as the particle size gets smaller. I hear of industrial units that have "bag trees" with the equivalent of hundreds of square feet of bag material. OTOH, they are moving huge volumes of air. Might be smart for me to reverse my system and have less and coarser inlets and more and finer outlet areas.

Re: efficiency of air filters in series

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Not quite.....

Jesper, Denmark

>The determination of filter efficiency is a bag of worms. ASHRAE has some specific test procedures that are impossible to duplicate in real life. My understanding is that even though they can specify efficiencies by particle size, they do rely on some of the larger particles adding filter surface and efficiency to the 1 micron stuff.

It is a bit like the HP ratings of Universal motors: Who has the equipment to accurately measure????

If a filter is rated 99% at 1 micron, how are you going to prove or disprove it??

Re: efficiency of air filters in series

#9

Re: Not quite.....

billfrommich

>Jesper, I think you're correct in pointing out that if a filter relies on building up a what is called a "dust cake" to reach its claimed efficiency, then the second filter, being "starved" of dust, may not do so. Or perhaps you would have to interchange the filters - after the first filter has built up the required dust, it is moved into the second position. Also, as you say, who really knows if you can trust the measurements, or what they really mean, even if honestly obtained and reported.

Re: efficiency of air filters in series

#10

Re: Not quite.....

eliot d

>On a related question that I have always wondered about, given that no matter what you do, there is always some dust that doesn't get filtered out, how do you go about figuring out what is the concentration of dust in your shop? What are safe levels? There must be a way because OSHA measures it for industrial settings. I'm not talking about the efficiency of any particular filter; I'm asking about the air in the shop.