Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

Posts

If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#1

If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

Keith Newton

>There is a bill in the House Ways and Means committee that could help ease the burden of not getting to claim the market value of your work. It needs your help to move it along.

The bill is H. R. 1524. If Artist could deduct fair market value of their work when making a donation, it seems to me that we / they could donate more and better work to charity, without taking such a hit financially.

I have provided a link right to the page where you just type in your name, and a note saying that you want their support of this bill.

I only give 2 - 4 pieces each year, but have request for about 10 others. I could not donate to them all, but I could do more if I could afford the loss, but as it is, the burden is too great for most of us trying to make a living in a very hard market area.


http://waysandmeans.house.gov/contact.asp

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#2

Done. My letter below...

Joe Pack

>Sent to the House Ways and Means Committee...

I am writing to ask your support of H. R. 1524, a bill that would allow artists and craftsmen to deduct the true market value of their work donated to charities.

I am often asked to donate items to charities. The value of my work is in the labor and creativity, not the material cost. A turned bowl that would normally sell for $100 may actually contain only a couple of dollars worth of wood, meaning I can deduct only a couple of dollars for my donation. While not claiming to be in their class as an artist, this is akin to allowing Norman Rockwell or Pablo Picasso to deduct only the cost of their canvas and paint for the donation of a painting that would sell for thousands at market prices.

Please support H. R. 1524 and allow artisans to receive true market value for their donations to charity.

Respectfully,

Larry J. Pack

Send yours, too.

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#3

Great Idea- Let's get at least 20 of us on this...

Dave Winters

>Done.

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#4

Done.

Paul Dwight

>

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#5

Done

Jay Kilpatrick in TX

>

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#6

It's not tax deductible.... this will raise debate

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>There are some people who say that if you build something and give it away, then your deduction is $0. Nothing, zip, nada, big fat zero.

This frustrates the heck out of me. I've donated thousands and thousands of dollars worth of things I've built and have not been able to claim any of it as a tax deduction. My CPA won't allow me. It frustrates me beacuse I know other CPA's who do allow it and other people who do claim this as tax deductions.

I have not been able to find any details on this new proposed bill. The link you provided just gives yuo the ability to send a comment about it. I will need to look more into thsi bill perhaps this bill realtes exactly to what I'm going to post here:

I'm not a IRS agent, nor a CPA, but have been involved in this quite a bit and non-cash donations that you make/build are not a tax deduction from what I've been told.

Here's the reasoning:

(I won't cloud the issue with Sales Tax, this is simply income tax or taxable earnings issue).

If JOE spends $100 on wood, makes a chair, sells it for $500, then JOE'S income is $500, and his costs are $100, so his profit is $400. At the end of the year, JOE must pay the IRS income tax based on that $400. So far, fairly easy to understand.

Let's say JOE get's wood for free, makes the chair, sells it for $500, then his income is $500, his costs are $0, so his profit is $500. JOE must pay the IRS income tax based on that $500. Perhaps not realistic, but fairly easy to understand.

If MICHAEL goes and buys a chair for $500 out of his pocket and gives it to charity, then MICAHEL gets a $500 charitable donation tax deduction, which effectively reduces his earned (and taxable) income by $500. Still fairly easy to understand.

Here's the part that people will want to discuss/debate:

If JOE builds that chair with his free wood, and gives it to charity, he is NOT permitted to claim a $500 charitable donation tax deduction. And here is the reasoning:

If JOE builds that chair and sold it, he would have a $500 profit which is taxable. Then if JOE then gives a check to the charity, he would have a $500 charitble deduction. He'd have income of $500 and a deduction of $500, net is $0. He would not owe any income tax. So far so good, right?

Or if JOE builds the chair, then sells it to the charity for $500 and they pay him $500 for it. He has $500 income that the charity gave him. If he then turns around and gives them a $500 donation check, that is a tax deduction. So he has $500 income, and a $500 deduction, net is $0.

Until someone pays him $500 for that chair, it has no value in the eyes of the IRS. If JOE gives it to charity, he can't claim a $500 deduction. If he get's paid $500 for it, then his profit is $500, and he can claim a $500 deduction. Net effect is $0.

JOE can only claim it as a deduction if he sold it first.

This thought is completely opposite to the whole PRO BONO idea that lawyers and doctors use. There are CPA's who state that PRO BONO work can never be (legally) claimed as a charitble donation and tax deduction. Neither can our work or objects we donate.

So go ahead, let the debate start. I'm not a CPA and don't know if this is right, but everyone is welcome to repond with your thoughts, as well as actually facts if you are a CPS, etc and an authority on this.

Is this common knowledge? Is this what this new bill is trying to correct? Do people just assum/know that if they make and give something it's a tax deduction. Or do people assume'know that it's not a tax deduction.

I really would like to know more about this. Partly be

Happy Woodworking!

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#7

Ironic, isn't it?

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>On the flip side, say you go to a charity dinner and pay $100, but eat $40 worth of food--you can only claim $60 as your charitable donation. In essence the IRS requires the reduction of your donation by the market value amount of the food consumed.

