Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

OT- Printer recommendations

Posts

OT- Printer recommendations

#1

OT- Printer recommendations

Joanne - Dansville, NY

>Our HP Deskjet printer that we have had for many years died the other night and we are needing to purchase a new printer.

What printer would you recommend? inkjet or laser?

What brand & model?

We have a decent scanner, so we don't need an all in one printer.

Thank you for your suggestions in advance.

Joanne

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

#2

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>Laser. Less expensive to operate.

I actually have one of each. I can count on one hand the number of times I 'needed' an inkjet for the color copier capability. I have to use it oftener to keep it from drying out!

Last summer I got an HP 1020 that is working out great. I'm at grad school so I generate a lot of paper each week and am as poor as the proverbial church mouse. Still on the original cartridge. All in all, a good value.

That said, it'll probably run dry this next week, as I am in the midst of final papers! :)

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

#3

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

John McGaw

>I'd suggest that you consider a decent-quality color laser. I've been using a Dell 3100CN for 1-1/2 years now and find it far superior to inkjets for "printing" work as opposed to "photo" work. I have the printer on my network along with an HP Laserjet 5P which has been cranking along for at least 10 years now (and only on the second cartridge!). There are a lot of newer color lasers available at reasonable cost and the costs only look better when you look at the cost-per-page.

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

#4

You're gonna hate me

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>But a printer or computer is no different than a tablesaw or bandsaw, or a truck or car, for that matter.

It's hard to recommend a saw to someone who "wants a saw". To make a good recommendation we need to know what sort of woodworking you will be doing and your budget.

Same for computers and printers.

What's your volume, budget, speed requirements, and need for color?

I highly recommend most HP printers. I also recommend the B&W LaserJets unless you need color. They sell hundreds of models, and even for personal use or small home office there are a dozen or more.

The LJ1018 is very good for $99. I also have two LS1320 myslef, but at $400/each they might be out of your price range.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

#5

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

Bob Fawcett

>If you use your printer to print photos, you will want to stick with an inkjet type.

I have a canon that does a great job on photos.

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

#6

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

Binen

>Don't worry too much about which printer you buy. They are all pretty good. Just be sure to buy one able to do what you want. The thing you need to look at is ink cartridge. Find out how many copies you get and the cost per copy. This more than anything will determine you final satisfaction.

Binen

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

#7

It depends

Curly Smith

>Ditto what Mark said above but I'll add a few comments:

- If you use the printer every day (or every other day) then an inkjet printer can be a good choice. Inkjets are horrible choices for infrequent use as the ink will dry out and you'll discard a partially used, and expensive, cartridge. In addition, infrequent use leads to clogged jets, meaning you'll fight the printer every time you use it. FYI, your old printer was much more forgiving than the new printers.

- If you buy an inkjet printer try to buy one that can use "after market" cartridges. Look at the printer supply aisle in your local office supply store and verify that the generics (or refills) will fit your printer. You don't want to get locked into a sole supplier that might decide to discontinue making the cartridge or that charges a premium price.

- Laser printers are much cheaper to operate "per printed page" than inkjet printers but they cost more to buy. Laser printers also print faster and are quieter (generally speaking).

- Inkjet printers are cheap since the money is in the refill cartridges. However, you can get a color laser printer for free if you buy the refills from the manufacturer. It's the same business model as the inkjets but I don't know how cost effective it really is. If interested, visit the Xerox website and look for the Phaser printers.

- Want an inexpensive printer? Check the police auction websites. Also check the computer clearinghouses for discontinued models BUT verify that you can get supplies before you buy one.

- Printers don't come with a printer cable and new printers generally connect via a USB port or a network connection. Make sure your PC has a USB port, a network card, or that you have the necessary adapters. It's all more money that you didn't want to spend.

- Color is expensive, stick to B&W unless you really need color.

Personally, I use a B&W laser printer and take my digital photos, and other color printing needs, to a print shop. It's the most cost effective for me, YMMV.

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

#8

Cartridges

Curt Harms

>Hi Joanne

As was mentioned, pay attention to cartridge cost & availability. You might check a web site like www.pcworld or www.pcmag or the like and look at their printer reviews. The killer with inkjets is cartridge cost. Cheaper printers seem to have higher per page ink cost. I've refilled Lexmark cartridges with pretty good success. Some manufacturers have circuitry that disables cartridges once they're empty or after a certain time period, I think. You might call one of the refill vendors to find out which printers have this "feature" and stay away from them.

Personally I have a networked laser MFD that I use 95% of the time. Yes, inkjet cartridges will dry out if not used. The cartridges that have the nozzles built in can be soaked and cleaned with a paper towel so they'll work again if they dry out. If the nozzle is separate from the cartridge and the nozzle dries out and plugs, it can be a real problem as there's no way to reach them except the clean cycle integral to the printer.

HTH

Curt

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

#9

Re: OT- Printer recommendations

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I totally agree with Mark. The type of printing you do will dictate the economy and quality you need. I personally have used many lasers, HP, and Epson Ink Jets and others when I worked as an Engineer. I currently gave my Laser (black & white) to my youngest son as he needed a printer. I use an Epson Photo R200. I have purchased Epsons for several years as off brand cartridges are available - usually around $3 - less in quantity. I purchased Six sets of 6 cartridges for my current printer on Ebay for something like $70 including shipping. The only issue is that I must print something - usually 1 photo (using all 6 colors) about every week or the jets will become clogged. I use one set of cartridges about every 6 months or so - extra black about every 4 months. I can buy black cartridges separately on Ebay and may need to in a year or so. I had one printer clog beyond repair when I failed to print for a couple months. Otherwise I just purchase a new one every three or four years at a cost of $50 to $100 - about the price of a set of replacement cartridges for a HP. Usually the printers have improved enough in 3 years or so it's worth buying a new one. HP makes a great printer BUT generic cartridges are not available. As 1 or 2 sets of their replacement cartridges cost as much or more than my Epson with a couple years supply of cartridges - I stay away from them. Lasers are great if you only want B&W - they are quite expensive for color and extremely expensive for Photo quality. The toner cartridges actually cost more per sheet than I pay for generic ink jet. Before you purchase a printer be sure to check the availability and cost of replacement cartridges.