Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Japan Drier: How Toxic?

Posts

Japan Drier: How Toxic?

#1

Japan Drier: How Toxic?

Dave Winters

>I use Mineral Oil on my cutting boards, but it takes a long time to dry- maybe it never really "dries", but it keeps leaching out. I rub it all off, and then the next day there are spots of it showing on the suface. So I'm thinking if I add a dash of Japan Drier to the oil, that'll help. Not sure what this stuff really is, and if it's at all toxic when dry...

Thanks in advance-

Dave

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

#2

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

Tom Stockton

>I think it can be fairly toxic so I wouldn't use it. I think a better approach would be to change techniques. What I do is to wipe on a fairly generous coat and let it sit for 5 minutes and then wipe the cutting board down with a fresh cloth. I let them sit overnight and give them a quick rub down with a cloth and they are good to go.

Tom

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

#3

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Mineral Oil never dries. I'm not sure how japan drier would affect it. Mahoney's walnut oil will dry and is non toxic. but it is more yellow than mineral oil. It's available from most of places that carry woodturning supplies. Another option is to mix bee's wax into mineral oil heated in a double boiler. It will not bleed as much as plain mineral oil.

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

#4

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

Dave Winters

>Yeah, leaving it on the piece too long is my problem. I make these with alternating strips of walnut and maple, and I have found that leaving the Mineral Oil on overnite really turns the walnut a nice, very dark chocolate brown, which is the look I want to contrast with the hard maple. Nothing I have tried gives me the darkness that the Mineral Oil does. So you see my problem.

What is Japan Drier, anyway?

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

#5

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?  *LINK*

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>


http://www.utrechtart.com/msds/docs/JD.pdf

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Useless.....

Jesper, Denmark

>Japan drier is a metal catalyst dissolved in a petroleum solvent.

It can only accelerate reactions that already can take place, so as mineral oil is not a drying (reacting or polymerizing) oil to start with, adding Japan drier will not help you.

The solvents may be in the MSDS sheet, but they are not as bad as the metals left behind as the drier evaporates.

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

#7

Re: Useless..... *LINK*

Dave Winters

>Wow- You guys are the best, as usual. Thanks a million.

Here's a link to my website, where you'll see my boards.

-Dave


http://www.davidwinterswoodworker.com

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

#8

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

Jim Dillon

>Dave,

I agree with Jesper on this one. The MSDS lists a cobalt ingredient but I think the data sheet per se is only talking about the toxicity of naphtha which is fairly harmless as long as you don't drink it 8-) or inhale it in unreasonable quantities. For sure, I would NOT use Japan Dryer on cutting boards because of the cobalt catalyst. Maybe many thinner coats of mineral oil will dry OK and still give you the color you want. This topic comes up from time-to-time, so a search might turn up something. Good luck.

Jim

Re: Japan Drier: How Toxic?

#9

Time to clear things up

Michael Dresdner

>First, Jasper is exactly right. Driers speed up some (not all) drying oils, but have no effect whatever on non-drying oils such as mineral oil.

There are many different driers and they work differently. Some are top or skin driers, some are through driers. Some oils are very much affected by them, some are not, and some respond only to certain ones, or only in a limited way.

The MSDS cited in the posted link is cobalt drier, which is one of the through driers. Other common driers besides cobalt include zinc, lead, manganese, magnesium, and selenium, though there are others. As a group they are metal salts or metal naphthanates.

If you add driers to a drying oil like linseed oil, they speed up the oxygen polymerization. Because they are true catalysts, they do not become part of the final molecule. However, in the course of going from liquid to solid, the finish forms a matrix in which is trapped the metal salts. In other words, once the finish cures, it is quite unlikely that the metals will migrate out unless affected by a chelating compound.

The bottom line is that while consuming large amounts of these metals is harmful, the odds of doing that from a cured finish is slim indeed.

You have probably already noticed that we humans do regularly consume small amounts of many of these metals, and some, like zinc and selenium, are crucial to good health. It is all about amount.

One word of warning: adding too much drier can have the opposite effect, preventing the finish from curing. What is too much? That depends on which drier you are using, what you are adding it to, and how much of what type of drier is already in the mix. Some driers have a synergistic effect on one another, meaning much smaller amounts in combination can have far more significant results. For this reason I alway caution people about adding driers to finish in a cavalier manner.