It sounds like the best way around the market value issue is if you had a "donation partner" that could match the value of what you give. He/she buys what you make, then donates it, and you donate the proceeds as well.

Jason

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#8

Re: It's not tax deductible.... this will raise de

Dave Winters

>So if Michael buys the chair from Joe and donates it to the charity, everyone wins?

Is this totally legal? We often have silent auctions to which I donate and then set out business cards, and I get my name on a thank you sheet of donators. Would I still be legal to do that?

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#9

No, I don't think so

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"So if Michael buys the chair from Joe and donates it to the charity, everyone wins?"

Not at all (again from what I've heard and my possibly flawed understanding).

MICHAEL buys the chair and is $500 out of pocket.

MICHAEL donates it to charity and gets a $500 donation receipt that reduces his income from $100,000 to $99,500

JOE earns an additional $500 and pays income tax on that amount.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#10

Here is more information

Keith Newton

>This is a letter from Rep. Vick Snyder to one of the artist who is in a gallery that shows my work. Maybe you can find more information by contacting Vick, or John Lewis.

The state or AR, allows the artist to deduct the cost of materials. Yippee.

Dear Nancy:

Thank you for contacting me about allowing artists to take fair

market value tax deductions on their charitable donations.

H.R.1524, the Artist-Museum Partnership Act of 2007, was

introduced by Representative John Lewis on March 14, 2007. This

bill would have allowed a deduction equal to fair market value for

charitable contributions of literary, musical, artistic, or scholarly

compositions created by the donor. I am cosponsor of H.R.1524,

which has been referred to the Ways and Means House Committee.

Thank you again for contacting me. Please keep me informed of

issues that are important to you.

Sincerely,

Vic Snyder

Member of Congress

If you would like to sign up for my weekly e-newsletter, visit

http://snyder.aristotle.net/newsletter.asp

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#11

Re: It's not tax deductible.... this will raise de

cameron y

>This is interesting. Wouldn't this be the same thing as donating any other propertiy, say a car? As I understand it, if you donate property you used to be able to deduct the market value. Now I think that you can only deduct the ammount the charety sells the item for... If you had a piece of furniture that was donated and then sold you should be able to deduct that value as you lost personal property in the donation...

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#12

Completely different tax issue (I think)

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>This is interesting. Wouldn't this be the same thing as donating any other propertiy, say a car?

With a car you likely BOUGHT and paid for it at some point.

You bought your car with cash, and then gave it away, so at some point you did spend money.

It's totally different if you create something. You can deduct up to the amount that it cost you to build, but not the value. In my example, with free wood, there was no cash cost, so no deduction.

Hey, I agree with you one this. I think it's silly.

Lawyers and doctors continue to deduct "loss of revenue" when they spend a day doing PRO BONO work, but according to my CPA it's wrong and illegal.

I went into business for myself, and discovered two things:

I work alot harder, escpecially for the charity and free work that I do, and get nothing back from it (monutarily that is).

I pay a whole lot more taxes now being self employeed that when I was working for a corporation. I thought it would be the otehr way around.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#13

Re: so... whats wrong with...

Grant Smith(remove 1 for email)

>Joe making a chair and then telling the church that he will "Donate the proceeds from the auction of the chair" to the same church? Then they hold an auction and Michael is the highest bidder at $500. Joe collects his $500 from Michael and turns around and donates it to the church.

Sounds like the way around the law. Joe gets his deduction and Michael gets his chair, the church gets their donation and the IRS gets what they deserved...(I think)

Am I wrong here?

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#14

Re: It's not tax deductible.... this will raise de

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>Net zero is what we have now, isn't it. We get to deduction our cost out of pocket. That isn't the goal. The goal is a deduction for the value of the product. "Value" is what it is worth over and above cost, for the purposes of this deduction.

Illustration: If lawyer A deducts $500 for 2 hours of pro bono work, then can woodworker A deduct $500 for 20 hours that went into a project that was donated to charity, when the 'value' of that project can be demonstrated to 'worth' $500?

Which of course, brings up the question, how does one demonstrate the 'value' of something? Given that Lawyer A gets to determine his/her own hourly rate, who gets to make the rules of determining 'value' for the purposes of this proposed legislation?

Sighhh.....

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#15

Re: so... whats wrong with...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Michael has made a purchase, not a donation...

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#16

Here is the actual bill

Keith Newton

>H.R. 1524: Artist-Museum Partnership Act

HR 1524 IH

110th CONGRESS

1st Session

H. R. 1524

To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide that a deduction equal to fair market value shall be allowed for charitable contributions of literary, musical, artistic, or scholarly compositions created by the donor.

IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

March 14, 2007

Mr. LEWIS of Georgia (for himself, Mr. RAMSTAD, and Mr. DOGGETT) introduced the following bill; which was referred to the Committee on Ways and Means

A BILL

To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide that a deduction equal to fair market value shall be allowed for charitable contributions of literary, musical, artistic, or scholarly compositions created by the donor.

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.

This Act may be cited as the `Artist-Museum Partnership Act'.

SEC. 2. CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTIONS OF CERTAIN ITEMS CREATED BY THE TAXPAYER.

