Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

Posts

Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#1

Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

Bartee ( Metro Atlanta )

>I am frustrated with wet stone sharpening. I have so much to learn about everything, I just need sharp chisels without get totally frustrated.

I looked at LV sharpening machine, but it is now $350.

I looked at the Work Sharp, which is $199. There are 3 good reviews on Rockler.

There is also a good demo video on the Wood Magazine site. Link is below.

So does any one have any comments?


Wood mag review and video

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#2

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Long Comments

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>My thinking - First my background, I will be 66 next month. I worked with good carpenters that had "sharp" tools in the 1940's & 50's. So much has been said about sharpening - kind of making it a mystic skill. In reality the people I worked with when I was young had a couple of stones. (sometimes they used a smooth concrete step if available). The stones most had were a Norton India stone - course on one side - fine on the other. Most had a Arkansas stone too, many were a mottled color (Black / grey & white. These guys were excellent woodworkers and could fit a dovetail like todays experts. They honed their chisels and plane blades on the Arkansas when they quit cutting easily. No examination under 10 power glass etc. If the tool chipped, they went to the India stone and worked out the nick. The angles were by eye, I'm sure they were not exactly what the tool was meant to have from the manufacturer (but they cut well). When I retired and built my new shop a couple of years ago, I bought good tools, (like the Lee Neilsen chisels), I really tried to emulate the new sharpening techniques and hone my tools to perfection - with about as much exasperation as you now have.

I tried about every method. I have several oil stones, have a full set of waterstones, a couple diamond and a ceramic stone. have glass plate swith glued on sandpaper, I also have a bench grinder with white stones and even an old Boyer Schultz surface grinder. I purchased a General sharpening guide - then the LV guide. I now sharpen till my tools suit me in use - the hexx with the books. Not disparaging the books, maybe I could sharpen better - but my chisels pare the wood without fraying or having to hammer them. My planes cut the board without tearing the surface etc. I do recommend the use of the LV sharpening guide for beginners - I still use mine occasionally. It does make keeping the bevels true and flat much easer, especially on small narrow chisels. However IMHO all tools benefit from hand honing after a short use - this is not difficult - if you kind of round over the edge a little - it will still work well. I guess what I am trying to say is don't take sharpening to extremes. If the tool works use it, when it quits, fix it by putting a new edge on it. Don't agonize over the skill - it will become easier and easier. I'm sure some will disagree, and have purchased the Jet, Tormak or other sharpening system and will swear by them - but I will continue to sharpen my way. Normally it doesn't take me 5 minutes to put a great edge on a chisel or plane blade. Unless I need to remove a nick I use my oilstones and ceramic. When I have to remove nicks or want to sharpen several tools I will use the faster waterstones. I don't keep them soaking so it is a hassel to set them up in trays. I do use an old razor strap occasionally to strop the edge,

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#3

Great comments, thanks.

Bartee ( Metro Atlanta )

>

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#4

JL

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please

JL

>I went after the "Holy Grail" of sharpening myself.

I have an 8" dual speed grinder for my turning tools.

I have a reasonable set of waterstones that I use for my chisels and plane blades.

I have a Tormek that I use to do the initial grinding on my plane and planer blades, which I then finish up on my waterstones.

I have a set of oil stones that I inherited from my stepfather - they work fine.

I have some sandpaper that I occasionally use.

I have a buffing strop w/ compound.

What do I go to first? The 8" grinder for the turning tools and the waterstones. I can get a nick out easily with the coarse waterstone and get it to very sharp in a few minutes. If I had to do it over again, I'd probably not bought the Tormek.

Look at the classes at Highland Hardware. There are some which go into sharpening a bit.

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#5

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please

Tim Caley - North Little Rock

>We had a demonstration of the Work Sharp sharpener at a woodworker's meeting a couple of months ago. Essentially, it is a motorized version of Scary Sharp. Did a good job of sharpening some chisel and plane blades that we tested. Has a neat wheel with holes in it that allow you to see the edge as you are sharpening lathe tools from the underneath side of the wheel (which requires special sandpaper from them). If you want to do more that chisels and planes, I don't think that it would be very versatile.

Long and short of it I guess, the demo didn't convince me to part with the dollars.

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#6

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Bartee,

I generally concur with everybody's comments, and closely with Larry's. Lotsa ways to skin a cat. My standby is a motorized wet stone a la Grizzly and Accu-sharp jigs which sre augmented with arkansas stones and diamond hones depending on the tool. My wet stone is a little less expensive than other electrical widgets but the results are very good, and I do sharpen chisels and irons for my #3 son and his employees for professional use. No complaints after using a simple and inexpensive system, and they pay me in cases of beer. What could be better?

