Tenoning Jig
Robert Egbert
>Does anyone know of a good hi quality Tenon Jig for a table saw?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Tenoning Jig
Robert Egbert
>Does anyone know of a good hi quality Tenon Jig for a table saw?
Re: Tenoning Jig
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
>American Woodworker magazine #123, September 2006 has an article on tenoning jigs. They tested 7 jigs and found them all to work very well. Prices range from $60 to $110.
Re: Tenoning Jig
Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana
>I looked at several at tool shows and at Indianapolis woodworking stores. I could see very minor differences in any except the price. Non of the differences appeared to affect the accuracy of the units. I purchased mine on sale at Rockler for (as I remember) around $50. I did measure the unit alignment using a dial indicator and found the clamping face was not parallel to the bar that fits the slot in the TS. With the indicator clamped to the table the clamping face was closer to the blade by about .020". I took it apart and found some bolts were not properly tightened. I tightened the bolts while aligning the unit (run out now is less than .001") and have been quite happy with the performance since. The guide bar is slightly undersized (.002 ~ .003") so I have to maintain pressure against one side of the slot when cutting. I thought about correcting this by "dinging or swelling" the guide bar and stoning it to size. However, I have found it comes in handy as I can adjust the tenon thickness by .002 to .005" depending on how I bias the fixture when cutting. I would expect you may find the same issue with any unit you buy, so I would look at the sale prices and expect to align the unit after you get it.
make vs buy
Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's
>I'm not big on actually making to many jigs as I would rather make stuff. but in this case the cost benefit of buy vs make are in favor of making it. I have not seen a commercial Jig that makes me go WOW!
there are many plans from the simple to the complex and really are just as accurate and probably better built. although, in my my mind, making tenons that way is not as safe for long work pieces. I may be biased by my short ceiling. a dado blade, router or bandsaw make quick work of them. a horizontal router table is about as slick as it gets.
I plan on doing them buy hand this summer. I'm twisted :).
Delta 34-183 Tenoning Jig
Lee Schierer, McKean, PA
>I have the Delta 34-183 Tenoning Jig andd am very happy with it. I had to do some inital adjustment and alignment, but it has never moved and does a great job of holding wood while making tenon cuts.
Lee
Funny you should say that…
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>> …in this case the cost benefit of buy vs make are in favor of making it.
Just today I was reviewing this season's The New Yankee Workshop episodes as I transfer them onto DVD, and while viewing Episode 1909, Table Saw 101 Part 2, I saw Norm showing his 34-184 (used to be a '182 or 3—he even started out with the heavy and expensive 34-172 which David Marks also uses) and saying, “don't even think about building one. They are so inexpensive it's worth it to just buy one.”
I've long shared that feeling as I've seen various iterations of this thread over the years. Lots of build-yourself-one sentiment, but it's never struck me that way. I'm with your initial thought that I'd rather be making something than making something to make something.
Rod
Re: Funny you should say that�
Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's
>I guess my thinking was that since I had a cross cut sled all i need is two square pieces of wood and a few c clamps. maybe a toggle clamp.
nothing elaborate stuff from my scrap bin that i could put together in the time it would take to drive to Rockler.
Re: Funny you should say that…
Glenn Madsen near San Francisco
>I only drive 6 minutes to Rockler, so factor that in...
The home made tenon sled could NOT have all the degrees of freedom that my Delta tenoner has. Every time I use it, I find new ways to adjust that sucker. Not always a good thing.
I really wouldn't want to build my own version.
Re: Delta 34-183 Tenoning Jig
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
>That's the one I have, too. Mine is about fifteen years old, and I've only had to futz with it once - mainly to clean out the accumulated sawdust from the threads.
Not much to say about it except "it does what it's supposed to do."
Re: Tenoning Jig
Ray SW Ohio
>I bought mine at Woodcraft, they were on sale when I did. I'm glad I have it. They're around $90 right now.
My wallet...
Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's
>would hate to be that close a woodworking store. I would be in there a few times a week :)