Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Discussion protocol

Posts

Discussion protocol

#1

Discussion protocol

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>If I open an item and see that the post is in all lower case with no punctuation, I conclude that the writer doesn't care enough about what he's saying to warrant my attention. Ditto for foul language.

Clint

Re: Discussion protocol

#2

so who is a writer?

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>last time I checked it was a message board, not a periodical. you are lucky that they are not all chat shorthand.

Re: Discussion protocol

#3

Re: Discussion protocol

Scott in Douglassville

>NBD. WWJD? YMMV. BFF?

L8R.

Re: Discussion protocol

#4

Still, Joe . . .

Henry Higginbotham

>Punctuation and capitalization make posts MUCH easier to read, and sometimes help convey what you really meant. You write it once; others read it perhaps hundreds of times. It really wouldn't hurt you to make an effort.

Re: Discussion protocol

#5

Re: Still, Joe . . .

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>I guess I'm lucky because most of the time, I have nothing important to say :)

it seams most of these threads are readable. decent enough English and punctuation. I'm just wondering where this thread is coming from.

Re: Discussion protocol

#6

I Weigh In At The Doctor's Too

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hello Clint,

I agree that it IS more difficult to read and understand, especially with weak eyes. I learned most basic knowledge of woodworking, and other valuable life lessons, from my next door neighbor. Mario came from Northern Italy and had an accent so thick that it took me literally years to easily understand him. However, it was well worth the effort. I try to set aside my initial reaction and try to see the message.

George

Re: Discussion protocol

#7

Re: I'm with Joe on this one.

Chuck Lenz

>I can think of better things to ramble on about.

Re: Discussion protocol

#8

Re: I agree Clint.

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Let's hope a few take it to heart.

Al

Re: Discussion protocol

#9

The percentage is low...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>Compared to some other forums I frequent, most posts here are fairly readable. I'd say that overall the posters here fall in the category of "educated"--or higher. Are everyone's grammar, punctuation and spelling perfect here? Of course not. Who's to judge the "effort" behind it? Maybe the poster lives in the hills of Tennessee and only made it through the third grade. Their writing shortcomings may indicate a lack of education, but not necessarily effort.

Jason

Re: Discussion protocol

#10

Lee Grindinger

You're an olde fart

Lee Grindinger

>Young folks use abbreviated text, people from other lands use imperfect English, like i do only more rarely.

Reject who you will, I'll still read em,

Lee

Re: Discussion protocol

#11

Re: The percentage is low...

Nelson

>Or that person is from a farm in Ind. and only went thru 2nd grade.

Re: Discussion protocol

#12

Just Wait, It'll Get Worse

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I've already see TMeze creeping into posts here and there.

"Wut U do bow tht?"

Oh, yeah. It's coming.

Re: Discussion protocol

#13

Eats shoots and leaves; why it matters

Michael Dresdner

>Though I certainly make every effort to understand a post no matter what, I am very much with Clint in feeling that grammar, syntax and punctuation matters.

One of my day jobs is answering questions at www.woodanswers.com. I field about ten per day and have answered well over five thousand in the past three years. Many come in with no punctuation or improper punctuation, lacking pronouns, and in very abbreviated jargon, as if they expect me to know what they are thinking.

In some cases I actually have no idea what they are asking, as their unclear descriptions could mean many different things. If I guess and guess wrong, I have wasted my time, annoyed them with a wrong answer, and wasted the sponsor's money. It does matter, and it is not an 'attitude' thing. It makes my job, which is helping others, much more difficult.

Don't believe me? Here's one that came in today:

"have 2 green wooden mushroom,what is the best for it to make tham look good ,"

Does that mean green wood, or something colored green? A comma would have told me, but the answer will be very different for one than for the other.

My unspoken question to them is always the same; "If you want my help, why are you trying to make it tough for me to help you?"

Of this message board I ask "If you are genuinely trying to communicate in English, a language fraught with confusion to begin with, why would you compound that by making your words even more difficult to decipher? The more cryptic you are, the more likely you are to be misinterpreted, both in true meaning and intent."

Re: Discussion protocol

#14

Re: Discussion protocol

Kirk (KC) Constable

>I should probably stay out of this... but I can't help myself. :-)

My personal pet peeve is spelling. Not typos, because that can happen to anybody... but folks that continually misspell common words, or words specific to their trade. Particularly distracting to me are posts about 'planners' instead of 'planers', 'rabbits' instead of 'rabbets', and 'dental' instead of 'dentil' molding.

