Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Question ?

Posts

Question ?

#1

Question ?

Ricky Johnson

>I am in the process of designing and setting up my first real workshop. I am purchasing a good quality table saw, band saw, jointer and drill press for a start. I am not sure weather to buy a shaper or a nice router table. Can you give me some advice.

Thanks, Ricky !

Re: Question ?

#2

Re: Question ?

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>A router is one of the basic tools in today's woodworking. Having one that fits in a table is also one of the basic applications of that particular tool.

It is not matter of either/or. It is a matter of when.

The router and it's table first. Later, the kind of work you choose to do within the very large world of woodworking will determine whether or not you have a need for a shaper.

Congratulations and welcome to our crazy world. There are many 'slippery slopes' for you to enjoy. Keep coming back. We love additions to our addiction. :))

Re: Question ?

#3

There was a time when,

Keith Newton

>the answer would have been obviously to go with a shaper. However now, with so many good router bit options, it is cheaper and they are more easily set up.

So my advice would be to start with the router, but it will be hard for anyone to give you any very meaningful advice without knowing more about what you will be making in your shop, and where in the world you are relative to other suppliers.

I have three good shapers, and seven routers, three of which can be set in tables at once to make doors etc. But I think it may end up being cheaper to have them made by a door shop, than making them myself.

However if you are into doing restoration or things where you may need short runs of unusual moldings that require special knives, then you are getting back over into needing the shaper.

Re: Question ?

#4

Re: Question ?

john lucas

>I would never give up my router. It's very handy in the router table but I also use it for all sorts of things handheld. It will do things a shaper can't, and vice versa, but I think most amateur woodworkers would be better off with a router and router table.

Re: Question ?

#5

JL

Re: Question ?

JL

>Given the relative power of some of the routers (Triton 3 1/4 hp and the new large PC routers) you are getting up to some pretty hefty power. Almost to low end shaper range. A good quality router and a good table will probably keep you happy for a little while :).

Re: Question ?

#6

Re: Question ?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Buy a lathe, you won't need most of the other stuff!

Bill

Re: Question ?

#7

Concur

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Ricky,

I'd sugggest all the responses are worth following. I have several routers, including the big P+C 7518. It gives me power to swing large diameter bits at low speeds. In a table, its a marvelous tool. Most work with or without the table is done using lighter machines and multiple bases. And, about the router table: I suggest you make your own. You can do it far less expensively and enjoy all the capability a commercial table can deliver. I use my own Norm Abram-based design. I have installed a commercial fence from Penn State Industries because its good and not too expensive. The other advantage of building your own tab;e is that you have full control over the size of the tool.\

George

Re: Question ?

#8

Before buying any tool

DB

>The first step in srtting up a work shop is to decide what you want to build. Then buy the tools that will best help you achieve that goal. If you want to make small boxes a router will be a great purchase. If you want to make entry doors then a shaper will be a better choice.

Re: Question ?

#9

Re: Question ?

Steve Schoene

>What you buy depends largely on what you want to build.

That said, you indicated you were getting a jointer. That isn't a very useful tool unless it is matched with a thickness planer. It takes both tools (or the hand plane equivalent) to square and thickness a board to be suitable for furniture making.

Re: Question ?

#10

Re: Question ?

Jim Dillon

>Morning Ricky,

First, welcome to WoodCentral. We all look forward to hearing more about your new shop and future projects. Without knowing more about what you intend to do, I would go with a large HP router. Next you must decide whether to build a router table or buy one. Another option, since you are getting a tablesaw, is to attach an extension table to your saw and mount the router into that extension table. There are many, many plans floating around for stand-alone router tables and fences. Building a nice router table would increase your skills at using your other tools as well. As space was limited, I went the route of inserting my router in the tablesaw extension and copying (with modification) the fence used by Norm Abrams on NYW. It has served me well. Good luck, and the more specific your future questions can be, the better we can help you.

Jim

Re: Question ?

#11

Re: Question ?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Welcome to the "money pit" of woodworking. As others have said, a lot depends on what you are going to build.

However, I don't have a shaper. (yet)- I do have a large 3 1/4 hp Porter Cable plunge variable speed router mounted in a homebuilt router table. You may want to look at the cost of shaper cutters. It is far more economical to purchase the router bits for all the various style cuts you want to make in the average home shop. I have about as much money in my router table with a commercial fence and "router raiser" as I would have in a 1 1/2 hp shaper but the bit cost made it a better choice for me. You do need the variable speed router if you are going to use large bits like panel raising (horizontal) - lock miter etc. I also have a smaller PC router set - with a plunge and fixed base. It is not variable speed as I use the big unit on the table for all large bits.

Another comment about the need for a planer is one you should evaluate. You either must have (and become proficient with) a good set of hand planes or purchase a planer if you are going to finish dimension rough sawn lumber. Due to the (lack of) availability of good, flat finished hardwood boards (and the very high cost), I consider my planers one of the most essential tools in my shop.