Re: Work Sharp sharper - Long Comments
Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana
>My thinking - First my background, I will be 66 next month. I worked with good carpenters that had "sharp" tools in the 1940's & 50's. So much has been said about sharpening - kind of making it a mystic skill. In reality the people I worked with when I was young had a couple of stones. (sometimes they used a smooth concrete step if available). The stones most had were a Norton India stone - course on one side - fine on the other. Most had a Arkansas stone too, many were a mottled color (Black / grey & white. These guys were excellent woodworkers and could fit a dovetail like todays experts. They honed their chisels and plane blades on the Arkansas when they quit cutting easily. No examination under 10 power glass etc. If the tool chipped, they went to the India stone and worked out the nick. The angles were by eye, I'm sure they were not exactly what the tool was meant to have from the manufacturer (but they cut well). When I retired and built my new shop a couple of years ago, I bought good tools, (like the Lee Neilsen chisels), I really tried to emulate the new sharpening techniques and hone my tools to perfection - with about as much exasperation as you now have.
I tried about every method. I have several oil stones, have a full set of waterstones, a couple diamond and a ceramic stone. have glass plate swith glued on sandpaper, I also have a bench grinder with white stones and even an old Boyer Schultz surface grinder. I purchased a General sharpening guide - then the LV guide. I now sharpen till my tools suit me in use - the hexx with the books. Not disparaging the books, maybe I could sharpen better - but my chisels pare the wood without fraying or having to hammer them. My planes cut the board without tearing the surface etc. I do recommend the use of the LV sharpening guide for beginners - I still use mine occasionally. It does make keeping the bevels true and flat much easer, especially on small narrow chisels. However IMHO all tools benefit from hand honing after a short use - this is not difficult - if you kind of round over the edge a little - it will still work well. I guess what I am trying to say is don't take sharpening to extremes. If the tool works use it, when it quits, fix it by putting a new edge on it. Don't agonize over the skill - it will become easier and easier. I'm sure some will disagree, and have purchased the Jet, Tormak or other sharpening system and will swear by them - but I will continue to sharpen my way. Normally it doesn't take me 5 minutes to put a great edge on a chisel or plane blade. Unless I need to remove a nick I use my oilstones and ceramic. When I have to remove nicks or want to sharpen several tools I will use the faster waterstones. I don't keep them soaking so it is a hassel to set them up in trays. I do use an old razor strap occasionally to strop the edge,