Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Finishing panel: What happened?

Posts

Finishing panel: What happened?

#1

Finishing panel: What happened?

Dave in Dacula

>This is a maple panel I was finishing for my latest project. As you can see a blotch appeard on both panels, any ideas as to why? Here is the scenario. I sanded both panels to 220 grit; wiped and tack clothed them clean; applied one coat of a Zinsser amber 1 lb cut shellac; next day applied a second coat of the same shellac; 2 days later applied one coat of Bartley Country Maple gel stain, waited a couple of minutes and wiped off the excess; waited a couple of days lightly sanded with 320 grit; wiped with a cloth, then a tack cloth to remove saw dust. At this point everything was perfect no problems at all. I then opened a can of Waterlox tung oil, I started on the left side of the panel (no problems) as soon as I got to the right side these blotches appeared. The panel on the right is not as bad but the same thing happened. This same problem happened about 5 years ago when I used Bartley gel stain (on white oak) followed by Bartley gel varnish; blotches appeared. I have finished many many projects and I have had this only happen twice both times using Bartley gel stain. After I apply the gel stain, all is fine it is only when I applied the oil or varnish that the blotches appear and it looks as if the oil removes the gel stain and leaves only the bare maple. I am very careful when I finish projects I wear new gloves and clean off all residue.

Thanks for reading,

Dave C.


img

Re: Finishing panel: What happened?

#2

Re: Finishing panel: What happened?

ScottM

>Glue

Re: Finishing panel: What happened?

#3

Re: Finishing panel: What happened?

Charles Sharp

>Looks like glue to me also.

Re: Finishing panel: What happened?

#4

Re: Finishing panel: What happened?

Paul Dwight

>If these were glue spots you should have seen them when you shellaced or stained the panels. Something else must be at work.

You say you started with Zinsser shellac. Was this the "Bulls Eye" stuff, or the SealCoat? Zinsser Bulls Eye shellac, which is what you most often find on the shelves at big box stores, contains wax. The harder-to-find SealCoat is dewaxed. This is an important difference when the shellac will be coated with other products.

I'd guess that you used shellac with wax in it. The wax prevented the gel stain from adhering to the shellac. When you brushed or wiped the top coat, some of the stain lifted off the shellac, giving you the light spots shown in your photos.

If this sounds plausible, I would offer two suggestions: (1) Keep only dewaxed shellac in the shop. Zinsser SealCoat is a little harder to find but it is a much better product for woodworkers. (2) After the gel stain has dried, I would apply a seal coat of dewaxed shellac. A gel stain applied over one or two coats of shellac will act more like a glaze than a stain -- it will sit on top of the wood instead of penetrating into the wood. Sealing the stain/glaze with a coat of shellac will ensure it doesn't lift off when you apply the topcoat.

Hope this helps. -- Paul

Re: Finishing panel: What happened?

#5

Also...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>I wouldn't sand gel stain. Get at LEAST a coat of shellac and a finish coat over that before doing any sanding, and only very light sanding at that (drywall sanding sponges work quite well here). There's no point in putting on a coat of finish and then sanding it right back off. I also wouldn't do any sanding after any shellac coats, as it is so thin that it would be easy to break through it and disrupt whatever is under it.

Jason