Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Warping

Posts

Warping

#1

Warping

Jim Hoeller

>I recently built a slant front desk out of quarter sawn white oak. After assembling the side pieces, they cupped a bit (about 1/4" to 5/16"). I dampened the concave surface, clamped them convex to convex side and was able to eliminate the cuping. The side pieces are about 21" wide.

The sides of the desk were dadoed for the interior writing surface and two dust frames for the shallow drawers. The writing surface was glued all the way across the width and the dust frames only at the back of the desk. I fumed the desk and then finished it with three coats of General semi-gloss wipe on oil based varnish.

After delivering the completed desk, the sides again warped but in the opposite direction and more towards the front of the desk.

Any thoughts on why this occurred and what can be done to correct the problem.

Thanks

Jim Hoeller

Re: Warping

#2

Ouch

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Joe,

You wouldn't expect quarter sawn stock to move around like that if it was dry and acclimatized to the shop. It sounds to me you had a drying problem, or differential sealing once the desk was fabricated.

George

Re: Warping

#3

Re: Warping

Terry in Edmonton

>Wait awhile. I have had the same thing happen and everything settled back into place in about 2 weeks. Probably not quite dry enough? The finish may have contributed to the existing problem. I wouldn't worry yet.

Re: Warping

#4

Ellis Walentine

Trying to picture this, Jim...

Ellis Walentine

>Just so I have the story straight, the grain of the sides runs vertical and the top is a solid piece of wood glued into dados in the sides? Sounds good so far. They should all move at the same rate if they were of similar species and moisture content when you made the desk. So what is cupping now? Are the sides bowing out? If so, does this mean the glue joints between the writing surface and the sides is broken?

I wouldn't have expected any of this from quartersawn wood if it was at equilibrium when you planed it. Is there a chance that the wood had a moisture gradient in it, that is, it was drier on one side than the other?

I don't know what to tell you. In a pinch, maybe you can pull things together with screws and plugs. I hate to give advice like that, though.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Warping

#5

Re: Trying to picture this, Jim...

Jim Hoeller

>The wood was purchased 10 or more years prior to using it for the desk. A friend with a small custom sawmill offer a deal on about 100BF kiln dried of it at a price I could'nt pass up. It was stickered and sat on a rack for many years before I had projects that warranted its use. None of the other pieces have warped and shrinkage/expansion of the lid/writing surface relative to the breadboard ends is barely perceptable.

The sides did pull away from the interior writing surface. The glue appears to have held but the wood on the ends failed. I did notice that there had been only minimal contact between the end of the writing surface and the bottom of the dado.

Would a hair dryer directed to the inside, unfinished surface dry it enough to allow to be drawn back into position? I could then use screws to secure it and plug the holes.

Thanks

Re: Warping

#6

Ellis Walentine

Sorry to be late with this reply

Ellis Walentine

>I wouldn't try to fiddle with the moisture gradient in your side boards, Jim. It's hit or miss and the wood would revert eventually to equilibrium, which means that any cup you adjusted would return.

This is a tough call. Glue alone already has proven inadequate. I think if it were me, I'd bite the bullet right now and clamp the piece back together with beams to flatten the sides against the endgrain of the top. If you can get some glue in there, fine, but what you really need at this point is mechanical fasteners -- screws -- maybe two on each end. Counterbore them and make plugs to match the grain of the side pieces and your customer will never know they're there.

My 2¢,

Ellis Walentine, Host