Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

What band saw?

Posts

What band saw?

#1

What band saw?

Muskie

>I started turning the beginning of the year and now I am planning on purchasing a 14" band saw (and riser block) in order to create my own blanks. Am considering the Jet, Delta and Powermatic.

Any thoughts or suggestions? Just read the reviews on the Powermatic and they were not terribly positive.

Re: What band saw?

#2

Re: What band saw?

Paul Waddle

>Any you mentioned are good band saws. They do not compare favoribly with the italians,but you get what you pay for in band saws. IMO,if this would be my main tool,go for the best,if it is used for lathe turnings and other not-so demanding work,all the aforementioned will do nicely.

Re: What band saw?

#3

Re: What band saw?

Barry Irby

>I have a Delta with a riser and the original motor. Works well enough with the right blade. OTOH, if I had known how much I would spend on it adding the riser, new guides, dust collection etc, I would have considered a bigger heavier duty saw to start with. But then, I want mine to do everything. Sawing bowl blanks and resawing boards into veneer are very different jobs for a bandsaw. What I really need is two saws, but if I left it setup for bowl blanks it would be OK. (OK, as in cursing it with faint praise.)

Re: What band saw?

#4

Re: What band saw?

Matt Berry

>Well to further muddy the waters there are a few more choices to throw in the mix. You just might want to consider getting a bigger saw from the start, more power is nice.

Look at

Mini-Max http://www.minimax-usa.com/

General Machinery http://www.general.ca/

Laguna Tools http://www.lagunatools.com/bandsaws.htm

Grizzly http://www.minimax-usa.com/

I've had a Jet 14" BS for about 10 years, it is a decent saw, even though it is sometimes a little underpowered. Now they have made many changes since I first purchased my saw,so they are a little bit different then my saw. A 1/4" blade actually seems to work better then a 1/2" blade on these saws. Good luck with your decision.

Re: What band saw?

#5

Re: What band saw?

Pete LaBelle

>Took delivery of a JET JWBS 14DX a couple weeks ago along with the riser block. 1.25hp motor. That was my choice among all the 14" saws out there. Haven't used it much yet, but all the indicators are that I'll have a saw I'll be pleased with. Planning on general bandsaw use, along with cutting bowl blanks from green wood.

Things that steered me were:

- cast iron wheels

- riser block option

- HP

- how beefy the table trunion system appeared

- no drive belt within the enclosed lower wheel chamber

- enclosed base

- overall height (low ceilings in the basement shop)

- cost

Re: What band saw?

#6

Re: What band saw?

wilbur

>If you are thinking about a 14" bandsaw/riser combination to get more vertical capacity, you may want to think about moving up to a 16" or 18" bandsaw. One thing to keep in mind is that you'll get better results through thick wood with a beefier blade. On a 14" bandsaw, that blade will have to make a tighter turn and gets stressed more in the process, leading to a reduced blade life. This won't be the case on a bandsaw with a larger wheel diameter. Besides, you'll get a bigger motor as well, which will help with thick stock.

Re: What band saw?

#7

JL

Re: 2nd Wilbur's opinion..

JL

>Why not just get a 16" or 18"? Steel City has their 18" at a Atl dealer for about $1300 and a Jet 18" for about $1200 and Woodcraft has the Rikon 18" for about $1150. I have an 18" Rikon that I like.

By the time you add on the cost of the riser block and the other things you will need, that'll be another couple of hundred dollars to the cost of your 14". You'll also have a more powerful motor.

If you are buying it used, that's another story. If you can get an old Delta (or whatever) and add a riser block (and the other things you'll need) - you can have a reasonable 18" for a lot less.

Re: What band saw?

#8

Re: What band saw?

Verne in Northeast NJ

>I've had a 1 hp Delta with riser block for 7 years now, and I really like it. It has done everything I've needed it to do from occassional resawing to cutting dovetails. It's been a good machine and I've had no problems with it. You can upgrade to a 1 1/2 hp motor with no modification if you feel it's underpowered (I haven't).

If you're not planning on doing a lot of resawing I see no real reason why you'd *need* a larger saw. If you *want* a larger saw, then that's another matter! ;-)

Re: What band saw?

#9

Re: What band saw?

Falberg saw Co

>All two-wheeled band saws are about the same, with only minor differences; so get the cheapest old used one you can find. Take great care, however, in the blades you use. Therein lies true happiness.