>I'm making a walnut table. The legs are 3 3/4" square at the top and turned at the bottom. The rails are 4 3/8 wide. The table top is 70 X 42". I'm making mortise and tenon connections for the rails into the legs. This is a somewhat expanded copy of an antique.
My question is, would you add any sort of bracing to the inside of the leg? I cut a flat surface or 45 degree chamfer off the inside corner of the pommel or square haunch at the top of the leg. I could run a brace across at a 45. Or I could run a piece straight in at a forty five and tie it to a cross brace under the table.
>Barry, it sounds like you have enough wood to do a large enough M&T joint at the leg and Apron, so long as the apron hits the leg near the outside, rather than farther in, where they get in the way of each other from long to short sides.
That 45� corner brace thing is usually done on cheaper tables that don't have M&T joints, but rather a bolt into the leg through the brace.
That 42 x 70 sounds too wide for my liking. Be sure to cut out a cardboard mock-up and get it approved before getting too far. However that may just be a personal thing for my taste.
>Barry, I'm almost finished with a table that is nearly the exact same dimensions as yours though my legs are slightly smaller at the top. I used floating tenons and the table is rock solid. I think you'll be fine without any corner bracing.
>I agree with you about the 42". I thought it was too wide. Went back and forth with my cousin. (Table is a wedding gift for her daughter.) This is the one they wanted walnut with "character" I posted about a few weeks ago. I went back to the stash of wood and got seven 1 X 6's and when they were cleaned up and glued the top came out 41". I suggested that if she were locked in on the width I could put a 7" wide board in the center, but she thought the 41" width was OK.
I was just thinking about the leg connection. I have made the mortises 3/8 by two inches deep by 3 1/2 wide. Left the closed at the top. And they are one inch in from the out surface of the legs. They could have been deeper, but I did not see the point. Just did not think a three inch deep mortise intersecting the one at ninety degrees would be strong or even as strong.
Don't have any 5/4 stock so the rails are slightly over 3/4". If I had used one inch rails, I would have used half inch thick mortises.
I am considering laminating the rails. Anyone got any sage advice on any of this?
>That's reassuring. You know how it is. I just did not want to get it put together and have one of those "wish I had fastened these legs better while I had the chance" moments.
It�s funny what will �get� you. The rails on this table are just about two inches too long to stand up in my tennoning jig. Curse that low ceiling. Hmmm? Wonder how she would feel about a 68� table?
The good news is that you should be able to make a stable table base with the rails you've got, but I would recommend making the joints a bit differently. The leg-rail joint is a special situation where you can throw out all your preconceptions about the thickness and shape of the tenon. In a kitchen cabinet door, 3/8" is a good thickness for a tenon on a 3/4" rail (I actually prefer 5/16") because it is going into 3/4" stile and you don't want the mortise cheeks too thin. On a table rail, the tenon is going into a much wider piece, so you can make it thicker without compromising the strength of the leg. I suggest creating a tenon with a scant 1/8" shoulder on each side -- just enough to keep the rail from rocking up and down or side to side once the glue sets.
In this case, you've chosen a rather narrow width for your rail. On a table this size, 5" or more is common -- so people can get their knees under it comfortably when seated -- because you want the widest tenon possible to keep the table from racking over time or under extreme conditions. But, I think that your 3 1/2" tenon width is about ideal for a rail of this height. Just make the bottom shoulder very small -- again, 1/8" is plenty -- and the top shoulder as small as possible without compromising the short grain on the top of the leg mortise. In this case, that would be about 3/4".
Regarding tenon depth, if you have 3 3/4"-square legs, I'd suggest longer tenons for more glue area, but 2" will probably work. Normally, my eye is used to seeing rails that are inset only 1/8" to, say, 3/8" from the face of the leg. I suspect this is because generations of joiners have come to the same conclusion about tenon length, and they traditionally place the rails nearer the outside face of the leg to achieve the greater depth. For what it's worth, I generally make my mortises so they meet at the bottom, and make the tenons with mitered ends so they almost touch when the joint is assembled, regardless of where the rail is placed on the leg.
So, the upshot of all this is that I think your tenons should be 1/2" thick by 2 1/2"-3" long by 3 1/2" high, and if you have the option of making the rails wider, go for it.
I read somewhere that the tennon was "supposed" to be about 1/3 the thickness of the rail. But now that I think about it, I think that was because the stile was the same thickness in a door application and they did not want the cheeks to be too thin. Just what you said.
I set these back a bit because the corners of the pommels on the legs are radiused. Figured with big fat legs I could trade a little and still have long enough tennons.
My thinking was that this was some sort of trade off between the tennon size and the shoulders. Assuming the mortise is sound and does not crack or deform, any forces applied to the legs and rails would get translated to deforming the tennon or trying to withdraw the tennons and the shoulders would act as fulcrums.
I have a half inch bit for my mortiser attachment on my DP. I bought a sharpener kit and have sharpened it. It awaits only the hand of the woodworker to drive it into the wood. I shall go forth and mortise.
>I don't think it is the corners that will need reinforcing. With 3/4" rails, I would want a couple of braces running across the width, so that the rails won't be bowing when the top changes width with the seasons. The cross braces would make it easier for the top to move relative to the rails. For example you could dovetail a 1 x 2 across between rails, top and bottom.
>I agree with the other posts about no need for corner braces.
Another thing to think about is wood movement and how you will attach the table top to the base. A 42 inch wide top can move a lot if there is a dramatic change in humidity.
Last table I built, I used brackets with sliding dovetails. The male dovetail on the bracket runs about an inch, then the rest of the bracket is flush with the table top. The top has a compound groove cut in it with a straight groove wide enough to place the dovetail part. You then slide the dovetail into the rest of the groove which is dovetail shaped. This allows for a lot of movement and looks attractive, though you only see it if you are below the table. ;^)
>I was already thinking about that. I don't really like the 3/4 rails. I am considering laminating another piece of walnut to the inside of them. I think this might be a good place to use some of the crappy sappy stuff I have. Also plan on putting a couple of rabbets in them and running some cross braces across under the top. I will probably make those about 2 to 2 1/2" wide or "tall" so they will be higher than the rails and not bump your knees.
>Thanks Jesse, I have been pondering the connection of the top. I think I might go to the "Shrinkulator" and look up the movement. I see you are in New Mexico. This table is air dried walnut in VA, headed for Charlston, SC. Better allow for plenty of movement.