Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

Posts

Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#1

Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

wilbur

>I spent some time tinkering with my jointer/planer combo machine trying to tweak the table and blade alignment last night, and although it was a good learning experience, I would be happy if I didn't have to do this again for a while.

Which leads me to the issue of magazine reviews for machinery. The typical machinery review will measure how well the machine is set up out of the box. This is probably not real important in the long run, as you can always tweak the set up yourself.

I think that the more important thing is how well the machine stays set up one you start using it. Unfortunately, there seems to be very few long term reviews of machinery, to see how well they stay in alignment.

It would be hard to do such reviews, due to the time involved, but I think that magazines may be doing a disservice by emphasizing the initial set up in their reviews.

Comments?

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#2

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thi

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Interesting thought. Your comments reminded me of Consumer Reports. Often with products, especially cars, they track longer term reliability issues. I know that's not exactly what you are asking about but I would think that would be useful information. Lot's of tools work fine out of the box (or initial setup) but how do they hold up over time? Reliabilty? Parts? Repair history?

That might be a worthy study for a magazine or journal to look into and report on.

Tom

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#3

Half the problem with machinery reviews

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>is that for the most part they are done by writers, not machine builders. The good news is that some writers are decent machine people and the bad news is that I don't know of many machine builders who can write. So don't expect change any time soon. The other half is that they mostly don't get to keep the machine long enough, or use it hard enough, to test the long term stability.

While long term stability and easy of adjustment are more important than out of the box accuracy, that is not the expectation of most machine buyers. They want it perfect when they plug it in.

Ray

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#4

Re: I agree

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>Taking one example of a particular machine and rating how well i's set up out of box has always seemed silly to me. May as well rate how difficult removing the anti-corrosion coating is.

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#5

That's already done!

HC Sakman

>I recall reading (in a tool review) how difficult to remove the anti-rust coating, more than once.

I agree that usage can reveal hidden problems, design flaws or inappropriate materials such as kind of weak alloy that is used where the adjustments are and it wears our prematurely; or a piece of plastic that gets brittle and cracks before it should. There may be many flaws that can only be exposed by usage and time.

Chico...

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#6

Use the power of the internet

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>and the members of this forum. who better than the people that use it long term to tell us about it.

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#7

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thi

Jesse in New Mexico

>Interesting thread, thanks for starting it.

I think the info about how hard the tool is to set up is useful, for planning purposes, but I wouldn't make a buying decision based on it.

One problem is that each year manufacturers tweak most of the machines, usually for the worse. What used to be cast iron is now aluminum, what used to be aluminum is now plastic. So knowing how well a 5 year old machine is holding up may not be much of a guide to what's in the BORG today.

I hardly ever totally agree with the machine reviews. Usually thats because they have some review criteria that don't really matter to me. As long as they explain what they did, I find the info worth reading.

But forums like this one are where you get the real skinny!!

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#8

the perfect review won't work

John Lucas

>I definitely agree that reviews often have a problem even though they try really hard. The best review would be one on how a machine performs over the years. However once you read that review the machine would have been discontinued for a new model so you wouldn't be able to buy it.

I was thinking that we should all do reviews of the equipment that we own and post it on WC somewhere but that's what got me thinking machines being discontinued.

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#9

PUBLISH MY REVIEW OF POWERMATIC 200

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Aftefrnoon Wilbur,

I will publish my long term test and evaluation of the new Powermatic 200 cabinet saw after Handyman's Club of America sends it to me for testing. Promise!

George

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#10

Re: Use the power of the internet

mdclor

>Agreed!!!

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#11

Re: LONG - Doubt if you will ever see this

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I am a retired Manufacturing / Quality Engineer. I was often involved in the test programs for many of the products we manufactured. To provide a reasonable accurate life test of a machine requires a lot, both in money and resources.

First reasonable testing parameters have to be developed - For instance, in the case of a planer you would have to determine the reasonable life of the equipment in normal shop usage. Say we decide it is 10 years.