HOWEVER: If you like the tool, buy it. I don't see how you can go far wrong. Frankly, the basic tool is NOT too expensive, although I suspect the prices of the sandpaper and slotted discs may be high.

George

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#7

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please

mike from American Sycamore

>I have just recently recieved my new Work Sharp. I put it to work immediately and ran it through its paces. It works great for chisels! I love it! I would recomend Work Sharp for chisels, plane irons, and other straight blades. Runs quiet and the paper holds up very well. IMHO I would have no trouble telling you to buy one.

Hope to have more time to "play" some more.

Good luck. Build with Confidence

Mike

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#9

Slight hijack...

Martin from Granbury

>I dropped a chisel on a tile floor and have a nick. I have Shapton water stones, and don't have a Tormek or the like. I would like to know a source for the 3m sticky backed sandpaper, which comes is rolls. I need to get the nick out before I put it on my Shaptons. I have a flat surface, just don't know where to find the 3m sandpaper. Thanks!

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#10

Re: Slight hijack...

Jesse in New Mexico

>I use Kingspore rolls, available at

http://www.woodworkingshop.com/

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#11

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please

Jesse in New Mexico

>Hey Mike,

Glad you like the sharpener. Can you tell yet how long the sandpaper will last? A lot of us are skeptical about that. Please post your experience after using it for a while!

Thanks,

Jess

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#12

I might be missing something, but…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…is there anything wrong with plain old wet/dry sheets and 3M #77 sprayed on a flat surface?

And towards that end, I have a stone countertop manufacturer here in town who has a pile o' slabs free for the taking. Those of you looking for a Scary Sharp™ surface might check your locale, too.

The biggest pieces at my place are usually sink cutouts (which can be daunting to process unless you have a wet saw—even with my small wet saw they can be hard to handle). There are also smaller pieces—cutoffs from the rough raw material. It's all ground, so is as flat as I need.

Rod

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#13

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Long Comments

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>I guess I have to agree with you, Clifton. I'm 76, but, unlike you, I took up hand tools much more recently - about 10 yrs ago or so. However, I have always sharpened my knives, jack and kitchen. I do now have a Lee Valley system. I also have a sandpaper system. But I still have my stones, all 3 of them, and I can and do do an exc ellent job with them on plane irons, chisels, etc. I have an even older system in the house I use with the kitchen knives, several of which are over 100 years old,

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#14

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please

Garrett in Victoria BC

>Work Sharp sent me a unit to review, and I hope to complete my testing and post the results sometime next week.

Initial reactions: well made machine base that comes with tempered glass platens that are flat and can be used on both sides. Abrasives are top quality and can be cleaned with a gum rubber erasing block. The easily adjustable tool holder is unique, really well thought out, making it next to impossible to get other than an excellent result on chisels and plane irons up to 2" wide. (BTW, the sharpening action takes place on the under-side of the platen.) Probably the most convenient machine on the market to maintain perfect edges for chisels and irons.

Cheers, Garrett

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#15

Re: Before you buy any more tools

Bartee ( Metro Atlanta )

>Bruce,

Thanks, ordered today!!!

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#16

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please

Bartee ( Metro Atlanta )

>Garrett,

Please us all know when you have had a chance to review.

Do you do this as part of your job ? Will this be published in a mag article ?

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#17

Order online?

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I believe that Klingspor's Online store has 3M paper. You could order it there.

I also understand that Industrial Abrasives sells similar sandpaper. I use their velcro backed paper as well as their self adhesive variety. I have nothing but good things to say about their products.

See ya around,

My ugly mug


Dominic

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#18

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please

Garrett in Victoria BC

>Hi Bartee

I do this sort of thing for fun, almost always for tools I purchase and pay for myself. This is an exception, since WorkSharp saw some of the other reviews I've published on the Web, usually here at WoodCentral, and asked if I would be interested in looking at their machine. I said "Sure" and they sent me one.

I won't publishing it in a magazine - although I have an article in this month's Popular Woodworking (shameless promo).

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#19

No, Rod, I'm just too lazy....

Martin from Granbury

>I used the stick on sandpaper at a class last summer, and forgot to ask where to buy it. I am sure your method works fine, but I really liked the ease of the stick on paper. Of course, if your method is significantly cheaper, I should look into it. Thanks for the tip.

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#20

Thanks Jesse and Dominic!

Martin from Granbury

>

Re: Work Sharp sharper - Comments please *LINK*

#21

Re: It's not so much the cheaper part...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>It's the where the overspray ends up. Cleaning up hands. Peeling the old stuff off, when it clogs. Gets a bit messy. But I still have half a can of 3M 77. And lots of abrasive papers.

But that only matters if you actually use that method to do your sharpening. Some of us have lots of ways to sharpen.

Which means, I guess, that we can't always make up our minds.