Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Wood movement and joinery question

Posts

Wood movement and joinery question

#1

Wood movement and joinery question

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I was looking at a plan for a simple Nantucket bench that I like (out of Woodsmith). The two sides have dual through mortises cut, to accept a lower stretcher that is glue in place. The stretcher will lay flat with twin tenons on each side. So, if you look at the bench from the end, you'll see to through mortises side to side (not up and down).

My question is, should I be concerned at wood movement of the center stretcher possible damaging the sides of the bench. To me, it doesn't look like the center piece will have any room to expand/contract. The center rail is about 8" wide.

I tried to think of other ways to join the pieces to account for wood movement, but I can't think of anything. Am I being overly cautious?

Re: Wood movement and joinery question

#2

Re: Wood movement and joinery question

Jesse in New Mexico

>Unless I am not visualizing your bench correctly (highly likely ;^) ), it seems the grain on the sides and the grain in the central stretcher are running in the same direction and should move together. If the stretcher were not on its side, there would be a problem.

If you want to be extra careful, 8 inches should be plenty of room for three tenons. Make the middle one through and glue it. Stop the other two short of the edge of the side and make the mortises a little wide and don't glue.

Re: Wood movement and joinery question

#3

Here's a pic *LINK*

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Here's a link to the picture of the bench from Woodsmith's site.


Woodsmith Nantucket Bench

Re: Wood movement and joinery question

#4

Re: Wood movement and joinery question

Tom Stockton

>No worries on wood movement everything is moving in the same direction.

Tom

Re: Wood movement and joinery question

#5

The only thing

Keith Newton

>that i would worry about when using this type joint would be if they cut away too much of the wood that it weakened the leg too much, making it susceptible to breaking there.

It looks like this one should be OK though.

Re: Wood movement and joinery question

#6

Re: Wood movement and joinery question

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>You know, I guess my 3 dimensional spatial reasoning wasn't working too well. As I look at it again you are quite right that everything is moving in the same direction.

The top they recommend just screwing on, but I'd certainly do that with a slightly oversized hole and washer recessed into the top rail. Even though it is in the same direction, why take too many chances.

Thanks!

Re: Wood movement and joinery question

#7

Ellis Walentine

Don't bother with the screws

Ellis Walentine

>Wouldn't you feel better if there were no hardware in this piece. All the wood goes in the same direction so you are extremely unlikely to run into expansion problems of any kind unless the individual pieces are at very different moisture content percentages when you make the joints. Rest assured that the only hardware a colonial cabinetmaker would have used to attach that top would have possibly been a couple nails, which can bend to accommodate a bit of difference in MC. A self-respecting one would have made multiple tenons on the tops of the leg boards and mortised them through the top and held them for eternity with wedges.

It's pretty amazing how wood movement works. Most species are resilient enough to absorb a modicum of movement without worry.

Ellis

Re: Wood movement and joinery question

#8

I like a challenge ...

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Keeps me honest and learning. It's amazing that even in a little project like this there are a wealth of things to learn. Up till now I wouldn't have noticed that all the grain runs in the same direction, or that there are other ways to attach the top, wedged tenons might be better, etc.

And all this because my wife thought it'd be nice to have a smaller coffee table, and this bench would do nicely (bench, table, it's all in the usage).

Hmm, now I can picture tenons on top of the legs with wedged through mortises. I'm glad I have Cosman's video on that.