Then you have to develop "average use parameters". This may be 20,000 linear foot of material - and determine what materials - Oak, Pine, Cherry, Walnut, exotic woods etc. of various widths - 2", 4" etc up to full width of the planer. Maximum and minimum cuts, board lengths also have to be a factor. You also have to have a means of varying the environment the planer is used in - temperature extremes, humidity, possible sunlight , maximum / minimum voltage fed to the planer. After the program is developed, you have to execute this in an accelerated manner, so the information is useful before the planer design changes or the machine is obsolete. Sooo - you set up about a dozen of each machine to be tested and feed the material thorough as fast as you possibly can without overheating the machine (overheating violates normal useage rules) while keeping records of accuracy, any machine adjustments required, failure of any components, problems noted in operating and performance IE quality of the planed surface finish, snipe parallelism of the product, noise, rattles, parts vibrating loose etc. When you are through, after 90 to 180 days of 16 / 24 hours / day, testing, you will have somewhat pertinent information. You will also have 12 worn out planers of each type tested, many thousand of BF of very thin wood, and a $20 to $50M bill for payroll of the operators.

The company I worked for made automotive switches and appliance timers. The cost to test a new design of a GM brake switch was several (tens of thousands) dollars.

In reality the very best information is right here on this site. The machines are used by a variety of operators and in various modes. Some will take heavy cuts of exotic woods, others will take light cuts of softwoods. The people here are in my opinion, some of the most qualified and honest appraisers of equipment available. Some like me are anal about the setup of machines, others don�t give a whit, but demand a quality output from a machine without any tweaking. Again IMHO, all will give you an honest answer to the best of their abilities. None are pressured by �advertisers� or have any pressure put on them by bosses to give �good� reports. Any problems (design flaws or manufacturing issues)in the equipment probably will be uncovered by more than one of the posters responding to our questions.

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#12

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thi

Charles Self

>You're right. The time involved makes it difficult, as does the space needed to provide reportage on the test.

It can take upwards of six weeks to test six or eight of the larger machines decently, as set up out of the box. To do a job on a long term test, the machines would all need to be in nearly daily use, for, at a rough guess, no less than six months, with a full year being a better choice.

So, who pays? I can tell you now, freelancers in the woodworking field are not getting rich. In fact, the freelance work has dwindled as magazines have increased staff. I don't believe ediotiral salaries are that great either, and I've heard rumors that the magazine profits would make a baby vampire...they suck, in other words. Readers already complain about the number of ads in relation to the text.

So, who pays?

Figure it out, let us know, and, particularly, let me know: I'd love to bring my English degree, writing experience...and, oh,yeah more than 50 years experience as a woodworker...to the task.

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#13

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thi

RichL

>Another aspect of machinery that reviewers don't address is parts availability. I've seen one blogger's comments that after several months of waiting for a part from the manufacturer, he gave up and bought the part from another manufacturer because the machines were essentially the same.

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#14

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thi

Earl Smith

>Looking at the thread of messages in response to machinery reviews, I couldn't stop myself from reading all of them. I wonder if it wouldn't be advantagious to allow us readers to place a response right in the thread box itself to be read in the next issue? I consider real life reviews much more reliable, and I rely on these reviews for most of my purchases.

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#15

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thi

Charles Self

>I think the parts availability situation has become critical only in the past five or so years, with 99% of tool production moved overseas. In the past Delta (for an example) had parts for its early Unisaws. Not all parts, but a goodly number for a tool approaching 63 or 64 at the turn of the century. I have to wonder, as I'm sure others do, how many of today's saw *makers* will be able to say the same in even a decade.

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#16

If Leigh dunked their Jigs in Cosmoline

Art Silva

>you would be in deep doo, doo Dave. Tee Hee.

Re: Are machinery reviews looking at the wrong thing?

#17

Re: Let's hear it for aluminum!

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

>Art, that would be one heckuva mess to try to clean up, wouldn't it? ;-)