I've given up worrying about possessive punctuation, because soooooo many people missed class that day. And 'there/their/they're' isn't worth even talking about. I know what they mean.

What constitutes 'vulgar' or 'foul' language is subjective... and in my opinion, you don't see either on this site. Someone may be 'pissed off', or 'not give a damn' about something... but folks, like it or not, this is just barely considered 'foul' nowadays... and it's a very long way from 'vulgar'.

Everybody doesn't like something... but everybody is still here.

KC

Re: Discussion protocol

#15

I'd rather see the post

Chuck Nickerson

>than have someone hold back because their English skills are weak. I have a friend who loves correcting people's grammar and pronunciation. He's starting to wonder where his friends have gone.

Re: Discussion protocol

#16

rebates?

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Kirk,

English - the disparate language separated within a border as well as outside of it.

No offence meant here - I've grown used to working in US English and using US terms. However, I still use Australian spellings and grammar as best I can.

While I have trouble wading through the wall of words, I try to do so as best as possible and answer accordingly. I spend all day working with students whose second or third language is English. They say that English and Chinese are the two hardest languages to learn, Chinese for its written characters, English for the various intonations and meanings related to homonyms(?) as well as the spelling and punctuation/grammatical rules.

Cheers,

Andrew

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Discussion protocol

#17

Re: Eats shoots and leaves; why it matters

Sgian Dubh

>""If you want my help, why are you trying to make it tough for me to help you?""

I have a similar complaint Michael-- people that phone, get through to my message system, leave a confused message, and ask me to phone them back. They close with an unintelligible gabble including their phone number spoken so fast that I haven't got a cat in Hell's chance of writing it down, even after eight or ten listenings.

I've got to the point where I simply delete the message if I can't make out their name and number after two or three listenings. I'm not going to waste five minutes of my time on that sort of nonsense.

At work I've known this go on for days or even weeks where the same caller phones repeatedly seeking the same help. If only they were considerate enough to clearly and slowly enunciate their phone number I'd be able to. Slainte.

Re: Discussion protocol

#18

Re: rebates?

Kirk (KC) Constable

>You're absolutely right... I'd hate to have to learn English as a second language. Especially spelling.

KC

Re: Discussion protocol

#19

JL

Re:I read that book...

JL

>that book and "The Deluxe Transitive Vampire" are my favorite grammar books.

Re: Discussion protocol

#20

Might I suggest...

Stephen in Utah

>'Elements of Style' by Strunk and White. A fine little book that helps with writing, fun read.

Stephen

Re: Discussion protocol

#21

I'm with Chuck...

John in New Mexico

>I'd rather see participation than ultra correct english usage.

John

Re: Discussion protocol

#22

In Defense of Malapropisms

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I can understand where responding on a helpline and to phone messages composed of fractured syntax and mumbled rants can get "old" in rather short order. But on a board such as this, the gaffs and typoes can actually be rather entertaining, and often lend a smile to what might otherwise be rather droll remarks. Lets not pass up the opportunity to laugh at ourselves while among(st) friends.

I'll certainly admit to keyboard problems, and have often wished Ellis could install an 'edit-your-post' feature to the site's software.

I also understand that to some the typoes and lack of a spell checker on the drafting screen amount to figuresnails on the blacborb. They're just things we have to deal with and get past on our own.

Re: Discussion protocol

#24

Paul Kramer

The Elements of Style by Strunk and White

Paul Kramer

>

Re: Discussion protocol

#25

Case-In-Point

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>We, like many, got hit pretty hard by last week's storm; lots of downed trees blocking back roads in my heavily wooded local area. Public Works guys did a great job getting things cleared and open, and the trees got cut and pushed to the sides of the roads.

Driving home the other day I saw that one resident had almost immediately posted 3-4 yellow "Notice - No Tresspassing" signs all over the downed large ash tree at the front of his property. Driving home this morning (with the paper and fresh bagels), I noticed a new handmade sign scrawled on a board tailed to the trunk. Just had to stop to read it, and was richly rewarded with

"KEEP OUT! OWNER WANTS ALL THE WOULD! VIOLETERS WILL BE PERSECUTED!"

I may just go back and take a picture.

Peace

mm