Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Shop heating

Posts

Shop heating

#1

Shop heating

Jack Hartley

>I have been in the process of building a new 24x42 shop in my barn. I have been doing some research on how to heat the area. I have contacted my insurance company and they have said no to any wood burning devices inside the building. I have looked into external wood burning boilers with radiant floor tubing installed. Has anyone used this type of heat for their shop? I am interested in any pluses or minuses and the type of system you may be using.

Is forced air a better option?

I do not natural gas. I looked into geothermal again with radiant heating but with a readly supply of wood I would like to use wood.

Re: Shop heating

#2

Re: Shop heating

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Here in east central PA, I heat and cool my two story 2400 sqft studio building with a heat pump-AC forced air unit, keeping it above 60 in the winter and below 76 in the summer. Operating cost for 2006 was $844.

Clint

Re: Shop heating

#3

Re: Shop heating

mdclor

>Jack,

I think if you search the archives you will discover that radiant heat is a real favorite. No cold tools and less likelihood of condensation IMO. Personally, I would never be without it again.

I don't know how the external wood furnace will do with radiant however. Hopefully, someone else will chime in here.

Good luck,

Merle

Re: Shop heating

#4

Re: Shop heating

Curly Smith

>I don't think a wood burning boiler is a viable solution for radiant heat. It has at least two fatal flaws:

a) no heat when you're not around to feed wood to the burner

b) expensive flow regulation to maintain constant heat generation when the burner is fired (your burner would not be generating constant BTUs)

You might be able to use wood in a supplemental boiler but the cost of the additional equipment might not be offset by the savings in other fuel. Based on your post I think you'll be stuck with either electric or propane for radiant heat but I don't see any reason why you couldn't put a wood burning stove outdoors and route the stack through your shop to give the radiant floor heating an assist.

Re: Shop heating

#5

Re: Shop heating

Paul Sadler III

>http://www.woodmaster.com/

http://www.heatmor.com/

Re: Shop heating

#6

Re: Shop heating

Andrew Nistock

>I had a new 30X60 shop built last year and am heating it with an outdoor wood boiler. I did not put in floor radiant heating but did build a heat exchanger and use forced air to heat the shop. I live in upstate New york where it did get to 20 below this winter and the shop stayed a toasty 65 degrees. We did use a fair amount of wood and it was a little bit of a pain to go out into the weather to feed the boiler but there was no smoke, soot, ashes or wood insects brought into the shop. Also no chimney expenses or worries about fires. JUst one point to remember, locate the wood burner far enough away from the buildings so there is no danger from a spark igniting a structure and also they will smoke on ocassion (just after filling) and with the short stacks on these units one can quickly get a lot of smoke circling around a shop. Good luck, Andy

Re: Shop heating

#7

Re: Shop heating

Jack Hartley

>Thanks everyone for you input. I will keep you posted on the progress.

Re: Shop heating

#8

Re: Shop heating

arw01

>With the price of gas these days, how much will it cost you to bring in enough wood for an outdoor boiler?

Tell us what your electricity costs are and what propane runs if ordered on a keep full basis.

To date I have not put the heat source in for my radiant floor, but I plan on natural gas unless I get a commercial water heater for free from one of the local HVAC suppliers.

Second call back your insurance company and ask about a PELLET STOVE. The girls in the office may give you a different answer.

Alan

Re: Shop heating

#9

Re: Shop heating

Alister

>I was going to use propane then went with coal.


img

Re: Shop heating

#10

Nice Stone Work...

Ron Bauman

>

Re: Shop heating

#11

Central Boiler installed last fall

Gary

>I installed a wood burner last fall, and cannot say enough good about it. We arrived at this decision from many diffenent thoughts.

A friend had one, and loved his.

Wood is always available for free. It may take a little work, but if you saw me, you would understand that I have a few spare calories which are available to be burned up! We thought about a corn burner, but decided against it as we would have been forced to pay for the corn.

Along with heating our home (which we moved into last spring...) and hot water, it would heat the shop. One stop heating for everything but the stove/oven.

I have only used mine for one winter, but cannot say enough good about it. I LOVE having it! If you do install one, I'd recommend making it large enough to heat the house as well!

e-mail me for more info if you want to.

Gary