Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

Posts

Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

#1

Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>My 12V DeWalt drill needs replacing. One battery is just about toast, other not a whole lot better and drill brushes are doing a lot of arcing. I have read reviews here about how much better the impact drivers are, but not sure what to get. I don't want to buy 2 tools and none of the "Impact drivers" appear to be equipped with standard chucks. However I have found Porter Cable and other "cordless Hammerdrill driver kits" that do have a standard chuck and are equipped with the adjustable clutch. Are these the same as the "Impact driver" and/or will they serve the same purpose? The 12V Dewalt suited my needs fine for all general use. Did have some problems with driving screws - caming out, broke a few etc. Thought the impact may alleviate the problems with screws and still do the general drilling. I have several tailed drills with high torque so that isn't a real issue. I just like the cordless for general use.

Re: Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

#2

Re: Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I've had the Milwaukee impact driver for about four years, and it's my mainstay for everything. The Dewalt is relegated to backup and when using different bits for the same task.

Clint

Re: Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

#3

Re: Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>I have the Makita drill/driver and the Makita impact. Use the same batteries and charger, so that is a plus. Solid tools. Solid brand. And 12V. Light enough for me not to tire using them and strong enough to drive 3-1/2" deck screws. Those higher powered cordless tools require both of my hands to handle!

My thoughts on the chucks. A regular drill chuck has three points of contact on the shank, sometimes round, of a bit. In an impact mode, I would think that would seriously slip. The hex chuck of the impact driver helps to overcome that. And you can purchase a drill chuck with a hex shank to use in the impact driver. Pricey little sucker. I got one, and maybe used it once. Maybe. Wouldn't spend that money again.

BTW, love the impact driver. Greatest thing for driving screws I've had in my hands. Beats the drill/driver up one side and down the other for driving screws, but not for drilling holes! Although I used it once with a largish spade bit through a 2x8 for running Romex. Wicked! :)

I know you said you didn't want two different tools, but if one new tool is a good thing, then two are twice as good! Go for it. You deserve it.

Re: Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

#4

Re: Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

Glenn Madsen on the road from SF Bay area

>I have two DeWalt 12v cordless drills, 3/8" and 1/2", and love them each for what they're good at. I bought a Bosch 12v impact driver two or three summers ago, and think that's one of the better ones out there. For driving screws, particularly long and/or large ones, it's the tool of choice.

My neighbor the tool guy has a DeWalt version of the impact driver that he really likes too. Don't know the voltage. I bought my Bosch first, or I might have purchased one of those, for the battery compatibility.

Impact drivers are NOT hammer drills. Different tool, different scope of work.

Impact drivers are also not made for drilling. They are specifically clutched for driving fasteners. Go see your local construction/contractor supplier for advice, and pay his price. Or check online.

Re: Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

#5

Re: Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question *LINK*

Gary S

>Makita has had a free drill with impact driver deal going for quite awhile. A quick search shows it at Tyler tools for $189.95, and I'm sure other outlets have it as well.

I can't speak for the other brands, but the Makita impacts I have are great tools. Drive a few 3" screws into something and you'll immediately see the difference between an impact and a drill.

As mentioned above, an impact is not a hammer drill.

Gary


img

Impact/Drill offer link

Re: Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

#6

Re: Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

Barry Irby

>Several have mentioned it, but they are different tools. Hammer drills hammer in a linear direction, sort of like striking the drill bit with a hammer Ideal for drill through materials such as concrete. Impact drivers twist the bit in a rotary motion, ideal for driving screws. But, Impact drivers can be too powerful and snap off screws or drive them too deep. They do not include the clutch feature (yet).

I have a corded hammer drill and regular drill. I have the Makita setup with 12 volt batteries for both the impact driver and regular drill. Mine are Makita and They would be among the last tools I let go of. One feature or benefit to an impact driver is that they put way less strain on your wrist. The tools are small and light and somehow impact the screw far more than they do your wrist and shoulder. Much less than a regular driver drill. Very beneficial if you are using it all day to drive heavy screws. I would get a 12 volt or perhaps a 14.4 volt kit. There would be very little benefit to a larger set up and in fact the extra weight might be a detriment. Also, if you are drilling in hard materials like concrete, I doubt the impact driver would be any more effective than a regular drill.

Re: Help! Cordless Drill Driver / Hammer question

#7

Re:Thanks! I should have realized

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>that the Hammer mode is "in out travel" instead of rotary impact. I have used Hammer drills in the past. Don't own or need one. Appreciate the various posts with great information. Guess I will replace my drill with a new Drill driver (non- impact) and later buy an impact as they seem to be different animals altogether. I really don't mind buying two tools - SHMBO might!