Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Breathing protection

Posts

Breathing protection

#1

Breathing protection

Tom Dunlap in Atlanta

>Now that I have my shop setup for work I'll be doing more sanding. I have some thick 3M cup shaped masks and a couple of cartridge respirators.

What filters are getting high marks these days? How are they rated?

My Dad did lots of turning and sanding. He didn't wear good breathing protection and this had to add to the fibrosis of his lungs. My Dad taught me a lot of great things and I sure don't want to repeat his mistakes.

Re: Breathing protection

#2

Re: Breathing protection

Ells

>To be on the safe side, look for masks with filtering down to 0.3 micron (micrometer). Many folks try to collect it at the source, check out downdraft tables.

Ells

Re: Breathing protection

#3

Re: Breathing protection

Tom Dunlap in Atlanta

>The projects that I have ahead of me are large tree trunks and branches that need sanding. Way too big for a downdraft table. I will have a shop vac connected to any sanders that I can. The sanding will be outside since my storage unit is too small.

Setting a particulate size is important but the seal against the face is more important. If the seal is poor then chunks not microns will go into my lungs. I don't have a beard these days so that ups the effeciency.

On a similar note...earmuffs attentuation is compromised about 10% by using glasses. When I was wearing muffs I used ones with a higher attenuation to take up some of the discount. Hard to do that with air filters.

Re: Breathing protection

#4

Re: Breathing protection

kkaneoka

>Over the past few years I've become very sensitive to wood dust. Using N-95 rated masks has done wonders, just remember to take your mask off last, after you've vacuumed yourself off well and you're out of the shop or the dust has settled. I use a cartridge style 2 micron pleated filter on my dust collector that also works very well.

Re: Breathing protection

#5

Re: Breathing protection

Chuck Lenz

>It's not the chunks that will get you, it's the fine micron stuff that will eventually get you.

Re: Breathing protection

#6

Re: Breathing protection

Tom Dunlap in Atlanta

>I should have said..."chunks AND microns will go in my lungs."

You're right, it's the microns that do the damage.

Re: Breathing protection

#7

Re: Breathing protection

Pat Evans

>I'm not recommending an AFS as a substitute for a mask, but my portable AFS is a tremendous help. By placing the AFS in the immediate vicinity of any dust making operation, the air flow carries the vast majority of dust directly into the filter and away from me.

Re: Breathing protection

#8

Re: Breathing protection *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Tom,

Don't know what filters are the latest and greatest, but I've had good luck with the Moldex N95 particulate disposable respirator, especially with the vent as I wear glasses. I think the N95 designation refers to how good the filter is at filtering out small particles and is the designation to look for these days. I haven't price compared, but buy from Lab Safety Supply. They offer a very large selection and service has been good, at least for me. Their regular yearly catalog is HUGE.

I think (don't hold me to this) that FWW did a review on full-face respirators maybe a year ago or so. That might be helpful.

I try to attach my shop-vac to the sander when using it and that is a BIG help.

As a sidenote, I can't quite visualize sanding "large tree trunks and branches" with a normal shop sander 8-), but, hey, that's my problem not yours. Good luck.

Jim


Lab Safety Supply

Re: Breathing protection

#9

N95, N99, N100, P95, P99, P100 *LINK*

wilbur

>These are all NIOSH ratings for air filters. The N means that the filter traps dust. The P means that the filter traps dust and oil particles. 95, 99, and 100 means that the filter will trap 95%, 99%, and 99.97% of particles. P100 will give you the best coverage.

The feds have all the information you need:


NIOSH filter information

Re: Breathing protection

#10

One more point to consider

albertabob

>Although the Niosh ratings give us a gauge to the effectiveness of the filter materials they cannot estimate the bioload in the air around them.

Here is an example:

If you have 10 ounces of dust in your work shop that is either ambient (in the air) or on the surfaces, the filter material will only trap say 95% of the dust that comes in contact with it, (or 99% as the filters vary).

So if your mask collected say 1/2 ounce of dust there would still be 9-1/2 ounces ready to jump inside you the moment you disturb them.

My habit is to have two separate dust filters running during any sanding type operation and to leave both on timers for a 2 hour run after I clean up the shop for the day.

As Ellis pointed out earlier trapping dust at the source is the best solution but ambient dust is the most difficult to trap due to it's tiny sizes.

As an observation from visiting several shops overthe years, central dust collectors and cyclones have little impact on the submicron particles and may even contribute to their dispersion into the air.

So,wear a quality mask,use a dust collector,downdraft table and ambient dust filters and please do blow out our shop at least once a week to remove the settled dust.

p.s. if possible don't wear your street clothes in the shop.

-- Climbing down of the hand madesoap box now.

Bob

Re: Breathing protection

#11

JL

Re: Breathing protection

JL

>In addition to considering a reasonable dust mask consider some other options. Your work may not fit on a downdraft table. OK - what else can you do?

JDS, Jet and other manufacturers do make their "air cleaners". I plan on buying one for my new shop. Will it get all the dust - no.

How about using a stand mounted dust collection hose? I bought one (a stand) with a 4" hose connection several years ago. I had originally intended it for use just behind my lathe. I found it useful for sucking up dust in sanding operations (hand and power) and other things. Just a thought.