(a) In General- Subsection (e) of section 170 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 (relating to certain contributions of ordinary income and capital gain property) is amended by adding at the end the following new paragraph:

`(8) SPECIAL RULE FOR CERTAIN CONTRIBUTIONS OF LITERARY, MUSICAL, OR ARTISTIC COMPOSITIONS-

`(A) IN GENERAL- In the case of a qualified artistic charitable contribution--

`(i) the amount of such contribution shall be the fair market value of the property contributed (determined at the time of such contribution), and

`(ii) no reduction in the amount of such contribution shall be made under paragraph (1).

`(B) QUALIFIED ARTISTIC CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTION- For purposes of this paragraph, the term `qualified artistic charitable contribution' means a charitable contribution of any literary, musical, artistic, or scholarly composition, or similar property, or the copyright thereon (or both), but only if--

`(i) such property was created by the personal efforts of the taxpayer making such contribution no less than 18 months prior to such contribution,

`(ii) the taxpayer--

`(I) has received a qualified appraisal of the fair market value of such property in accordance with the regulations under this section, and

`(II) attaches to the taxpayer's income tax return for the taxable year in which such contribution was made a copy of such appraisal,

`(iii) the donee is an organization described in subsection (b)(1)(A),

`(iv) the use of such property by the donee is related to the purpose or function constituting the basis for the donee's exemption under section 501 (or, in the case of a governmental unit, to any purpose or function described under subsection (c)),

`(v) the taxpayer receives from the donee a written statement representing that the donee's use of the property will be in accordance with the provisions of clause (iv), and

`(vi) the written appraisal referred to in clause (ii) includes evidence of the extent (if any) to which property created by the personal efforts of the taxpayer and of the same type as the donated property is or has been--

`(I) owned, maintained, and displayed by organizations described in subsection (b)(1)(A), and

`(II) sold to or exchanged by persons other than the taxpayer, donee, or any related person (as defined in section 465(b)(3)(C)).

`(C) MAXIMUM DOLLAR LIMITATION; NO CARRYOVER OF INCREASED DEDUCTION- The increase in the deduction under this section by reason of this paragraph for any taxable year--

`(i) shall not exceed the artistic adjusted gross income of the taxpayer for such taxable year, and

`(ii) shall not be taken into account in determining the amount which may be carried from such taxable year under subsection (d).

`(D) ARTISTIC ADJUSTED GROSS INCOME- For purposes of this paragraph, the term `artistic adjusted gross income' means that portion of the adjusted gross income of the taxpayer for the taxable year attributable to--

`(i) income from the sale or use of property created by the personal efforts of the taxpayer which is of the same type as the donated property, and

`(ii) income from teaching, lecturing, performing, or similar activity with respect to property described in clause (i).

`(E) PARAGRAPH NOT TO APPLY TO CERTAIN CONTRIBUTIONS- Subparagraph (A) shall not apply to any charitable contribution of any letter, memorandum, or similar property which was written, prepared, or produced by or for an individual while the individual is an officer or employee of any person (including any government agency or instrumentality) unless such letter, memorandum, or similar property is entirely personal.

`(F) COPYRIGHT TREATED AS SEPARATE PROPERTY FOR PARTIAL INTEREST RULE- In the case of a qualified artistic charitable contribution, the tangible literary, musical, artistic, or scholarly composition, or similar property and the copyright on such work shall be treated as separate properties for purposes of this paragraph and subsection (f)(3).'.

(b) Effective Date- The amendment made by this section shall apply to contributions made after the date of the enactment of this Act in taxable years ending after such date.

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#17

Look at it this way...

John in New Mexico

>and I know about as much as you, just fooling with logic...

An outfit I used to work for would donate a piece once or twice a year. Because it was a business with employees, the cost of the piece could be figured as materials + shop time. They had to pay the time for the guy who made it right? We billed shop time at $50/hour. So the business couldn't deduct the lost profit from donating, but they could deduct more than just the basic materials cost.

I suspect an individual could do the same thing, and their accountant would pass it, IF they had a regular figure for shop time that they charged their regular customers. If you don't have those, and just build a piece now and then and donate it to your favorite charity, you could probably just deduct the materials cost, maybe with some sort of tooling depreciation if you were that much of a masochist for about a 50 cent deduction.

That's my take on it.

John

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#18

Re: Completely different tax issue (I think)

John E. in SC

>I'm a physician, and personally, I've never heard of a doctor deducting volunteer or "pro bono" work as "lost revenue". My partners and I "give away" thousands of dollar worth of care every year, some voluntarily (we see certain patients we know can't pay for free or greatly reduced fees, and also volunteer at a local free clinic) and some involuntarily (through patients that don't pay) but we've never been able to benefit one dime on taxes by this.

Re: If you donate your work to Chariety, *LINK*

#19

Autograph your work!

Joe Pack

>Maybe, John, if you sign your name...or just scratch it in a bit somewhere where it won't be too visible, you can claim your donated work as "art." Heck, with the patient's permission, yo might even be able to advertise a little bit! :-)))